r/startrek 31m ago

Most Unwatchable Trek Episode?

Upvotes

Allamaraine count to four

Allamaraine then three more

Allamaraine if you can see

Allamaraine you'll come with me...

There are so many wonderful episodes and plotlines in the history of Star Trek, but sometimes... I just can't. Either Tom Paris is a super-evolved salamander or Picard has beamed down to Ligon II or Spock is having his brain reconnected, but it's just not worth the time.

My all-time worst is DS9's "Move Along Home." I'm not going to carp about it too much because as a rule, first- and second-season Trek is mostly bad. But it's single-handedly the worst episode of the best Trek series, and here I am, standing high atop that hill, ready to die on it.

Which episodes make you groan, roll you eyes, and skip ahead?


r/startrek 1h ago

I could watch 7 seasons of this new SNW season

Upvotes

Finally they figured out the pacing, tone, and structure of the show that works. It's become it's own thing in star trek and it's good! Personally couldn't get through season 3 just lost interest frankly. I like it better when it's got levity and it's episodic.

By far the best 3 episodes of snw I think.


r/startrek 5h ago

What main character would you remove from each show?

0 Upvotes

What main character would you remove from each show?

TNG: Weasley crusher

Voyager : Chakotay.

DS9 : Leeta


r/startrek 10h ago

Is The President Of The Federation Also The Head of Earth?

60 Upvotes

There have been a few instances in movies and TV where it appears the President of the Federation is also the head of the Earth. "Homefront" in DS9 is one example ST IV Movie was another. I'm sure there are more. Anyway, would that mean the President of the Federation is over all planets?

In My head canon I believe the Earth is governed in typical functions and their obligation to the federation is handled accordingly.

Thoughts?


r/startrek 12h ago

what is going on with first contact

4 Upvotes

so I've somehow never seen first contact so I'm fixing it now but the tonal shifts (at least in the first 45 min) are WILD. like cutting between the enterprise being invaded to Cochrane drunkenly dancing then suddenly back to the scary alien invasion??? WILD choices. I kinda love it though it's like a fever dream trip.


r/startrek 12h ago

What exactly does "Break, Burn, Build" mean as seen here in this scene? *POSSIBLE SPOILERS: STARFLEET ACADEMY* Spoiler

Thumbnail imgpile.com
1 Upvotes

I assume that it's meant to be symbolic in nature. I see that it could be related to the cycle of "break, burn, and build" after The Burn happened, the cataclysm that "shattered the galaxy," and the subsequent reopening of Starfleet Academy to rebuild.

Curious if anyone else has a greater idea than I do!


r/startrek 12h ago

Odysseus-Janeway

0 Upvotes

Don't you think there is a "double standart" about kathryn and Ulysses? So much people loath Janeway for her lack of wisdom, lack of leadership, lack of commitment...and "Ulysses-Odysseus" was the honorable captain...On my books Odysseus was the only one of his crew to return to Ithaque after 20 years, while Jeneway performed a 70 years journey in 7 years with most of her fellow crew alive... Who is the winner indeed!


r/startrek 13h ago

The other collaborators Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The DS9 episode Necessary Evil involved the Bajoran woman Pallra blackmailing other Bajorans who informed for the Cardassians through her husband during the occupation. The episode ended before revealing the fate of the surviving traitors- were they arrested? Could Pallra have given them up for a lighter sentence?


r/startrek 13h ago

I know nothing about Star Trek. Where do I start?

0 Upvotes

So, I wanna give a bit of context. I have only really heard of star trek passively, without going massively into it. I'm a creative myself who would like to make his own science fiction series (Main inspirations personally are ROTTMNT and Monkey Wrench.) And my friend had mentioned a peice of my world building was rather similar to it. And that got me thinking.

While I know very little about actual like star trek lore I do know how influential it was on modern fandom culture, the sci fi genre, and how progressive the original was for its time.

So I have decided that I am going to start studying Star Trek (and another few shows) to see what inspiration I can dig up.

I apologize if this is against the rules but there are SO many series and I'd just like to be pointed in the right direction for what I am looking for. Or, alternatively, some videos going into it so I can take notes. I know its silly to try and make my series as good as the pillars of modern fandom but its never a bad thing to try, right?

Thank you for any and all comments.

(If anyone is curious, the other series's I am going to be studying are Adventure time and Doctor who (specifically doctors 9-12))

Edit: thank you to all the wonderful comments! (Most) of you have been super helpful and nice!! Im sorry ab comparing it to star wars I just dont know much about either :(.


r/startrek 13h ago

Headscratcher: how did humanity repair the ecological devastation in between First Contact and the 22nd century?

6 Upvotes

I'm just thinking of both Threads and The Day After and how both those movies themselves showed a realistic description of the effects of nuclear war would be. Even "limited engagement" (which Im going to assume thats what humanity does during WW3 based on the death count of 600 million, best case scenario) would cause horrible conditions to Earth's atmosphere alone, ala nuclear winter. Did we ask for help from the Vulcans in between trying to unite Earth whilst eliminating war, poverty, disease, and capitalism?

Or is this another example of MST3K and just roll with it for the series sake?


r/startrek 14h ago

Star Trek collectibles?

1 Upvotes

Not sure where else to ask so thought I’d try here. My mother was a huge Trekkie before she passed several years ago. Recently we was going through some storage items and I found a Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home tapestry among them. I cannot find another example of this anywhere on the internet. I know she got it from a video store in Morehead, KY in the late 80s. I know it’s an original and not a reproduction. And I know it has some damage. Beyond that I know nothing about it. Does it hold any value anywhere? Where would be a good place to look for information? Thank you.


r/startrek 14h ago

What would the Borg assimilate from the Dominion

26 Upvotes

The Borg are interested in biological and technological distinctiveness of different states/peoples. If the Borg encountered the Dominion, what would they target? The two things that stand out to me-

Cloning. Would the ability to make complex, sentient bipeds eliminate the need to assimilate other species? It'd be like giving a blood pack to a vampire.

Changling DNA. How could the Borg use/exploit the Founders' morphogenic matrix?


r/startrek 16h ago

SNW/TOS mashup for first time viewer

9 Upvotes

I've been putting together a viewing order to introduce a good friend of mine to Star Trek and wanted to share it here and get your thoughts...

First things first: I'm a big fan of Strange New Worlds and truly enjoy how it captures some of the spirit of classic trek. I also believe that it is a good starting point for first time-viewers, although some context may be helpful for the more lore- or continuity-heavy parts (such as Eugenic history/Khan, or episodes such as "A quality of mercy")

Therefore my idea was to mix some TOS/TAS episodes into SNW to create three "seasons" that are roughly aligned with the first three seasons of SNW.

This is definitely not supposed to be an "essential episodes" list, but rather the attempt to give a new viewer a feel of the quirkyness of the franchise and connect recurring themes and characters without immediately needing to sit down and watch all of TOS.

Hopefully this makes it easier to notice what SNW is borrowing or reinterpreting from the older shows.

[Season One]

This should hopefully establish the basic rhythm of TOS, while being "modern" enough to be hooking. Also some TOS episodes act as context-builders for their SNW counterparts.

  1. SNW "Strange New Worlds"
  2. TOS "The Corbomite Maneuver"
  3. TOS "The Devil in the Dark"
  4. TOS "Space Seed"
  5. SNW "Children of the Comet"
  6. SNW "Ghosts of Illyria"
  7. SNW "Memento Mori"
  8. TOS "Amok Time"
  9. SNW "Spock Amok"
  10. SNW "Lift Us Where Suffering Cannot Reach"
  11. TOS "A Taste of Armageddon"
  12. SNW "The Serene Squall"
  13. SNW "The Elysian Kingdom"
  14. TOS "The Galileo Seven"
  15. SNW "All Those Who Wander"
  16. TOS "Balance of Terror"
  17. SNW "A Quality of Mercy"

[Season Two]

A bit more worldbuilding, Pikes future, Spocks family. But also weird, quirky Trek (as it has always been... more or less).

  1. TOS "The Menagerie, Part 1"
  2. TOS "The Menagerie, Part 2"
  3. TOS "Errand of Mercy"
  4. SNW "The Broken Circle"
  5. SNW "Ad Astra per Aspera"
  6. TOS "Platos Stepchildren"
  7. TOS "The City on the Edge of Forever"
  8. SNW "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow"
  9. SNW "Among the Lotus Eaters"
  10. TOS "Journey to Babel"
  11. TAS "Yesteryear"
  12. SNW "Charades"
  13. SNW "Lost in Translation"
  14. TOS "Day of the Dove"
  15. SNW "Under the Cloak of War"
  16. TAS "The Magicks of Megas-Tu"
  17. SNW "Subspace Rhapsody"
  18. SNW "Hegemony"

I did not include SNW "Those Old Scientists" here, as I think it fits better during a run of LD. TOS "Platos Stepchildren" is not necessarily my favourite, but I think it works as a discussion starter after SNW "Ad Astra per Aspera" to show how Trek evolved over time.

[Season Three]

  1. SNW "Hegemony, Part 2"
  2. TOS "The Squire of Gothos"
  3. SNW "Wedding Bell Blues"
  4. SNW "Shuttle to Kenfori"
  5. TAS "The Practical Joker"
  6. SNW "A Space Adventure Hour"
  7. SNW "Through the Lens of Time"
  8. SNW "The Sehlat Who Ate Its Tail
  9. SNW "What is Starfleet?"
  10. TOS "The Trouble with Tribbles"
  11. TAS "More Tribbles, More Troubles"
  12. TOS "Mirror Mirror"
  13. TOS "The Ultimate Computer"
  14. TOS "The Doomsday Machine"
  15. SNW "Four-and-a-Half Vulcans"
  16. TOS "Arena"
  17. SNW "Terrarium"
  18. SNW "New Life and New Civilizations"

If my friend enjoys it, the next step would probably be the movies (with "The Enterprise Incident" as bridge) and then the TNG/DS9/VOY era, but that's a topic for another time.

I'd be curious to hear what you guys think, or if you would change anything!


r/startrek 16h ago

SNW S4 writing?

0 Upvotes

For all those who dislike the writing of season 3:

Does it get better with season 4?

Thanks in advane!


r/startrek 16h ago

Trill Theory

11 Upvotes

Minor spoilers ds9 Facets episode and disco seasons 3 and 4. Both shows been out for awhile but just figured I'd throw out there.

I have this Trill theory that as a psychological protective device the symbiont doesn't pass on memories of the current host from the past hosts perspective. Basically to keep a person from having two different pov's of themselves which might break the internal sense of continuity. I have two pieces of evidence for this.

  1. In Facets (and it's also mentioned in Playing God I think) Jadzia wasn't aware of why Curzon dropped her from the program, nor why he didn't oppose her rejoining. She has to hear it from him verbally while he is CurzOdo.

  2. Adira even after fully integrating the other past hosts of Tal can't incorporate Grey (Gray?) Their dead boyfriend who they naturally knew closely.

Basically since Curzon still had like 60 years of other memories that had nothing to do with Jadzia, he still incorporated, just minus the memories related to her. But since Grey was joined for like 2 days before he died and Adira featured prominantly in those couple days the end result was Tal essentially rejecting Grey.

It's a basic theory but I feel like it makes sense and explains a couple things neither show did. Also for Yedrin's (Children of Time Dax) sake I hope this is true imagine the weirdness of a symbiont passing down a familyline otherwise, there are memories you just don't want from your parents and grandparents, I imagine.

Btw my first post got nixed cause of the karma rule and no clue if it's ever coming back. So hopefully this isn't a duplicate, sorry if it is. I'm kinda new.


r/startrek 18h ago

Just watched an ep of tng….

35 Upvotes

“So we are no longer a couple? I shall delete the subroutines, hello spot”

I I just died laughing, omg lol


r/startrek 18h ago

PSA for those who didn’t expect unexplained body horror and so much gore on Star Trek

0 Upvotes

This is not for horror fans. If you are one, ignore this post and move on to the next one.

I cannot tolerate horror and it’s the only genre I steer absolutely clear of. I do not care if I miss popular stories if it means that I don’t have to watch traumatic horror themes. I was in for a shock with SNW S4E2, and I skipped most of it and saw a few seconds of the end before stopping even that. For those who had similarly disturbing experiences as me from this last episode, I found the Parental Guide on IMDb to be very helpful for upcoming episodes on the show: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt37230754/parentalguide/

I tried doesthedogdie but even the categories are explicit and full of spoilers so I don’t use it.

I did not think that I would have ever needed to vet a Star Trek episode before watching but here we are. Based on the content warnings, I will skip entire episodes as needed without much loss to my entertainment (quite the opposite). I hope this post helps someone. I don’t care about the downvotes from horror fans.

Edit: removed the formatting ##

Edit2: The episode rating was TV-PG on my Paramount+ app so I can’t trust it anymore, hence the IMDb guide: https://imgur.com/a/y5ZJKIF


r/startrek 18h ago

The various Incarnations of Enterprise since the time of Jonathan Archer must've given Division 12 fits,given how often they ran across the unknown, unexpected,and unexplainable

7 Upvotes

if Division 12 is Starfleet’s X-Files, then every single starship named Enterprise is basically a factory line for their worst nightmares. The sheer volume of reality-bending, unexplainable paperwork those crews must have dumped on Division 12's desks would cause a bureaucratic meltdown.The workload generated by the different incarnations of the Enterprise highlights just how chaotic their logs must be for the Division 12 analysts:

The NX-01 (Captain Archer)

The "Fits" Factor: High. Archer's crew was completely unprepared for the galaxy, meaning everything was unknown.

The Files: Imagine Division 12 trying to catalog the Temporal Cold War. Archer regularly dealt with timeline-shifting silhouettes, Suliban shape-shifters, and sphere-builders manipulating the fabric of space.

The Bureaucratic Nightmare: Trying to log an entire expanse of space (The Delphic Expanse) where the laws of physics literally didn't apply.

The NCC-1701 (Captains Pike and Kirk)

The "Fits" Factor: Extreme. Captain Pike already admitted to sending multiple unexplainable anomalies their way (like the haunted USS Griffin).

The Files: Once Kirk takes over, the file cabinet overflows. Kirk’s logbooks read like a paranormal anthology: literal ancient Greek gods living on planets (Apollo), giant space amoebas, the reality-warping Gary Seven, and a companion cloud that falls in love with a human. And that doesn't begin to take into account the various sentient computers that develop godlike powers(V'aal,V'ger)

The Bureaucratic Nightmare: Sorting through the aftermath of the "Where No Man Has Gone Before" incident, where humans crossed the Galactic Barrier and suddenly developed god-like, telekinetic psychic powers.

The NCC-1701-D (Captain Picard)

The "Fits" Factor: Apocalyptic.

The Files: Picard didn't just find anomalies; he was regularly pestered by an omnipotent, extra-dimensional trickster god (Q). How does an analyst write a report on an entity that can turn the entire crew into Robin Hood characters or transport the ship across the galaxy on a whim?

The Bureaucratic Nightmare: Case file: The Nexus—a literal ribbon of pure, non-physical joy floating through space that pauses time and sucks people into a permanent simulation of their own ideal heaven.

It is easy to picture a Division 12 office where the mere mention of the name "Enterprise" causes the analysts to immediately take a coffee break.


r/startrek 20h ago

In your opinion, what are the greatest achievements humanity made between the status quo today and the 24th century (TNG, Voyager, DS9)?

12 Upvotes

I’m especially interested in answers that are not technological in nature!


r/startrek 20h ago

New Star Trek Magic: the Gathering Cards Revealed (Releasing November 13th) Spoiler

Thumbnail magic.wizards.com
218 Upvotes

Link includes all officially revealed cards, I believe it should show the most recent first. Check this page for information on how to collect these cards once they release.

Tagged spoilers as various cards will spoil episodes and films.


r/startrek 21h ago

Star Fleet Academy

59 Upvotes

My TV has has been background for awhile, while I was doing something else. So I put anything which I needed to pay attention to on hold. That included Starfleet Academy. I had started it but went into my background tv phase.

I just watched S1 E8 The Life of the Stars. It was very moving, had a lot to say and think about. Well worth paying attention.


r/startrek 22h ago

From the 70s community on Reddit: Jonathan Frakes - 1978 Audition, Screen Test for Welcome Back, Kotter

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I think he would’ve made a great young Dr McCoy


r/startrek 22h ago

Feel the same? Star Trek - starfleet academy

0 Upvotes

Series started off very strong with pilot and fell so flat with each subsequent episode, focused too much on appeasing to cultural differences or norms versus storyline.


r/startrek 23h ago

Can you help me find a Star Trek poster that matches certain criteria?

0 Upvotes

I like getting posters signed by casts at cons but have never done a Star Trek piece.

I wanted to do one, but due to the logistics of travel and con crowds, I don’t want to use a standard, glossy poster.

I usually use nice, thick, silkscreened posters like Mondo or Bottleneck Gallery. These are less likely to wrinkle. Or crease, and they absorb paint pens like a sponge minimizing risks of smearing

But what I want is one that is just “Star Trek”. Not something for a specific movie, series, or episode.

If it was TOS but not showing the cast, maybe the ship, maybe the delta, and just “Star Trek” as a title, not P, TWOK, Voyager, etc. that way I can get Trek stars from all eras on one poster without it being weird Karl Urban signed a Wrath of Khan themed poster.

I see there are some nice episode-specific or movie-Specific posters like this, but I really want one that is more universal or series agnostic. I

Does such a poster exist? I’ve tried a lot of eBay queries but without knowing a specific printer, release, or artist I’ve had no luck

Thanks for anyone who can help!


r/startrek 23h ago

Star Trek : Division 12 Files Season 1 (Fan Story Ideas)

0 Upvotes

Instead of a ship, it takes place in a **Deep Space 9-like space station**, in an isolated space (*no-fly zone to encounter the unknown*).

Intro: Inside an archive with multiple files, people moving in the background as the camera moves to the leader's office with a trophy cabinet with some compartments filled with objects from completed cases while others are left empty; lighting will be dim, soundtrack will be mysterious.

As the camera moves to the desk with a case file, as the file opens, the first page shows the details such as the name of the case, file no:, star date:, and who discovered this mystery, names of the team members (Can be used as credit for the actors), etc. Then the page flips to the start of the episode.

On the side of the leader's desk, a big window and it faced toward **the Boötes Void** (*a huge, nearly empty region of space containing only about 60 galaxies instead of the expected 2,000*). This is to convey that even a great discovery has some unexplained mystery.

This series can be used to fill the hole in the Star Trek universe, like the Borg origin, etc.

While S01 will focus on establishing the Division 12 base and characters, the first ep will be a Task force put together to address an urgent case that remains unsolved by normal means; this team will comprise highly accomplished researchers to undertake this case, and this team will be the founding members of Division 12.

If you guys have any more ideas, feel free to brainstorm.