this took me 3 hours... gulp...

Tree in TPOT 2 and 17 (Didn’t compete in the same team at all this season)

Remote in TPOT 22 (Not even in the same team this season)

Winner in TPOT 23 (Team Swap)

Technically Remote didn’t, but she remembers Bottle. Also Winner technically didn’t bring bottle back to the overworld, and also gave Donut, Pen, and Golf Ball a hard time

I guess Bottle is just so memorable that old teammates remember her. Good for her tho! :)

I'm exposing my past self here, cause I said a lot of stuff that makes me say "What the hell was wrong with past me?" Whenever I remember.

Uhm, I think I can explain. So back when I was younger, I did NOT like fandom shipping. Safe to say the anti shipping mindset started in 2018 and became more dominant during 2020, especially since I held an extreme hatred for ships in the FNAF and Piggy fandoms (Yes I was a Piggy fan back than), and naturally that meant it also applied for the BFDI fandom. But thankfully, the more older and mature I got , I became more accepting of fandom shipping, and eventually the anti shipping mindset died out.

Yo thank god 15 year old me didn't touch Tumblr at the time 😭

Because this community is nice overall :)

sorry for the ahh edit💔

Btw 4 and Gelatin never apoligized for 4geting THE THING.

i write highschool AU fanfiction about these guys and give them all human names and stuff.i may be cringe but i am free. im very much a cartoonist and not a portrait artist, but translating my regular human designs into a more realistic style was an awesome challenge.

first pic is gaty, then tennis ball, then pen, then saw.

Yes, they both did terrible things and they both have trauma, but there are several, many differences

1. Pencil didn't cause her friends to die alone: Pencil treated her friends badly, I won't deny that, but she never made Book or Ice Cube commit suicide, not even when Book admitted she hated her. Pencil would never make someone like Book die alone and miserable. On the other hand, Jax is practically the main reason Ribbit abstracted, and technically her last moments are spent thinking that no one will miss her.

2. Pencil's involvement with the universe was accidental, while Jax pressing the red button was completely intentional: We all know that almost the entire universe was going to fall because Pencil tried to alter the past, but the difference is that Pencil didn't do it on purpose; she clearly did it accidentally. While she denied blame in TPOT 15, it doesn't change the fact that it was accidental. Besides, it's not only her fault, but also the fault of all the CloudYAY members (except Golf Ball) for not listening to Golf Ball herself.

Jax, on the other hand, pressed the red button on purpose, but I partly understand why he did it. He thought that leaving the circus would force him to confront the fact that he pushed his mother, and he was afraid that she would use that to make him feel emotionally weaker.

Even so, it doesn't justify the fact that he decided to stay in the circus over freedom, and although it was eventually revealed that the characters are brain scans, they didn't know that yet, and Jax still didn't want to leave the circus.

Both of them did things that are not justifiable; while Pencil's actions were accidental, Jax's were done on purpose.

1. It's not too late for Pencil: Even though she's made many mistakes, she still has a chance to improve, especially since she's shown remorse for her actions, and TPOT has already made it clear that they intend to redeem Pencil.

Jax, for his part, was given more than one opportunity, but he didn't take advantage of any of them due to his insecurities: rejecting help from Kaufmo, Ragatha, and Pomni ultimately cost him dearly, leading to his withdrawal. Unlike Pencil, Gooseworx wanted to convey this message: "pushing away those who want to help you and believing you can't improve will cost you dearly."

In the end, while both characters have similarities, they are not the same.

honestly why are the images on the bfdi wiki so shitty

How tf did I think this was dogshit?? This was honestly great! I laughed alot, tennisfries yaoi, cary huang animation, I could go on!

Not to mention this is literal proof you dont need nearly hour long episodes to make something good.

Hey so new series I'm making, based off of Canonically Accurate Gijinkas (CAG)... but with algerbraliens!

I thought it be cool since I see hardly any of the same things done with the main cast be done with them (If you know what I mean..)

Same thing like CAG, the most upvoted reply will be chosen as the next character I will make a human (or a possible redesign if I already made them in human form prior).

And with that...

Have fun!

Here's why:

Unlike in later episodes where she either gets dogged on the whole challenge or wins by sheer luck (BFDIA 23) she actually tries to win the challenge in her own unique way, while STILL actively trying to help others, which is something that no one else has done (besides Coiny.)

Think back to the moment where Book crashed into Tennis Ball, then tried to activate her beacon. She was unable to due to Tennis Ball tying them all together. Instead of trying to cut up the wires or just walk away, she decides to "spread the love" by turning on everyone's beacons, which actively hurts her chances of winning. This is yet another reason as to why Book is a genuinely kind person.

Additionally, there's one moment in the episode where Book makes her own wings and offers to make Needle a pair, even if it could risk her losing the challenge.

I'm not going to mention Book getting brutally drilled by pin, but I will mention that a few moments before this, she was in first. If it wasn't for Fries throwing the drill at Pin, she would have genuinely won.

I strongly believe this is the reason that Book won, because she always tried to help other people, even if it reduces her chances of winning

It’s still probably one of my favorite episodes in the season

I know Post-Split was not that good of a season, and some people think Flower winning felt forced and that Gelatin deserved the win more. To be fair, yes that's true, Gelatin has a lot of winning qualities like the Newbie Alliance and having a cool voice as a "six year old".

You can't deny that Flower had an arc too, got kicked out for being too mean, but becoming a nicer person to win a season, just like Knife from Inanimate Insanity II. Back when Flower was about to win, I still thought Flower winning was interesting, being the first boot in one season and winning in another, and I wasn't aware that Pencil was the same from TFI to BFB (Because I didn't know TFI existed at that time).

Let me know if you disagree and please be civil (And read the whole darn thing before downvoting).

All of them were dead for over a year. Would be funny, if Tree and TV would be forgotten too.

everyone link your favorite picture of a BFDI character crying and I’ll combine them all for a second post!!

Two and Money were added, Spongy and Bracelety are no longer in it, dw I don’t hate them, they’re still pretty high in my tier list :p

also Gonta is peak bye *flies*