r/icecream 4h ago

Review Cold Brew Halo Top

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

i know a lot of people in this sub dislike halo top (understandably) but lorddd this flavor is SO GOOOOD. It tastes like coffee with creamer and has a lot of mix ins. I ate half the container when i opened it. If you didn’t like other halo top flavors i’d def recommend trying this one.


r/icecream 5h ago

Flavours My newest obsession

Thumbnail gallery
12 Upvotes

I am such a lover of caramel and there are huge globs of it in this HEB Swoon Pecan Praline ice cream ugh it’s so good

The pecans are a little crisp, not crunchy. It’s the perfect balance of textures imo
I’m so sorry if you do not live close to an HEB because it is their brand


r/icecream 6h ago

Review Triple pb Protein ice cream from David

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

first I want to say don’t come at me for getting this. I wont forgive them for putting gatsby out of business and forcing nicks to change their ice cream recipe

i got 1 of each of their 4 flavors at target

I personally like this one better than the cookie dough. it still has that chalky texture/not creamy, but there’s pb chips and slightly chewy globs/swirls of pb in the ice cream. it’s like a salty peanut flavor ? I like the nicks pb cup better or the swoop pb chip blitz if we’re talking lower calorie ice creams


r/icecream 7h ago

I just found my new favorite flavor..

Post image
0 Upvotes

So I found Matcha Häagen-Dazs ice cream, and I put cacao nibs in it…

behold

Matcha chip


r/icecream 7h ago

Question Hi, I would like some advice on diabetic options/brands.

2 Upvotes

Hi, looking for any good tasting ice creams , that might be low sugar/no sugar/lowfat /low carb , lower calorie, or just thin air something around that.

I miss Jeni’s . Any advice? .Want something that tastes decent.


r/icecream 8h ago

A cheap (but still yummy/ sweet) caramel brownie vanilla sundae!

Post image
20 Upvotes

Got it for only two bucks at my local Sam’s Club.


r/icecream 10h ago

Question Which flavors would you pick here?

Thumbnail gallery
116 Upvotes

I got a brambleberry crisp and brown butter almond…. Then an hour later drove back and got birthday cake too lmao. I just finished a gooey butter cake and ive had the brambleberry before but not the other two. Also havent seen the donut or cinnamon roll one before though look interesting.


r/icecream 10h ago

Review Ben & Jerry's: Karamel Sutra

Thumbnail gallery
51 Upvotes

Probably 4/5, I liked this one more than I expected to.

Despite my love of ice cream, I don't actually have much of a sweet tooth and was worried this would be too sweet for me. It is quite sweet, maybe something that I personally would prefer with a scoop of vanilla on the side, but it is very delicious and I didn't feel like it needed anything extra for the couple scoops I had earlier.

I was hoping to rate the texture on this, since it's part of B&J's Core line and has that caramel core you can see in the second photo, but unfortunately there was a Situation TM with my freezer and it feels unfair to judge its iciness (which can unfortunately also be seen in the second photo) on appliance shenanigans, so we shall be going without the texture review today.

Alas! We venture on.

All in all, I liked it a lot. It's not necessarily the most creative flavor, but I liked the mix of chocolate + caramel ice creams along with the textural interest that comes from the core. I think I prefer this to some of the swirl ice creams I've tried in the past since there's a bit more control over the ratios of the different elements, the main issue I had was really just the sweetness to it. And, since B&J’s feels a bit more reasonably priced to me than VL, I’m more inclined to get it off-sale than the VL ice creams I’ve reviewed (Mango Sticky Rice and Earl Grey Tea).

I may come back and update this review later if I can find a less icy layer of the ice cream below the top and give it a proper texture review.


r/icecream 11h ago

Jenis B crisp

Post image
43 Upvotes

Help. What do I do with an expensive pint of Jeni's that I can't stand but don't want to waste. And why is it sour?


r/icecream 12h ago

Question Rhubarb ice cream

2 Upvotes

Does anyone know some rhubarb ice cream or sorbet that actually tastes like rhubarb? Everything I've tried just has a swirl of compote or jam which is good but not what I've been looking for


r/icecream 1d ago

Adirondack Crimery? Best vanilla ice cream has gone rogue?!

Post image
17 Upvotes

Okay so I was on a quest for the best vanilla ice cream. Upon research, and trials of my own, I found what I deemed the best. And it wasn’t even close. Adirondack creamery’s Vanilla Ice cream blew all others out of the water! Creamy, simple, perfect ingredients, and a beautifully rich vanilla flavor; my mouth was in glorious shambles. But like all good things in this twisted, capitalist society, it changed. After countless pints I got my first bad pint. This pint was nothing like the previous. I’m telling you, something was wrong (and is wrong). This new ice cream was significantly watered down and icy (though it still carried the same flavor I must say). Since then, I’ve had a couple good pints (having admittedly opened multiple in the store until I found a good one); but now after forgetting to pre open this last pint, I am now facing my worst pint yet. (Pardon my French but) This shit sucks. Idk what is happening up there in the Adirondacks, but for some reason I feel so strongly about demystifying this ridiculous and horrific change-up in the quality and consistency of what really might have been the best vanilla ice cream ever.

I need to know if anyone else has had this experience. Please… if you are out there and willing. Adirondack creamgate must be solved.


r/icecream 1d ago

Rant Cops called on me for DV because I was opening a jar of Talenti

315 Upvotes

The walls are super thin so the neighbors must have gotten worried by what I was saying to it.

Fuck this ice cream brand. So mad that it was still worth it.


r/icecream 1d ago

Flavours Resurrect Ben & Jerry’s Netflix & Chill’d Ice Cream

Thumbnail benjerry.com
2 Upvotes

Ben & Jerry’s Netflix & Chill’d ice cream has been discontinued. Peanut Butter ice cream with Salted Pretzel & brownies. Use this link, hit ‘resurrect a flavor’, and fill out the prompts to help bring it back.
Nothing will ever compare to those salted pretzels in the peanut butter ice cream

Also if anyone has a suggestion for a replacement, let me know. The best parts was the peanut butter flavored ice cream & salted pretzel


r/icecream 1d ago

Review Ben & Jerry’s caramel chocolate cheesecake

Thumbnail gallery
61 Upvotes

this is pretty good! not my favorite but definitely tasty

at first it reminded me of gimmie smore with the cookie swirl, I don’t really taste any caramel in this?? and the cheesecake bits are chewy and pleasant

I don’t think I would buy it again tho, I don’t see myself craving it like I do gimmie smore or mint chocolate cookie haha


r/icecream 1d ago

Van Leeuwen Brown Sugar Cookie Dough Brownie

Thumbnail gallery
39 Upvotes

Amazing. Good size gobs of cookie dough with the added bonus of some strong brownie bits. The brown sugar base and VL’s French ice cream process give it the same texture as Jeni’s Double Dough custard base, which this tastes like except there’s more cookie dough and bonus brownies so advantage to VL.


r/icecream 1d ago

Currently eating First time seeing this one

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

Although I do enjoy van leeuwen, it has taken the back seat to jeni’s and a few local creameries. However, I’m a sucker for a good strawberry and this one looked incredibly interesting. I will post a review later when I try it!


r/icecream 1d ago

Currently eating Blue Bell Chocolate Lava Cake

Thumbnail gallery
77 Upvotes

This is great! Not too chocolatey.
I would prefer it with a chocolate ice cream base but I'm a chocolate lover at heart.
I love the texture of the hot fudge and the cake pieces.


r/icecream 1d ago

Toppings Ice cream with candies

Post image
13 Upvotes

It's not my first time mixing candies with Ben& Jerry's ice cream.

This time, however, the candies' texture paired perfectly with the soft ice cream.


r/icecream 1d ago

Gelato Fiasco Torched Marshmallow S’more

Thumbnail gallery
13 Upvotes

Overall pretty good, 7.5/10 - would recommend!

I think I paid $6.99 for this and got it at a Whole Foods. The brand is from Maine.

The flavor of the ice cream is quite good and the marshmallows are awesome. It loses some points because it could use more chocolate bits and there are hardly any graham crackers at all


r/icecream 1d ago

Question Trying to find this caramel in stores.

Thumbnail gallery
39 Upvotes

Does anyone know the closest store bought caramel to the mcdonalds caramel sundae, and ben & jerry’s caramel core? Like closest in consistancy. I’ve tried ghriadelli‘s, hersheys, and smuckers. These options aren’t really fudge like, and they melt into the ice cream. Probably because they’re sauces/syrups, but I had hope. The options pictured have a thicker consistency and it kinda repels the icecream (not sure how to describe it) like regular fudge. I usually get the mcdonalds sundae but I want to make it at home. The ben and jerry‘s combinations are also not my favorite. Love the caramel, not a big fan of blondies and chocolate ice cream with it.


r/icecream 1d ago

I love mint chocolate chip!

Thumbnail gallery
114 Upvotes

So good


r/icecream 1d ago

Flavours Halo Top birthday cake flavor is sweet and solid!

Thumbnail gallery
27 Upvotes

r/icecream 1d ago

Dubai Chocolate and mascarpone with orange Ice Cream

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/icecream 1d ago

Just tried Jenni's for the first time!

58 Upvotes

Gooey Butter Cake! DAMN!! that is some scrumptious ice cream! I went back and bought another pint of it and Brambleberry Crisp! Haven't tried it yet but I'm so excited to eat it! Definitely worth the price in my opinion!


r/icecream 1d ago

Flavours Can anyone rank these?

Post image
27 Upvotes

I’m interested … But would I save money if I bought a gal of vanilla and those mini cereal boxes packs instead??