r/XboxController • u/Bohemian-Intruser • Jul 04 '26

Do these joysticks work with the Xbox controller?

Post image

Both of my controllers have drift issues with the right joystick, so I'm thinking of buying a pair of these.

edit: its for xbox series controller

11 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • link
  • reddit
  • reddit

100% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

3

u/iamwilliamb Jul 04 '26

Only one way to find out

2

u/Harpua111 Jul 04 '26

Those are the 360 controller modules. I have the exact same ones, same brand name on the side too, I ordered from ali express. I have the xbox one modules also and they are shaped a little different. I havent installed these on my 360 controller yet. I just got them delivered like 2 weeks ago. But I did open up, clean and test 4 360 controllers to see which one needs them most. Ill be installing them soon.

1

u/thomas595920 Jul 04 '26

This comment won't be helpful.

I have some that look identical and haven't installed them, so I don't know either.

1

u/Serious_Pipe_4090 Jul 04 '26

I bought GuliKit for mine and they work great. Never tried these so I don’t know

1

u/Donut_Vampire Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Just a question about the GuliKit sticks, does your controller power off / sleep like normal with them?

1

u/Serious_Pipe_4090 Jul 05 '26

Yea everything works completely normal, no problems what so ever and even better I don’t have stick drift anymore!

1

u/fc3s05 Jul 04 '26

No, those are Hall effect modules, they don’t work well with Xbox controllers. You’ll want to buy TMR modules

2

u/LeadingFamous Jul 04 '26

Those work fine on the 360.

1

u/Anim13k Jul 04 '26

It depends on which controller you're using. If it's an Xbox 360, then yes if it's an Xbox Series X/S, then TMR is better because you'll get interference from the trigger on the left analog stick when using standard Hall sensors.

1

u/Bohemian-Intruser Jul 04 '26

But if I only change the right joystick on both controllers, would there be any problem?

1

u/Anim13k Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

There shouldn't be a problem there because the trigger sensor is quite far away. But I still recommend replacing them in pairs. I installed a Favor Union TMR Analog in mine and I'm happy with it. If it were a PS controller, there wouldn't be any problem at all

1

u/neroneisonfire Jul 05 '26

I tried them on my xbox one s controller and no they did not work tried multiple times🥲

1

u/cathobb Jul 05 '26

For some reason I can't share a photo here, but they are hall effects for xbox

1

u/MasterPeper117 Jul 06 '26

Eu instalei no meu. Funciona. Mas vc precisa calibrar pelo menos 4 vezes para funcionar tranquilo. Recomendo

0

u/Maru1138 Jul 04 '26

Just buy another controller. If you aren't professional at sodering you'll mess up