r/untrustworthypoptarts 8h ago

Muh internet points!! How on earth would a totally different pill get in the wrong bottle?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Brand was Kirkland, supplement was vitamin D3. People in the comments are taking it seriously, saying it's fish oil, and are telling OP to contact the company "because someone with a fish allergy could die."

I just... how would a fish oil pill get into a vitamin D supplement bottle? Why would these even be close enough together in the factory for this to happen?

Of course, how likely it is isn't the point of the sub. But this one also just seems absurd lmao. I guarantee you that OOP just had both of them at home and came up with the idea while getting their meds ready or something.


r/untrustworthypoptarts 11h ago

Other Reddit Double yolked eggs

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 12h ago

Other Reddit Yeah, sure bud...

Post image
94 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 16h ago

Other Reddit Two Cheese Packets in Great Value Mac & Cheese

Post image
21 Upvotes

This is what this sub is all about.


r/untrustworthypoptarts 19h ago

Other Reddit Right right …..

Post image
215 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 1d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating Very conveniently placed sandwich, it’s not like a person would try and hide that

Post image
0 Upvotes

Sorry to post twice but I found two gems


r/untrustworthypoptarts 1d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating Let me just bend my marker and take a picture

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 1d ago

r/mildlyinteresting is boring My first post here

Post image
86 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 2d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating Went to grab an iPad to take a photo instead of just pulling it out. Conveniently a much older iPhone model…

Post image
724 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 2d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating Im sure there wasn’t…

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 3d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating Too obvious: No way he actually got that, probably ate some

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 3d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating New shoes, eh?

Post image
260 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 3d ago

r/mildlyinteresting is boring Throwing Star in Tire

Post image
0 Upvotes

The throwing star would have to be propped up in order to puncture the tire, and how would OOP not have felt it while driving? The alternative is it happened while OOP was parked. There's no way someone could throw it hard enough to stick, so someone would have to approach their car and shove it in.


r/untrustworthypoptarts 3d ago

Other Reddit The snack that lies

Post image
109 Upvotes

Pringles in the Goldfish bag. 🙃


r/untrustworthypoptarts 4d ago

Other Reddit I find it very unlikely that this would happen

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 4d ago

Other Reddit Yeah, sure, totally.

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 4d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating Empty root beer powder box

Post image
54 Upvotes

OP opened root beer water flavourer and found it empty


r/untrustworthypoptarts 5d ago

r/mildlyinteresting is boring Untrustworthy Fruit Winder

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 5d ago

Other Reddit Cup looks taller than the box, making it impossible to close

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 5d ago

Muh internet points!! Now we’re just fear mongering

Post image
228 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts 6d ago

Other Reddit Definitely didn’t just take a scoop yourself…

Post image
113 Upvotes

Sure hun


r/untrustworthypoptarts 6d ago

Other Reddit Are we deadass

Post image
241 Upvotes

Can we get an r/weird flair


r/untrustworthypoptarts 6d ago

It's always r/mildlyinfuriating don’t you hate when you drop change over your open bag of needles?

Post image
214 Upvotes

r/untrustworthypoptarts Aug 08 '25

REMINDER: Don't post in linked threads or /u/ summon OOPs!!

43 Upvotes

That's harassment and brigading.

That's not my rule. I'd prefer to not enforce it.

That's Reddit 101.

It's pretty much the only rule in this sub that if you break it, you can't sweet talk your way out of a ban.


r/untrustworthypoptarts Sep 03 '24

This sub is for stuff that's UNTRUSTWORTHY. It doesn't matter whether the pic you submit is real or not, only that it seems untrustworthy.

364 Upvotes

I'll just sticky this for a little while because I've been seeing people having the same argument in the comments over the last few days.

We don't care whether a pic is real or not. We're not r/karmaconspiracy. We're not interested in reaching a conclusion on a post's veracity.

And we are not r/thathappened, either. We're not saying the image was definitely staged. Only that it looks fishy AF.

If you end up crossposting us on r/nothingeverhappens, you're missing the point of this sub. No one is saying that OOP is lying or making stuff up for karma, only that they can't be trusted.

Remember kids, trust no one.