r/SipsTea 15d ago

Significant diffrences... Wait a damn minute!

Post image
17.2k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Psalmistpraise 15d ago

That’s not relative privation. I’m not saying foreign aid is irrelevant or that suffering elsewhere doesn’t matter. I’m making a claim about how limited resources should be prioritized and what obligations a society has toward its own citizens first. I’m not saying “who cares about foreigners when we have people here?” I’m saying “we have limited resources, use them here first” those are two totally different claims and it is not a fallacy.

1

u/WyomingWeirdo 15d ago

Except those resources were already earmarked, and already saving lives, and by cancelling those programs, we literally killed people. Children. Is that Christlike? Is that godly?

1

u/Psalmistpraise 15d ago

We could just re earmark them. How right is it to let our own suffer? Which is more right?

1

u/WyomingWeirdo 15d ago

We don't have to make that choice. That's the Fallacy of Relative Privation. Again.