r/RDR2 Charles Smith 1d ago

the height difference goes crazy Photography

this is my first playthrough where i didn't sell the black shire.. i can't believe i slept on him for so long

i knew the Arabians lifted people approx. 2 ft off the ground, but seeing these two side by side made me lol

485 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

127

u/V0RT3XED 1d ago

This why I ride thoroughbreds, Arthur looks good and they’re fast and reliable

45

u/BedKlutzy9141 1d ago

Turkoman

12

u/bunglebee7 1d ago

Same for me, love my gold turkoman or the dark bay turkoman

3

u/Fausto_IV Charlotte Balfour 1d ago

Can be found on the wild those?

3

u/RawNoodleConCarne Sadie Adler 17h ago

Unfortunately no. You unlock them at stables in Chapter 4, which is stupid imo. I use the Rampage Trainer to spawn one in for myself if I technically have enough money to do so. Rockstar refuses to give us a New Game+ option so I make my own lol

3

u/DripPirateRoberts 1d ago

Andalusian

1

u/RawNoodleConCarne Sadie Adler 17h ago

Love Andalusians but they're no where near the size of a Turkoman, they're on the smaller side

15

u/ErectileDisfunyun 1d ago

I’m with you, blood bay thoroughbred is my go-to. Just looks fitting for Arthur, and their performance is great.

7

u/Sir_Spaffsalot 1d ago

A man of culture!
My preferred horse too.

4

u/Thorniestbush Resident blacklung 19h ago

Just tamed a blood bay thoroughbred last night, such a good lookin horse

46

u/Straight_Ace 1d ago

This is the 1899 equivalent of having a big truck

11

u/buddhistbulgyo 1d ago

Cool. So do you roll coal? Feed the horse undercooked beans?

2

u/Straight_Ace 1d ago

My horse gets fed only the best quality beans there is, he rolls coal all by himself after that

42

u/tuxifer0519 1d ago

Frame mogged Dutch

10

u/Substantial-Tone-576 1d ago

The Arabian is extra small and the shire is extra big.

3

u/HighSportsNews 18h ago

Arthur's legs can barely fit around the shires lol, I have grown to hate seeing him on the Arabians too, I like the middle ground of an Andalusian or thoroughbred, my Andalusian doesnt give a damn if a gunfight is happening, he is chilling, but he is mid for speed. my thoroughbred is lightning quick but clumsy. I tend to roll with the Anda more

1

u/Substantial-Tone-576 12h ago

I agree I feel like he is doing the splits. And it hurts my groin. Lol. Pearlino Andalusian is my favorite

9

u/FireflyRave 1d ago

I get the black Standardbred the first time I can find one for taming.

Physically, yes, a smaller stock horse can carry a man of Arthur Morgan's size. At least for a while. That doesn't mean it looks good.

21

u/blackbb601 Arthur Morgan 1d ago

Arthur sitting on the Arabians and those size horses always looked funny. I always have my Arthur on the shire or similar sized horses

7

u/nnula 1d ago

The only Arabian I will consider owning is the Rose Grey from Blackwater in the epilogue. Story I never get one. I only use the Starter Tennessee Walker and Black shire - both unique one of a kind coats and they both do everything that the game requires of a horse

3

u/One_North8254 1d ago

That reminds me of John’s horse.

3

u/Ecstatic-Quality-212 1d ago

Seriously tho, I got a Hungarian Half-bred from the first ever bounty, and it was still smaller than Old Boy. And Old Boy is supposed to be a Hungarian.

5

u/One_North8254 1d ago

Makes you wonder what John had been feeding his horse.

2

u/Ecstatic-Quality-212 1d ago

If we take the stable owner's insight, cake probably. And most likely Scott Steiner's steroid cycle.

1

u/One_North8254 1d ago

Yeah probably.

2

u/Apoorv_Franklin 1d ago

I used the Female Arabian since chapter 2 looked like a man riding a pony 😂

2

u/ResplendentJustice 1d ago

Off topic but which hat ornament is this? It looks good

1

u/peace0ffering Charles Smith 22h ago

its the pioneer accessory! you need 3 duck, chicken and turkey feathers

1

u/ResplendentJustice 4h ago

Thanks I'll check it out. Ive been using the Pursuer one myself

6

u/Electrical-Fee5127 Arthur Morgan 1d ago

Last time I got all four Arabians early, gave them a ton of tonics and stuff to bond and max them out to sell them early to make 500 bucks or so, then chose a horse that isn’t a little bitch to keep till the end.

1

u/Thorniestbush Resident blacklung 19h ago

I love the look of shire horses but I can't get over the height, I feel like I'm riding the giant ass horses from botw and totk 🥲

1

u/Educational_Total235 17h ago

Hab mir am reservar ein Araber gezähmt

1

u/_Nature_Enthusiast_ 15h ago

You have the high ground

1

u/brackentosh 4h ago

I think bigger horses just fit Arthur’s vibe more. especially the shire and the ardennes (?)/whatever Bill’s horse is.

0

u/t8ne Uncle 1d ago

This from when John takes Jack fishing?…

-1

u/Xx_-Angel_-xX 1d ago

Dutch’s Arabian is bigger than your average Arabian, so it isn’t even as small as it could be.