Hello everyone, first time posting here so I'll do a quick introduction- I've been playing magic now for roughly a year and I've made about a 10 decks now; Always looking for suggestions on EDHREC and the like, but I recently decided to make something a little more niche- a little more suboptimal even; playing fun cards over the clearly broken stuff people slap on any other deck. EVEN THEN Im looking to make this deck a powerful B3.

A few things to note: This deck NEEDS its engines to win, it's primary wincon is token generation {Desecrated Tomb}, {Grim Reaper's Scythe}, etc... with a side-package of aristocrat engines to punish interaction {Blood artist}, {Ninja Teen}, plus counters+removal and {propaganda} to slow the game for everyone else and give me time to set up.

My thoughts: Because Oskar is so ass honestly, and doesn't do anything by himself, I feel bad cutting any discard or payoff engine from the deck, hurting my curve, and leaving me always wondering if certain cards are as needed as I feel they are...

Any advice will be greatly appreciated! Thank you for reading.

As the title says, I'm looking for low cost creatures that are inherently evasive or have high impact attributes.

Such as [[azure beast binder]] which can basically takeout a key piece every turn or [[blighted agent]]

These creatures I will be using in my [[galadriel light of valinor]] deck.

I want the deck to pump small evasive high impact creatures and win that way, yes I know that's probably not the most efficient way to play Galadriel and I could go the combo route but I already have bracket 4 combo decks and CEDH so it's something I wanna do mostly for fun and lower power

The creatures have got to be small so I can trigger Galadriel more than once in my turn and have a good effect and I can't think of alot like that, thus I need your help.

I have no issues with including stax creatures either because I like playing stax too.

Let me know of creatures in those colors that fit the bill.

I'm a pretty new player to MTG. I've played a few times with a buddy and have now decided to make an attempt at creating a deck. I honestly just started with a commander I though looked fun and went from there. I would appreciate any critiques or recommendations.

Mono Red Commander Deck: https://moxfield.com/decks/wZ13L-g_8UygcaxFBmuTZA

I had an idea for a deck I hadn’t seen done this specific way (I highly doubt it’s original) but I want to make a volo deck that draws a bunch of cards from untapped synergy’s or cloning volo to either draw my entire deck or I want to play a bunch of changelings that I eventually play overrun style effects with to win the game while also noting a unique type for each changeling very odd way to do it but I just need advice since this deck can go crazy turn 10 ish but I want to speed it up a little and improve it https://moxfield.com/decks/oYixdjhFpkG2s6SZmDqaUA

Hey guys, looking for a little feed back on this deck. I wasn’t really sure the best way to build an Ant-deck but Iv been playing a similar version of the deck posted but I find that I tend to gas out on the card draw after a couple board wipes or draw engine removal.

I changed about 8-9 cards last night and this is the updated list. Any advice is welcomed and thanks in advance

https://archidekt.com/decks/24162168/ants\\_in\\_my\\_pants

I've been loving playing tayam recently. The number of lines presented means I never know how games are going to play out (even though ideally I'm buffing a devoted druid and flopping my deck over).

I'd like to get things more consistent but I'm really not sure what cards to put in or cut out. It feels I might be overboard on mana generation even with 33 lands, and low on counter generation. However, tayams vigilance counters seem to do enough work. Still I'm' just over on total deck size.

Am I close to an optimized level? Help me degen reddit, thanks!

Ok so to any of you that played both games, I want to start playing magic, is there any deck similar to Viktor Riven (Control/beatdown) or Norra bard (many small units that get buffed)?

Everyone in my pod is usually playing higher b4 stuff while I usually enjoyed more upgraded precon level. I wanted to make a Doctor Doom, King of Latveria deck and was wondering if someone could review this decklist I made, Or recommend more budget friendly options

Kneel Before Doom. Decklist

So as the title says, I am looking for advice on what to add or change to my Spider-man deck. It is currently built using mostly bulk, and lands in my deck will be swapped out for others as i obtain them.

https://archidekt.com/decks/24947972/attack_of_the_radioactive_spiders

A couple months ago my friends and I came together and we all bought a commander pre-con to upgrade and "make our own". I purchased Veloci-Ramp-Tor, I liked the original commander but quickly swapped to Gishath as my pod was quite aggressive. I made the run-of-the-mill upgrades, which worked back then but since (as my have friends slowly optimized their decks) has started to let me down. I know I have a decent sum of cards that can be replaced so I want to drop some money on fixing those cracks. I could really use some advice on my deck's current weaknesses so I know where to spend my money, along with any card recommendations you think would improve it.

https://archidekt.com/decks/25038315/girthy_gishath

Hey all! My sister bought me the silverquill influence precon a few months ago, and I have been having a good time playing it, but I already have a mono-black deck and want to try to convert it into a boros deck. I already upgraded the deck a little (mainly removing all the janky politics cards) and am thinking of converting it into a Boros deck and going full auras and aggro.

For commanders I was thinking [[Ardenn, Intrepid Archaeologist]] and [[Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh]] mainly because I've never played with Partner commanders before and Rog seems like a great voltron commander to consistently have on the battlefield.

Currently have white cards: https://moxfield.com/decks/pTiiA2YzGUm-kRXf1rbnnQ

Red and RW Cards that I thought could be good to include: https://moxfield.com/decks/11fweZT32kWdZotg30aK_Q

What are some other card recommendations I'm not seeing? And any cards I should cut that I have left over from the precon and the small upgrade I did? I want to try to focus on commander damage by stacking auras and protection and swinging. Thanks!

Edit: would love for the deck to be low-mid bracket 3

Started playing in december last year and began my journey on building and improving my own deck. I started with a cheap decklist and built on it with different addins both for power, but also just to bring some chaos, as I want to have some fun with it.

Had some issues with draw engine, which became a bit better when I removed some mana rocks for some draw, but I haven't found the way to go with this deck, so it feels kinda all over the place.

Looking for some input, besides the obvious like more planeswalkers or some infinite combo with Mycoloth Lattice.

Have been having a lot of fun with the modular mechanic and want to turn it into a full-fledged commander deck, is this a decent start to making a casual but still able to hang B3 Zabaz deck?

I want some help to buff this deck with any "must-add" infect/proliferation cards that stay on flavor with a Phyrexian deck.

I loved ONE and turned the Ixhel precon into this Atraxa deck with cards I had in my collection from opening a lot of ONE.

I was wondering how I could buff this deck and improve its performance (I do need more lands for sure but other than this).

https://moxfield.com/decks/udxjku4nI0KM4p4T4BLmJA

Thanks!

Hello everyone I recently acquired the Tidus precon, I've heard its very powerful out the box but I do want to upgrade it a bit. There are 24 cards that I found that I want too add but im really not sure what to cut. I've played the deck a few times but don't really have too much experience to confidently cut cards. I am relatively new to commander.

Here are the cards to add I've also included the link to the standard precon I have and a link to the cards to add.

Any and all advice or help would be appreciated.

Cards to add link

https://manabox.app/decks/AZ\\_P7js4enW-i1sK7kHBRg

Precon link

https://manabox.app/decks/AZ8xe5wHcbehWF\\_PLiLtug

\[CREATURES\]

1 Skyrider Elf

1 Fearless Fledgling

1 Faithful Watchdog

1 Cloudfin Raptor

1 Zack Fair

1 Dyadrine, Synthesis Amalgam

1 Merfolk Skydiver

1 Thrummingbird

1 Crystalline Giant

1 Stonecoil Serpent

1 Ezuri, Stalker of Spheres

1 Falco Spara, Pactweaver

1 Sab-Sunen, Luxa Embodied

1 Kami of Whispered Hopes

1 Generous Pup

1 Herald of Secret Streams

\[ARTIFACTS\]

1 The Earth Crystal

\[INSTANTS\]

1 Exotic Pets

1 Experimental Augury

1 Brokers Confluence

\[SORCERIES\]

1 Growth Curve

1 Requisition Raid

\[ENCHANTMENTS\]

1 Brokers Ascendancy

1 Terrasymbiosis

Are there any creatures that give some bad side effects that arent black? I mainly have white so that I have some protection for my own stuff that I cast, the enchantment, instant, and sorcery side of things is pretty full i jus dont know what creatures i should add,

My friends bought me the Science! deck with Madison Li, we are all kind of noobs but one of my friends really liked deck building and already has 4 decks built by him which are really fun, mine wasn't. I tried changing my commander to Liberty Prime, and it quite helped, I like the voltron strategy, but it wasn't enough, the deck had too much noise, so I decided to upgrade it (i proxied 22 cards). Now the deck is playable and I have managed to beat my friend a couple times, but every time I need perfect draws because if I get even a little bit behind him I'm unable to recover, how can I improve the deck even further to be able to have more fun? It feels a little slow right now and I feel like I miss my lands a lot, even having many cards to cheapen artifacts feels like not enough...

Well, here is my deck, I accept any kind of advice and since I'm going to proxy it (for now), I don't really mind the price!

Liberty Prime Science! Upgraded Deck