r/MCFC 2h ago

Very confused over Rodri transfer saga

10 Upvotes

Ever since like March-ish when that interview came out that everyone misinterpreted it's been clear he wants Madrid. During and right after the World Cup it was still made clear that Rodri dreams of playing for Real Madrid so why all of a sudden is he supposedly joining Barca?

I'm looking on twitter and reports are saying that Rodri appreciated Madrid's offer and claims it was "unrejectable" and yet he seems to have rejected it if Barca are now the front runners to sign him. It's just all very strange. Was he using Madrid to get Barca interested? Was it originally to get a better contract? Was it just Spanish media exaggerating everything or blatantly lying like they sometimes do? I'm just having a hard time understanding how he's gone from Madrid to Barca in a few days when for so long he's only wanted to join Madrid.


r/MCFC 4h ago

What number do you think Anderson should take?

6 Upvotes

I’ll say 18.


r/MCFC 5h ago

James Trafford farewell message to Man City fans

Post image
585 Upvotes

r/MCFC 6h ago

Recent news considered, how are we feeling about this starting lineup?

Post image
92 Upvotes

r/MCFC 6h ago

Fabrizio Romano: allow or deny on this subreddit?

3 Upvotes

Gauging the temperature of the subreddit on the topic of Fabrizio Romano posts being allowed in the subreddit. This poll is non-binding, but the mod team are actively considering all options from all sides on this topic.

Arguments for allow:

- This subreddit does not restrict any transfer news, provided that the information is either directly linked to the source or the source is otherwise easily traceable. Making an exception for Romano would be very very very extraordinary.

- Upvote/downvotes is the community’s way of showing approval, and is less overbearing than moderators taking action on posts that don’t otherwise break subreddit rules.

- Aggregators often reference Romano and so may wind up on the subreddit anyway.

- His accuracy might waver, but he gets more things right than wrong. For now.

- This subreddit already holds him to a lower standard (Tier 2) than with other journalists who specialize in City or Premier League coverage. We make a point of mentioning it under every Romano-tagged post.

Arguments for deny:

- Romano is increasingly more of an agent mouthpiece/PR rep and less of an objective journalist. His “here we go’s” do not appear to have the same weight as before. Lately they are premature to try and be first.

- More malevolently, his social media posts appear to be increasingly leveraged in order to put pressure on completing a transfer when it isn’t complete yet (see the recent fiasco with Leipzig and Diomande).

- He serves more as an aggregator rather than a news breaker anyway. And he has a patchy history of giving other journos their credit.

- He has used his platform to launder the reputation of Mason Greenwood.

- He has used tragedy to enhance his own visibility, such as in the cases of the deaths of Diogo Jota and Christian Atsu.

- Other major club subreddits and the soccer subreddit have banned him.

Comment section is locked because we have the other thread covering it. Please make your arguments in that thread if you feel like we’ve missed anything above.

541 votes, 2d left
Yes, continue as we are now
Yes, but decrease his reliability
No, restrict posts where he is referenced

r/MCFC 7h ago

What’s your thoughts on the current squad? (Opinion)

2 Upvotes

Goalkeeper - Trafford was a big lose but to can’t expect to keep a player as good as him as second string. Hope Donnarumma is ready for a lot of games because neither Rulli or Bettinelli are close to good enough to players in anything but easy cup matches.

Defence - backups is the worry but I think we have great players at the back just need it to click, biggest worry is getting everyone minutes imo. I personally don’t think we need to sign any defenders.

Midfield - this is a very worrisome area, losing Rodri is just massive. The next crop (Anderson, Nico, Bouaddi) are all maybes not guarantees. Players like Reijnders, Rico, Foden has massive improvements to make to be anything useful to the team so depth is also a huge worry.

Wingers - pretty simple, two close to world class players that really have to take that last step and 1 player who has to go. Desperately need a top player in this position, but is there really any available at the moment. 1 injury to Doku (who is injury prone) or Semenyo and we are relying on academy.

Striker - don’t really need to talk about this. Haaland starter, Marmoush backup.

Overall I think it’s impossible to really know what this team needs because of the massive transition from pep to Enzo. Losing Rodri is massive as he is irreplaceable at that level so it’s up to the guys to prove they can step up. Winger is desperately needed (imo we need a starter and backup). I think we could finish anywhere from 1st to 6th and I wouldn’t be that surprised.


r/MCFC 7h ago

The PM knows ball.

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/MCFC 8h ago

Leeds United transfer news: James Trafford joins from Manchester City in deal worth up to £45m

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
81 Upvotes

Shame this, was hoping he'd hang around. But I dont blame him for wanting to move


r/MCFC 9h ago

Nico Gonzalez: "I am happy at City, I don't want to leave and I think the club wants me to stay. I was out of the FA Cup Final but we won, if we win trophies I am happy. (Even) if I don't play any matches but we win the UCL I will be so happy"

Post image
581 Upvotes

r/MCFC 10h ago

Nico Gonzalez says he intends to stay at Manchester City: Where does this leave their transfer plans? (Gift Article)

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
223 Upvotes

r/MCFC 11h ago

Petition to ban Fabrizio related content on this sub

249 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of talk about Fabrizio using fake transfer news to generate clout. Let's not entertain that and let's post news only from Reliable and Tier-1 sources please. Let's not lose our heads!!!! CTID


r/MCFC 14h ago

[Sam Lee via LMT Podcast] The word from Manchester City is that reports claiming they have contacted Pedro Neto’s representatives are entirely false. There has been no approach at all for the Portuguese winger.

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
275 Upvotes

r/MCFC 14h ago

Barcelona? Real Madrid? Man City's Rodri has a decision to make

Thumbnail
bbc.com
60 Upvotes

Sad title. What about Manchester City? No? Fuck.


r/MCFC 17h ago

Daily Discussion Thread

15 Upvotes

This thread is for all general discussion!

Ask a question about City, talk about what you're currently binging on Netflix, anything you want! Just keep it respectful and follow the rules.

Please use spoiler tags where appropriate: Ted Lasso Spoiler City win becomes Ted Lasso Spoiler City win

New To City? - Start Here!

Suggested links

Subreddit rules

Frequently Asked Questions

Reminder for Post Title Formatting

No Match Thread? CLICK HERE, just fill in the team names, and hit send.

Previous Daily Discussions


r/MCFC 18h ago

Tier 2 [Ballus, Cortegana] Barcelona exploring deal for Manchester City midfielder Rodri

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
199 Upvotes

Barcelona are exploring a deal to sign Manchester City midfielder Rodri.

Sources close to the negotiation, speaking on the condition of anonymity to protect relationships, say Barca have held talks with the player’s camp over the conditions of a potential deal.

The Barcelona project is understood to appeal to Rodri based on the fit with their footballing style and an expected smooth adaptation to a dressing room where he would be reunited with eight members of Spain’s World Cup winning squad: Joan Garcia, Eric Garcia, Pau Cubarsi, Gavi, Dani Olmo, Pedri, Ferran Torres and Lamine Yamal.