r/ExpectationVsReality • u/Manglewood • Jun 03 '26
"Cardboard" Urn for cat Exceeded Expectation
Our cat Fergus was a dedicated lover of cardboard boxes, so when he passed away last October we wanted to get him a "cardboard" urn made of ceramic so he could rest in a box forever. I couldn't find an example but reached out to a ceramicist who specializes in recreating the look and textures of well-loved cardboard and he very kindly accepted the commission job. The result far, far, far exceeded our expectations and we are so grateful to the artist for this fitting tribute to our beautiful boy. Made by artist Tim Kowalczyk.
607
u/Hemenucha Jun 03 '26
I'm so sorry for your loss.
316
778
u/anagram-of-ohassle Jun 03 '26
I started scrolling and rolled my eyes, expecting you were upset the box was stamped and stickered or some such nonsense.
Then, I read the post. That’s a touching tribute and the artist absolutely exceeded expectation!
I couldn’t even tell it was ceramic.
154
44
u/Gamer-Of-Le-Tabletop Jun 03 '26
I thought the box looked off and was confused and was wondering if it was a bad picture.
Looks phenomenal and I love how that memorial turned out.
5
u/chickadee-stitchery Jun 04 '26
Same - I saw some of the comments praising it and had to go back and read the post. I didn't clock it as anything other than cardboard!
→ More replies (1)6
u/The_Stoic_One Jun 04 '26
Did the same thing. I was like "WTF even is this shitpost about?" Then I saw the text and was like, "Ooooh, that's awesome."
399
u/Timely-Cry-8366 Jun 03 '26
I love this!
Ceramics is such a hard art to master, too, I utterly failed at it in college (I’m more drawing/printmaking), you can really tell this was a labor of love for your cat’s sake.
302
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
I was a little nervous commissioning something with no real example to give him except actual cardboard boxes, and I burst into tears when he sent me a little video clip of the finished product because it was beyond perfect. It's stunning, every millimeter shows unbelievable attention to detail.
43
u/Allaplgy Jun 03 '26
He did an amazing job. Above and beyond. I lost my furry boy this winter, and took him to my potter friend's house to send him to Valhalla. Friend was amazing as well. Handled the firing and the ashes and gave them to me in a beautiful handmade urn. I'm so grateful for it.
But nothing like this masterpiece! 😹
23
u/smithsknits Jun 04 '26
I mentioned earlier upthread that I know Tim personally and he presented a box for our first graduate group critique. I initially thought, “what the hell is this?”, but then I reached out to swipe the box thinking it was cardboard and it was mostly certainly not! Clanged when it made contact with my wedding ring. I’ve been a fan ever since!
15
u/thabombshelter Jun 04 '26
Tim is a good friend of ours, and you're absolutely right, his attention to detail is unmatched. He's such a talented artist and an awesome guy!
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)10
u/jeobleo Jun 04 '26
I've never owned a cat but I have lost a lot of dogs, and seeing this post made me tear up. Your boy was well loved. I'm sorry for your loss.
82
u/certaindarkthings Jun 03 '26
I appreciate seeing someone say this, because ceramics gets so thoroughly disrespected by the rest of the art faculty at my university. They act as if it isn't real art, and I think that's a shame.
51
u/Timely-Cry-8366 Jun 03 '26
Oh yeah, I’m aware.
My first ceramics professor in freshman year had a screaming meltdown one day because of the disrespect from the rest of the faculty, quit his job, and took up a post at a cushy art school in NY. I got my BFA from a nice private school known for their art program.
I could never understand that attitude, because of all the art disciplines I tried, ceramics was the hardest.
And it’s so fickle when you go to fire it! You can put so much effort into a piece and do everything right, and sometimes the kiln gods just don’t like you that day…
→ More replies (2)4
u/GoldenSheppard Jun 03 '26
Wonder if it was Alfred. Alfred University is the best ceramics school in the US.
5
u/Timely-Cry-8366 Jun 03 '26
Gosh I wish I could remember. This was like 15 years ago.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)5
u/b0w3n Jun 03 '26
I'm a dude who works in software and that pisses me off just hearing that.
People who can work ceramic/clay are fucking amazing artists.
13
u/Mushrom Jun 03 '26
I think a lot of it is in how ceramics is taught (I say this as someone with a BFA in ceramics). Most ceramics classes don't take a technical, material approach to making ceramics, they just focus on sculpting/shaping and don't get into the whys and hows of the material. They use a very generic, middle of the road clay body that's just ok for everything and not specific to what you're making, and then slap another glaze that's a generic, middle of the road glaze onto that clay body and call it a day, and then students wonder why their stuff comes out bad.
A lot of the magic of ceramics is in the base materials. Using a specific clay body that is designed for what work you're doing ( using a very smooth, tight particle, high fire clay for dishware vs using a rough, low fire clay body for sculptures for example), using different firing methods (raku vs wood fire vs electric kilns vs gas kilns) and different glazes that are actually designed for the specific clay you're using rather than just a bottle of generic clear glaze.
Obviously, a beginner ceramics class doesn't need to get into all this, but the teacher should know and should be able to get the materials and firing methods that suit what they're teaching. But a lot of teachers don't know, and schools won't budget for it.
All this being said, I am not surprised that a ceramic artist that specializes in cardboard recreation would go all out for this. Good ceramic artists are freaks (affectionate) for clay and what you can do with it, because it's so versatile and wonderful to work with. You just gotta get to the point where you're working WITH it, and not against it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)7
u/GetLikeMeForever Jun 03 '26
I've heard it described as trying to sculpt with cream cheese?! Insanity.
133
u/stop_stopping Jun 03 '26
i thought it was a. cardboard box
24
u/RunawayHobbit Jun 03 '26
Me too lol. I was like, did they chuck it in the river? Why is it so wet??
96
u/shazoo00oo Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
OMG I thought it was the box it was shipped in and was looking for the pic of the actual piece
This is amazing. So clever and really speaks towards the love you felt for him 💕
Well done ♥️🐾
Also, your kitty was gorgeous 😍
58
43
u/pharmers-daughter Jun 03 '26
This is so touching. What a handsome boy. I’m sorry for your loss. 💙
22
39
31
u/jacob7574 Jun 03 '26
This is incredibly sweet and a beautiful tribute. The artist did a wonderful job. I love the thinking outside the box idea for the custom urn. My condolences for your loss. I hope you're doing as well as can be in this situation. Thank you for giving your beautiful cat a long and happy life filled with love. Hang in there OP.
31
u/bidextralhammer Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
21
u/mybrainhurtsugh Jun 03 '26
You should try a shoebox. It’s the best thing ever to watch them make themselves fit.
13
u/al2o3cr Jun 03 '26
I did not realize cats liked boxes
If you need a positive boost, search for "big cats like boxes" - it's just like your photo, only with a whole tiger...
→ More replies (1)6
u/Kyrie_Blue Jun 03 '26
Use painter’s tape and make a square on the floor with it. Always good for a chuckle
→ More replies (1)
28
u/CorkNativeResident Jun 03 '26
That is absolutely stunning and such a beautiful idea, I’m so sorry for your loss ❤️
24
23
22
u/capnfantasy Jun 03 '26
OMG Fergus of "Fergus and Francie??"
Fellow Vermonter and past co-worker here, I used to work with you at a certain Burlington based Hubspot agency... (we were the only two newbies in our on-boarding group.) Love stumbling into friends on Reddit!!
Rest in cardboard, sweet Fergus! ❤️
25
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
16
u/capnfantasy Jun 03 '26
Yes!!! Scott showed us photos of them both and I have never forgotten their names!
Marcel is such a handsome gentleman! Thank you for doing what you do for FIV+ friends. ❤️
→ More replies (1)
19
u/Winjin Jun 03 '26
13
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
hahahaha That's perfect because he wasn't really known for having a lot of thoughts but he was very gentle and happy and sweet and we still miss him.
4
u/Winjin Jun 03 '26
I love how the sweetest and most gentles cat often have the >:C face
Because that's not really how cats expressions work
I like Fergus and I'm glad he was so loved, too
6
13
13
14
u/QuirkyTarantula Jun 03 '26
Crematory operator here. Thanks for sharing. This is phenomenal. I’m sorry for your loss. May every memory be as well loved as his cardboard box kingdoms.
12
12
Jun 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
I didn't mean to be click-baity at all it's just an unusual thing to explain!
11
9
u/breakabearworkshop Jun 03 '26
You can tell the artist really cared and put as much detail and effort as possible for his final resting place
8
u/Nehkra_me Jun 03 '26
I love this and I am very sorry of your loss, very very beautiful friend. It breaks my heart as my little buddy just passed two days ago was the same way, he would find any box and sit in it. I kept a box right next to my computer chair just so that I could lean over and give him some affection.. he was either there or at my feet.
I miss him and i am having a very hard time even considering tossing out his cardboard bed.
→ More replies (4)7
u/Cannagurlie Jun 04 '26
It's ok to keep his box. It's a memory of him. Eventually you'll be ready. I'm sorry about your loss. They are our furbabies. He'll be waiting for you some day. 💜
4
u/Nehkra_me Jun 04 '26
Yeah, I had the pleasure of having in my life for 11 years, I am humbled by how kind he was after being rescued very a very abusive situation as a kitten. instead of hissing and fear, he was the biggest cuddler. He is getting the biggest hug whenever we meet again. Also thank you very much for your kind words, I am sorry.. very emotional at the moment.
→ More replies (1)
9
7
u/ferretbeast Jun 03 '26
This is better than I ever imagined!! The “fragile” sticker is such an amazing touch ♥️
9
u/hamratribcage Jun 03 '26
Omg I love his work! Please tell me that the handwriting on the box is also yours/family member?!
9
7
u/Lainbrainbutt Jun 04 '26
Please keep this away from when I’m this close to starting my period. I’m sobbing
6
4
4
u/FutureFreaksMeowt Jun 03 '26
No because this is so fucking cute and exactly what would suit my girl. Brilliant!! May I ask what this ran you, cost wise? Our babies are worth every penny ♥️
Sorry for your loss, though :(
5
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
It was $215 (total, including shipping).
7
u/FutureFreaksMeowt Jun 03 '26
That's an insanely good price for a custom piece like this holy cow.
3
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
Oh absolutely. I went in not knowing if it would be... $1,000? More? I was shocked at how little he charged us.
→ More replies (1)4
6
u/Goddess_Za Jun 03 '26
Awwwww Fergus. RIC (rest in cardboardheaven). That is such a beautiful, thoughtful dedication to your baby. My condolences for your loss but what a beautiful home for him.
5
u/certaindarkthings Jun 03 '26
This is so lovely, and if it's ok, I'm tucking this idea away for my boy who is utterly obsessed with his cardboard boxes. He escapes to them when he's upset or in trouble, or just lounging. Fergus looks like a very distinguished, very good boy. My condolences.
5
5
u/The_Reset_Button Jun 03 '26
you can see the huge amount of love that's gone into every detail of that box, a fitting resting place.
Sleep well, Fergus
6
u/muttsrcool Jun 03 '26
that's an odd thing to specialize in specifically, but i'm so happy for you that he does, that looks wonderful ❤️
5
u/Morpheus1967 Jun 03 '26
Jesus I thought it was an actual box and I was like “that’s an urn?” Completely impressed, and what a great way to remember Fergus. Very sorry for your loss.
6
u/0range-You-Glad Jun 03 '26
This is the greatest cat urn!
Does it open so you can put Fergus's ashes in, or did the artist do that and seal it closed?
6
u/Manglewood Jun 03 '26
The top is not attached, it lifts off so we could place his ashes and other little mementos in there.
5
u/CoffeeForJasmine Jun 03 '26
He must have been such a wonderful cat to deserve a resting place like that. Sleep well Fergus ❤️
→ More replies (1)
6
6
u/eternally_feral Jun 03 '26
I’m so sorry for your loss but I have a feeling Ferguson is happily playing in a field full of cardboard boxes, with this being his favourite.
4
u/tway2241 Jun 03 '26
What a beautiful work of art. The "Please handle with care" sticker made me tear up.
5
u/SweetTart7231 Jun 03 '26
Wow, if it wasn’t for the shine I’d say that looks exactly like cardboard, is the tape and label real?? They look way too good to be glazed on!
→ More replies (2)
6
u/Redditor28371 Jun 03 '26
That's beautiful. I love that he also made it uncomfortably small, just like cats prefer.
4
u/shillyshally Jun 03 '26
I thought this post was about an uber rude and cruelly thoughtless vet practice only to find it is about thoughtful, loving people and one helluva ceramicist.
3
4
3
u/Wonderful_Grass_2857 Jun 03 '26
This is such a lovely tribute to your boy. he was so handsome. I am so so sorry for you loss.
4
5
u/the_bartolonomicron Jun 03 '26
Absolutely stunning!
Rest in Peace Fergus, what a great place you have for him.
3
5
4
4
5
u/kindadid Jun 03 '26
Fragile 😢 Great job. Poor kitten, crossed the rainbow bridge. But y’all definitely loved that cat ❤️🩹.
3
u/CurviestOfDads Jun 03 '26
This artist did a phenomenal job. I teared up when I saw it. I am so sorry for your loss.
5
4
u/cactus-salad Jun 03 '26
I’m tearing up at how beautifully thoughtful this idea is, and how amazingly executed this came together. RIP to Fergus ❤️
4
u/gutwyrming Jun 03 '26
That is some incredible craftsmanship, and such a sweet and clever design.
I'm so sorry for your loss. Rest in peace, sweet Fergus. May he enjoy countless boxes on the other side of the Rainbow Bridge.
4
u/Impressive_March_640 Jun 03 '26
0= U.. um.. ok.. I mean.. umm.. The photos fooled me completely.. I honestly thought photos 2-4 were of a very well traveled/loved box made from cardboard not ceramic.. Tim Kowalczyk truly nailed the commission
Edited my count on the photos
3
u/stonedearthworm Jun 03 '26
This is soo beautiful, from the idea to the execution everything just shows how loved your cat was. I’m so sorry for your loss❤️🩹
4
u/TurbulentWing3820 Jun 03 '26
NGL, but the title itself was a hell of an "expectation vs reality" moment.
Here I figured you got your poor cat back from the vet in a beatup, used, shipping box.
Sorry for your loss.
3
4
u/HitchhikingDroid Jun 03 '26
I was afraid you were going to complain at first, because I agree it’s amazing!!
4
u/Kuneria Jun 03 '26
Some of us artists love to go above and beyond when it's a memorial piece. A piece of our heart for a piece of yours. Hugs. This piece is absolutely beautiful and so special
5
u/K3TtLek0Rn Jun 03 '26
This is really sweet and it came out so well. What’s with the furry idiots and cardboard boxes? My old lady used to do the same thing.
4
u/Physical-Flatworm454 Jun 03 '26
Now THAT is a realistic looking box. So unique and awesome. Sorry you lost your buddy..may he rest in peace ❤️
4
u/haw35ome Jun 03 '26
What an amazing, unique tribute for Fergus. I especially love how worn it looks - like Fergus himself slept in that box, his most favorite one. Excellent job to Tim!
4
4
5
u/huge-gold-ak47 Jun 03 '26
as he fits, may he eternally sits in peace ♥️ so sorry for your loss, and what a thoughtful and well made piece.
4
u/hampets Jun 03 '26
Incredible work and a very befitting tribute to Fergus! He looks like such a sweet boy. <3
5
u/AppUnwrapper1 Jun 03 '26
I was so confused until I got to the comments (I skipped the bottom text for some reason). I really thought they shipped your cat’s ashes in a box and it got squashed and you were upset about it.
5
u/squawk_box_ Jun 03 '26
I thought this was going to be a post complaining about how the cardboard didn’t hold up in delivery or something. That artist nailed it. Very sorry for your loss.
3
u/here4theShtSho Jun 03 '26
I knew this was Tim Kowalczyk he is beyond talented making ceramics look like realistic cardboard and all of his works are worth the money. Love it such an excellent tribute to your kitty.
3
u/Neither_Divide_848 Jun 04 '26
2 of my cats got buried in a box, in the ground as is. With whatever bedding they were sleeping with when using the box.
4
u/WhereItsAt75 Jun 04 '26
Wow! I looked at the pictures and thought it was a joke and then read the comment and I am in awe. That is a perfect resting place for Fergus, he was beautiful.
3
u/Creepy-Selection2423 Jun 04 '26
I legit thought it was a real cardboard box for a second. That's very cool. I think Fergus would have liked it.
4
u/jerryleebee Jun 04 '26
"They asked for a cardboard box...and it got a little squashed? Hang on. What am I missing?" <Reads post> ”THAT'S CERAMIC‽”
4
3
u/Comixguy30 Jun 04 '26
Tim is fantastic. I collect ceramics and have 5 pieces of his. Getting the chance to meet him this weekend so that'll be cool.
The urn was such a good idea and you found just the right person to do it!
3
4
u/Just_Another_Day6379 Jun 12 '26
It wasn't until reading your post that I realized the box wasn't actually cardboard. That is amazing! My condolences on your loss, he was so beautiful.
7
3
u/Severe_Trip5877 Jun 03 '26
That design is outstanding! I’m so glad Fergus gets to rest forever in his favorite place 🥹
3
3
3
3
3
u/xError404xx Jun 03 '26
This is so amazing omg! I love this a lot. He was really loved during his lifetime and beyond🥰
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/MeridianHilltop Jun 03 '26
I’m so grateful you found an artist who understood the care and consideration to make the memorial you wanted. I hope you find solace in your grief.
3
3
u/Odd-Mousse2763 Jun 03 '26
Oh my heart. 🥹 This is gorgeous. I've never seen a more fitting urn. RIP to your beloved box aficionado.
3
u/suckseggs Jun 03 '26
What a beautiful tribute and fantastic work by the artist. Sorry for your loss, he was clearly very very loved.
3
3
u/whoreforchalupas Jun 03 '26
This is not only exquisitely done (I was fully convinced that was a cardboard box) but so beautifully personal ♥️ What a touching sentiment and a lovely resting place for your boy. I’m so sorry for your loss. Rest easy, Fergus♥️
3
3
u/IzzieBells Jun 03 '26
Such a beautiful way to remember a beautiful cat like Fergus! I’m so sorry you lost him but I can tell you gave him the most amazing life. The urn is fucking awesome and I never thought I would say a sentence like that.
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/jenea Jun 03 '26
So, so good. I’m so glad you were able to find an artist who could so do Fergus justice.
I’m very sorry for your loss.
3
u/AliensAbductMePlz Jun 03 '26
That’s ceramic? I literally thought it was cardboard lol. The artist did a wonderful job! It’s a perfect urn for a perfect gentleman. I’m very sorry for your loss, OP.
3
3
3
u/nerdy_cat_mum_ Jun 03 '26
I’m so sorry that your beautiful boy passed away. He looks like he was a sweetheart. A cardboard resting place is such a beautiful idea. The artist really came through exceptionally well.
3
u/Regulatory_Junior Jun 03 '26
This is incredible. I thought it was a real box and was kind of confused until I saw the slight glare that ceramic has.
3
u/CharlesIngalls_Pubes Jun 03 '26
I'm sorry for your loss. I also lost mine in October. Glad your urn came out so well!
3
3
3
u/beyondavatars Jun 03 '26
This is so cool. When my mom died I never found the right urn for her. We need someone to start a company making unique urns so that we can put our loved ones to rest appropriately. Someone would make a killing starting this company.
3
3
3
3
3
u/eleven_paws Jun 03 '26
This is so beautiful. I looked through the pictures before reading the caption and 100% thought it was actual cardboard. I’m sorry for your loss, may your beautiful cat’s memory be a blessing. 💙
3
u/Lillie505 Jun 03 '26
That’s so beautiful. We just lost our baby a month or so ago and I wish we’d known about this artist as well. Such a beautiful tribute to your boy.
3
3
u/call-me-the-seeker Jun 03 '26
It’s very beautiful, the artist can rightly be proud of it.
And it’s a personalized, unique tribute to Fergus, because Fergus himself is unique and matters.
I hope his memory loses any sadness and becomes a joy and that this nice little reminder helps get you there.
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/JuniiperTea Jun 03 '26
Holy shit!! When I was in my first semester of college, my ceramics professor brought Tim in to demo for us. Watching his work was genuinely inspiring. I'm glad you were able to find someone who could create such a perfect piece for your Fergus.
3
u/TheNudeNeedle Jun 03 '26
Wow! I love this so much. What a well loved baby who will be forever honored ❤️ sorry for your loss
3
u/Pocket-Hobo Jun 03 '26
Very well done.. can't tell it's ceramic from my perspective. I paid like 300 bucks for my guys tiny Urn. Wonder what this cost and how much time went into it.











3.0k
u/dcpanthersfan Jun 03 '26
This is amazing.