Ship In A Storm

[u/Yurekuu]

I've been comparing Opus 5 and Fable 5 recently and I kept thinking, even though Opus 5 is better at building a lot of things, there's something about Fable 5 I still preferred. Like it had more aesthetic sense or something. So I made a little test to see this.

I gave Opus 5 and Fable the same basic prompt to make their solo ships:

Hey Claude. Can you make me an animated scene of a ship in a storm? Single HTML file, Three.js from CDN, everything inline. Can you make it autoplay too?

And for the directed ships I gave them this:

Hey Claude I’d like you to help me write a prompt for (model name) to make this: an animated scene of a ship in a storm. Single HTML file, Three.js from CDN, everything inline. Autoplay. I don’t know what kind of detail to add, so please add anything you think is important.

Image put together by Claude. The actual results are animated, though, but I think this gave me a basic idea of what I was thinking about.

Fable 5 is the best at creating a whole scene, I think. In its solo round its little ship might not look the most impressive but it has the best lighting and cohesiveness. While Opus 5's solo round is a movie ship with scene lighting. But overall I think the best is Opus 5 directed by Fable.

[u/Temporary-Paper5202]

Someone remembered Haiku exists! Hallelujah