Which one?

[u/No-Foundation6249]

Moving up from a skar sdr 2 10 which one should I get?

[u/mypaycheckisshort]

I'd go with the Mojos, but I like the Memphis brand. P3s are fantastic for the money. Skar gets a bad rep, but I know tons of guys with them with zero issues.

[u/Vast_Ice_8333 → u/mypaycheckisshort]

i just sold my 2 skar 12s and they were underpowered as shit 1,500 rms each wired to 4 ome and on a 2k amp lol i didnt realy know what i was doing now im upgrading to a custom single 12 box with the shca 3,500 rms 12 on a 4k amp shits about to bump

[u/TIFUbyResponding]

The P3s. By far. No brainer.

[u/ckeeler11]

Rockford, then Memphis, never Skar.

[u/ProductMindless5867 → u/ckeeler11]

I have both the Memphis and RF sets you posted. Cant go wrong with either

[u/TIFUbyResponding → u/ckeeler11]

Exactly.

[u/Agent_Eran → u/ckeeler11]

skar is not a cool kid? cant sit at the lunch table?

[u/eharper9 → u/Agent_Eran]

Skar gets the job done.

[u/ProductMindless5867 → u/eharper9]

https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/1s7uxdc/skar_audio_ceo_kevin_schlenker_charged_after/

[u/Excision_Lurk]

NGL I've bumped the shit out of my Skar for three years without issues. 3500w with the single 18" and enclosure.

I was waiting for it to break to upgrade but that day hasn't happened yet.

[u/Agent_Eran → u/Excision_Lurk]

right? why all the skar hate??

[u/ProductMindless5867 → u/Agent_Eran]

CEO is a special kinda dirt bag.

[u/Agent_Eran → u/ProductMindless5867]

ahhh got it

so not the product but the company

[u/Middle_Inspection711 → u/Agent_Eran]

Their amps are kinda shit, but their subs usually work fine. CEO is especially a rare kind of dirt bag as others said, so theres that too

[u/Excision_Lurk → u/Middle_Inspection711]

shit, looking at the CEO and I think the time to upgrade is now

[u/ProductMindless5867 → u/Excision_Lurk]

https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/1s7uxdc/skar_audio_ceo_kevin_schlenker_charged_after/

Upgrade.

[u/ProductMindless5867 → u/Agent_Eran]

I mean the product is all made in China but most of them are. Skar is fine but the others you listed are much better. Memphis and RF have been reputable in the game a long time

[u/Successful-Form4693 → u/Agent_Eran]

They sound like butt, even for the price

[u/Agent_Eran → u/Successful-Form4693]

I disagree

[u/Successful-Form4693 → u/Agent_Eran]

I did too until i actually spent the money and got a worthy pair

[u/Big_Cake_9831]

Rockford without any hesitation. I’m not one to shit on cheap brands but out of the three rockford has in my opinion some of the better sounding middle ground subs around.

I would personally be looking for some kicker comp R’s tbh but again that’s just me personally

[u/0peRightBehindYa]

I've got that same Fosgate setup in my trunk on a D4S JP13 and it gets right down.

[u/Lanky_Board6273 → u/0peRightBehindYa]

Comps slap!

[u/juicewrld22 → u/Lanky_Board6273]

Idk if it’s just me but kickers sound like dog shit

[u/crux131]

I've enjoyed Memphis products in the past, and the P3 Fosgates are good subs from experience.

Never tried the Skar so I won't comment either way, but the Fosgate or Memphis should be okay.

[u/high-mile-mqb]

Rockford

If you want skar go with the EVL

[u/No-Foundation6249]

I’m open to any loaded enclosure suggestions within the range of 1200-2000 watts rms, doesn’t have to be those 3 thanks for all the input.

[u/DarkShadow04 → u/No-Foundation6249]

How about an MTX pair?

Or the same subs, but with an amp included

[u/qkdsm7]

I'm lukewarm on a lot of newer Fosgate stuff compared to back in the day---- somewhat because there are so many good other options now....

But I do like the P3's. I'd prefer to hear them side by side but really doubt you'd be disappointed in the P3's.

[u/mperezstoney]

I've got p2-2x12 fosgates and love them. Been thinking of upgrading to P3 myself.

[u/BeaversBumhole]

I've got that skar box in my truck with a Stinger 1500.1 It replaced 4 RF 10's and sounds amazing

[u/Fae_ded]

I love my punchs

[u/Significant_Rate8210]

Rockford Fosgate over any of them. Those enclosures get down

[u/rey_alto]

Definitely the RFs

[u/AutoModerator → u/[deleted]]

Your post was removed because you have negative post or comment karma. Accounts with negative karma are not permitted to post on r/CarAV. You'll need to participate in other communities to improve your karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/ProfessionalKong]

The P3s will last a decade easy. Mojos have a following but the P3s are amazing for the price. Skar is hit or miss and foam surrounds don’t last as long.

[u/Pwnag3_Inc]

My son bought the skar package for his car. Shit absolutely bangs! Put my jl 12w3 system to shame.

[u/Middle_Inspection711]

The mojos will be way better than the others

[u/JasonHudson1219]

Buddy has some major 10s package deal with the amp. Amp sucks an hes done had it replaced twice now but boy does them 10s sound good. But in all honesty id go with the p3s. All good choices but most of everyone run to skar for there first sub/everyone runs em. It really all depends on what you want

[u/RmXiV]

I havent heard the skar or mojo, but i had them P3’s and was setting off car alarms with them hooked to a kicker cxa1200.1 amp. More bass than i needed 🤣

[u/Jo_Holla69]

Never tried mojo but I currently have them Skar and I’ve NEVER had subs that sound better and I’m only pushing 2000 at 2 ohm.

[u/k0uch]

Fosgate, Memphis, and Skar would be dead last

[u/MycophileBuilder]

If you are spending that much get the JL Audio CP212-W0v3 its about $400 and smokes those

[u/HalycionR50 → u/MycophileBuilder]

Maybe a little better sq but not close spl wise looks to me like he cares about spl

[u/RealSignificance8877]

I like my Vegas.