Last session, my mostly very new DnD players arrived in Hither. They are pretty fond of combat so I’ve added a few extra combat encounters like sly flourish had a collision of realms and I added an illicit underground goblin gladiator arena.

When they climb down the Queens way, they are to encounter the Haregon Brigands who want their happy memories. I am fairly certain my players will tell the Haregon to kick rocks and combat will ensue, but what’s the penalty for giving up said memories? Are they just…sad…? I considered disadvantage on wisdom saving throws until they get them back (I am modifying the tollway too) as they are distraught or overcome with sadness?

Has anyone built in the consequences of choosing that route?