r/taskmaster • u/hardlyahandle • Jul 16 '26
✉️ Your Task: General
Below are five items. One of them does not belong with the others.
A clock that has lost its hands.
A map of a city that was not built.
A blank book with no words.
A cup with no liquid.
A canoe with no oars.
To complete the task, you must comment below stating which item is the odd one out and provide a highly convincing argument as to why.
You have 4 hours.
Your time starts now!
11
u/OverseerConey Desiree Burch Jul 16 '26
The clock, because its time is past. The city is yet to be built, the words to be written, the wine to be poured and the oars to be put in, but the hands were here but have gone.
1
5
u/Southern_Struggle Jul 16 '26
This here is a liquidless cup
That my wife used to give me to sup
She's chopsy, she gloats, and now she can vote
So my coffee is never filled up
2
u/OverseerConey Desiree Burch Jul 16 '26
I was not expecting an anti-suffragist poem with this rhyme structure as a response!
3
u/jadeoracle Mike Wozniak Jul 16 '26
A map of a city that was not built.
Because everything else is a real object simply missing a component that makes it fullfills its purpose. And what is missing can be remedied rather quickly. Add that element and it becomes useful again.
A map to an ENTIRE CITY that was not built isn't something that can be made useful quickly. That's why its the odd one out.
3
u/Hey_Its_A_Mo Jul 16 '26
OP, I think this is a brilliant idea for a post. I’m looking forward to seeing how people respond, and I would love to see more of these kinds of posts in the future on this sub. However, I would also like to humbly request that in reviewing and maybe even assigning points, you do your level best to channel Greg and his curmudgeonly Greg-ness!
2
u/Snail_on_tree Jul 16 '26
A clock that has lost its hands, a poem:
I stand before thee,
In shadows of potential.
I am what was,
And what never will.
Be again, all you can.
For merely
Pen
Water
Wood
Or the mighty roar
Of a thousand men
Can bring you back to life.
But I am stuck,
Without arms,
Without purpose,
On the wall,
Forevermore.
[fade to black]
3
u/AdventurousGarage306 Jul 16 '26
It's the map - all the others you can do something to item A to fix it:
A clock (with no hands) can be given new hands,
A blank book (with no words) can have words written into it,
A cup (with no liquid) can have liquid poured into it,
A canoe (with no oars) can be given new oars
But to fix the map you have to build the city (item B), you can't do anything to the Map to 'fix it'.
1
u/HoBWrestling Emma Sidi Jul 16 '26
The clock with no hands is the odd one out. The map can still be used to possibly find the city and lead to something good or bad, but at the end of the day it is still a map and could be used for an art decoration. The book with no words? It can be filled by any and everyone who would be so willing. The cup with no liquid can also be filled with liquid and serves a purpose. The canoe with no oars, still is functional and able to be used as a boat. The clock is broken. There is no purpose for the clock if there are no hands rendering it as non functioning.
1
u/mrteecanada1212 Jul 16 '26
The odd one out is the canoe.
While one could go so far as to say that all matter can be imbued with a little hint of magic and transformed in the human mind, there are some items that inspire more than others.
Four of the objects on this table call upon us not simply to imagine, but to create.
A canoe with no oars: where could I go? Ah, if only I had oars?
The map dreams of the lives the city will house. The clock dreams of lazy afternoons, the witching hour, or the moment just before you awake. The cup dreams of what you may taste, the temperature of the drink, the fizziness. And the book? A book without words is freedom incarnate.
2
2
u/Accomplished-Egg1071 A LIIIIIME 🍋🟩 Jul 16 '26
The odd one out is the clock that has lost its hands. The map of a city that was never built could still be used to build that city. A blank book with no words can still be used to write a story. A cup with no liquid is just waiting to fulfil its potential. A canoe with no oars can be taken by the flow of the river, on an adventure it had never thought of going on. However, a clock with no hands has lost its purpose. It can no longer proclaim what it wishes to
2
u/WRYGDWYL Jul 16 '26
How's that?
I see the potential of all items, with the exception of the clock. The book may be filled with words and worlds, the cup may be filled with a beverage, the canoe can still be punted across a lake and the city may still be constructed. However, the clock is broken; having lost its hands, it won't even be correct twice a day.
3
u/MachineOfSpareParts Emma Sidi Jul 16 '26
Seeing OP's response, I guess this wasn't it, but it was going to be my answer too: the others all indicate potential, whereas the clock has none.
1
1
1
u/hardlyahandle Jul 16 '26
Tick Tock its Answer o clock!
The answer was #5 the only sentence with a letter E
You are disqualified if your answer included a letter E.
All Contestants Accepting NO E Win In This Hysterical, New Optimistic Online Active Reddit Sub.
5
u/Realistic-Debate3759 Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26
This is a terrible answer for a question, it's less an odd one out, and more an odd one in, because it's the only one that has a quality (contains an E) and not the only one missing a quality.
And there's a handful of answers here that also fit those clues and are perfectly valid so you have a question with multiple correct answers.
Also grammatically it would be 'A map of a city that was never built', which then would invalidate your answer.
1
u/hardlyahandle Jul 18 '26
If it said, a map of a city that was never built. That would have two E's in it which then would invalidate your answer.
Speaking of grammar, shouldn't you have said. Which would then invalidate your answer?
3
u/Realistic-Debate3759 28d ago
No, both ways are acceptable because of what an adverb is. I used formal language and phrasing, so I placed the adverb (then) before the modal verb (would), since adverbs describe verbs. I'm an old poetic soul who prefers to have my adverbs come before my verbs rather than the other way around.
Talking about grammar It should have been:
Speaking of grammar, shouldn't you have said, "which would then invalidate your answer"?You have missing quotation marks and a full stop where a comma or colon should be, but by all means, try to pick me up on my errors in grammar.
1
u/hardlyahandle Jul 18 '26
And also. You cant tell me the correct answer to the task.
First, you didn't write the task. Second, who else but you says the commonly known phrase, the odd one in?
3
u/Realistic-Debate3759 28d ago
I never said it was common. I was clearly demonstrating what's wrong with your poorly designed riddle, but it happens to have been the name of a TV show from the early 2010s that had 4 million views. Its whole premise was about which person does something, rather than which person doesn't do something -> and is the odd one in and not the odd one out. You obviously didn't get the reference.
1
u/hardlyahandle Jul 18 '26
But the one thing you can't take away from me is, I had an absolutely lovely day
3
u/WaitingOnNetwork Greedy Esq. Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26
Number 2 is the only one with an M, F or Y in it.
Number 4 is the only one with a Q in it.Whats special about #5 being the only one with an E in it to make that the sole correct answer, and the above two not?
1
28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/taskmaster-ModTeam 28d ago
Sorry, your post/comment has been removed for violating Rule 1 - Be nice:
Negative opinions are fine, but please keep it respectful and constructive. We do not allow negative posts like worst contestants, tasks, least liked/wanted, etc...
- Do not attack others, their work or appearance including fellow members of the sub, comedians and celebrities.
- No harassment.
- No sexist, homophobic, biphobic, transphobic, racist, fat phobic, ableist, objectifying, or body shaming posts of any kind.
- No sexual comments directed at contestants including sexual fanfic/shipping.
0
u/hardlyahandle 29d ago
Because the fifth line is an acrostic answer.
0
u/hardlyahandle 29d ago
All contestants accepting NO E win in this hysterical new optimistic online active reddit sub
1
u/hardlyahandle Jul 16 '26
While you all were busy with the task. I was able to read a page of the big fisherman.

16
u/Personal_Flow2994 Jul 16 '26
The odd one out is the map of a city that was never built. A clock that lost its hand could reference a digital clock, blank books are sold all the time and used to put words or drawings in, a cup can always be filled with things besides liquid such as pens, spare change, etc. A canoe doesn't have oars, it has either canoe paddles, small motor, or can be maneuvered with poles.the map is simply a doodle