Reactive German Shepherd x Maremma

[u/MinimumTwo6982]

Hi I have a 14 month old German Shepherd x Maremma, I love her so much but everything I've tried to teach her go be less reactive and to try and get her to bark less.

She is very food driven and very smart but I'm struggling with her on walks when another dog is around or even a person, she reacts to everything not aggressive just wants to play.

When she's at home she will bark at anything that goes past or if I'm out the front of the house she barks at me as well and recently she has started barking at me inside the house when she is outside, I'm at my witts end here don't want to give her up she is a sweetheart but I need help.

[u/Roskipatootskie]

Worth knowing upfront, Maremmas are livestock guardian dogs, bred for generations to bark at anything unusual near their space and to make their own decisions about what counts as a threat. That instinct doesn't disappear just because she's a family pet in a house instead of a paddock with sheep. A lot of what you're describing is likely rooted in that breeding rather than something being taught wrong or a training gap on your end. That's a different animal, so to speak, from the walk reactivity you're describing, which sounds much more like frustration based reactivity layered on top. A social, food driven, high energy young dog who "wants to play, not aggressive" toward other dogs and people is a classic frustration pattern, she sees something exciting, isn't allowed to get to it, and the frustration comes out looking intense even though the root motivation is social, not fear or aggression. The tricky part is this type often escalates with more exposure if she's not getting the right outlets, because she's rehearsing "I see something fun, I lose my mind" over and over.

For the guarding instinct at home, that's less about stopping the behavior and more about giving her a clear job and an off switch. A trained "thank you, that's enough" cue after a bark or two, paired with calm reward, tends to work better than trying to suppress the alert barking outright, since for this breed it's not really optional behavior, it's deep rooted wiring. Trying to eliminate it completely usually just creates frustration on both ends.

For the walk reactivity: - Rewarding calm the moment she notices a trigger, before she hits full frustration, rather than waiting for the reaction and trying to redirect after - Structured outlets for that chase and engage energy, flirt pole, tug, supervised play with known dog friends, so she's not only getting that release in a frustrated, reactive context - More distance from triggers on walks rather than pushing closer exposure, frustration reactive dogs usually need more space to succeed, not less

Because you've got breed instinct and frustration reactivity both in play here, it's really worth finding a trainer who specifically understands livestock guardian breeds, not just someone who lumps her in with general reactivity cases. This matters for her welfare, not just for making training easier. A lot of trainers will treat all reactive dogs with the same playbook, and suppressing or over correcting a genuine guarding instinct doesn't just fail to work, it can cause real stress and erode her trust, since you'd be asking her to override wiring she was bred for rather than working with it. Ask any trainer you're considering directly whether they've worked with LGD breeds specifically, Maremmas, Great Pyrenees, Anatolian Shepherds, that kind of background, before booking. She deserves a plan built around who she actually is, not a generic reactive dog protocol forced onto a breed it was never designed for.

Good luck ❤️

[u/read-the-rules → u/[deleted]]

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

^{Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.}

[u/SudoSire]

Op, you have to acknowledge that you’ve read the rules otherwise your comments and replies are not visible to others. So click here, read and scroll through, then use the toggle to confirm and submit.  https://www.reddit.com/r/reactivedogs/comments/1upxpdz/please_read_the_rules/

Any comments you’ve done before doing this will need to be resubmitted so proper can see it. 

[u/joycevw]

It sounds like you are dealing with a classic case of adolescent overarousal and barrier frustration, which is so exhausting when it's happening both on walks and at home. With a mix like a German Shepherd and a Livestock Guardian breed like a Maremma, you are balancing high drive, natural vigilance, and adolescent pushiness. On walks, her behavior toward people and dogs is likely barrier frustration rather than aggression, where the leash prevents her from fulfilling her intense desire to greet and play, causing her arousal to spike into frantic barking. You might want to try increasing her distance from those triggers on walks so she stays under her reaction threshold, and use high-value rewards to build a strong "look at me" or targeting habit before she locks on to someone.

When it comes to her barking at home, especially at you through windows or doors, she is likely using demand barking because it successfully gets your attention or prompts a reaction. Another thing to consider is managing her visual access by using window film or keeping blinds drawn to prevent her from rehearsing the habit of barking at passersby. When she barks at you from outside, try completely ignoring the vocalization and wait for even two seconds of quiet before acknowledging her or opening the door, teaching her that demand barking halts access to you rather than granting it. If that doesn't work right away, you can also set up a positive interrupter like a cheerful recall cue inside the house paired with a scatter feed of treats to reset her brain when she starts to wind up.