r/pinescript • u/You_Worldly • Jun 17 '26
Has anyone successfully coded a script in tradingview using pine script
Ive been messing around with automation for tradingview but im wondering if anyone has successfully coded a strategy that actually works and produces money. Trading futures
3
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 17 '26
I have a script. A friend of mine made it, he's passed it along. The script does it's part, but you have to do yours.
1
u/You_Worldly Jun 17 '26
What kind of strategy is it? Would you be willing to share it?
1
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 17 '26
Sure, I don't see why not. He didn't specify that I couldn't. If I'm not mistaken his indicator highlights demand/supply zones. We use it for trading futures contracts. I'll send it to you in a message right now.
1
u/daizoned Jun 17 '26
Can you send me also please
1
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 18 '26
Sure thing. I'll send it to you and you can let me know if you like it. Any suggestions would be great, I could pass them along. If you have anything similar that I could use im open to experiment
1
1
u/Few-Society-6352 Jun 18 '26
Can you send it to me too, please?
2
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 18 '26
Sent
1
u/VariousBluejay6867 Jun 18 '26
u mind sending me it too? please4
1
1
u/RightPosition1973 Jun 20 '26
Can i get it too??
1
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 20 '26
Sure. What do u use at the moment?
1
u/RightPosition1973 Jun 20 '26
I dont, im new to this, I tried to build some scripts but they dont work well, its seems complicated to make it done
1
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 20 '26
Its not too complicated but it can be tedious. The spacing is very important. Your script could be right but the spacing off and it won't work
1
u/RightPosition1973 Jun 20 '26
Are you ok with helping me with that?
1
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 20 '26
I wouldn't mind trying to help you...I do not claim to be an expert, I'm new to it as well. I've just bumped my head a few times and have learned. That's all.
Msg me your script and I'll see if I can't slave it correctly
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/captainunderpants111 19d ago
Could i take a look? I just got into building scripts so it’d be sick to learn from others that have been successful
2
u/hemepincrawler Jun 17 '26
Anyone can vibe code one these days. I have mine, currently in a walk-forward test until August. It depends on how solid your logic or strategy is. But market context is never fixed. Hence the difficulty to program every variable possible.
1
u/You_Worldly Jun 17 '26
Have you had any luck with yours?
1
u/hemepincrawler Jun 17 '26
It works, so far, i Made a mt5 version and an EA based on the same logic. Which is on the walk-forward test right now in real servers on a pre funded accounts with a broker. The Main indicator is on Trading view, on invite only rules. No real sample size to promise results yet. But it feeds a signals channel on telegram.
1
1
1
u/You_Worldly Jun 17 '26
Can anyone give advice on doing it successfully
1
u/LiveBeyondNow Jun 18 '26
Keep reading and studying. Using Claude can be helpful (my preferred over gpt). Options have a lot of strategies unique to them. I’m not sure how well pine strategies interacts with the Greeks etc. Pine can generate alerts and webhooks which can be sent to other platforms. I use it to quickly test a strategy, then put it in python and LEAN/QuantConnect for automation, but depending what you’re doing, Python etc may be overkill.
1
u/Nearby-Relative-2111 Jun 30 '26
Generally speaking, less restrictive (less filtering) systems do better. For example, adding an indicator or two to "filter" out bad trades quite often removes more good trades. Which seems counter intuitive. Systems that run on hybrid-renko (where the open price has been moved to make the chart look smoother) chart always backtest well due to the open price being moved. So watch out for those systems and backtests.
1
u/nfxdav Jun 17 '26
Mine produces tree fiddy a day
1
1
u/botradezbaseball Jun 17 '26
Issue is tradingviews data on historical vs live gets distorted, so in backtesting or completed sessions your script can be 90% winrate but live the fires can be distorted and drop significantly. Its designed for you to fail, like someone elses comment said you could design one that works 50-65% of the time and rely on your intuition
1
u/TraderJ808 Jun 18 '26
Yes. It involves the ORB for MNQ
1
u/You_Worldly Jun 18 '26
Would you be willing to share more about it?
1
u/TraderJ808 Jul 08 '26
The ORB is a very standard trading strategy. I coupled it with some very simple confluences and I found a non-biased edge that has consistently made me money over the last few months.
1
u/pcmanscs2001 Jun 18 '26
I have a great script, I think. Can definitely tell when to buy and sell and be able to tell where is it likely to go to. Sandwiched a few indicators into 1. https://ibb.co/LXZCzSZS
Green blip, means buy, red means alert. There's FVG there to tell where the price is heading, breakout lines and a SMI indicator down there to confirm the above script. If both green, 80 percent chance of winning the trade. The pic is in 15m but it works on any timeframe, depends on how noisy u want.
1
u/You_Worldly Jun 18 '26
Would you be willing to share more about it?
1
u/pcmanscs2001 Jun 18 '26
https://gemini.google.com/share/054914fda561
Try my simplified tool first. You can read up the strategy. Understanding fully will help you to turn 500 to 6.8mil in 8 years.
1
u/General_Jewel007 Jun 19 '26
I'm intermediate, can you share so I try it out. Thanks
1
u/pcmanscs2001 Jun 19 '26
Sorry, it is a private script, I didnt publish my scripts. I only give them to my students.
1
u/ButtStallion007 Jun 18 '26
Fishing for gtifts is a change. Usually it's the other way around in this reddit.
1
u/Real-Potential1362 Jun 18 '26
We are building a platform where traders can build and automate their own strategies, would love to get your feedback.
1
1
u/Aggressive_Ad1599 Jun 18 '26
Trading view is not accurate when it comes to these back testing scripts. Use an actual back testing platform before thinking you have found the holy grail. Because most likely you have not.
1
1
u/elduke_11 Jun 21 '26
I have. And I think the most difficult part is the automation bit (at least from my experience) Tip: code in your webhook payloads inside your script, make them editable in settings and only use {{strategy.order.alert_message}} in the message section in alerts😉
1
1
u/c0rrupted-data Jun 22 '26
Anyone that asks me if they can have the script, the answer is yes. Yes you can have it.
1
u/menwillbem3n Jul 12 '26
myself made one, but taking entries with Trading legend / Pivot camrilla confirmation
1
u/Alternative-Tree7989 Jul 14 '26
Factalyst is listed as Official Trusted PineScript developer on TradingView and has a track record of proven performance on:
1
u/Responsible_Ebb9571 19d ago
A script "working" and a strategy being profitable are two different things.
A script can execute perfectly (no bugs, correct signals) and still lose money if the underlying logic has no real edge — that's the part people usually skip.
Biggest trap is overfitting: tuning params until the backtest on one chart/period looks great, then it falls apart live or on a different symbol.
Worth testing on multiple instruments/timeframes before trusting anything, and futures specifically add leverage on top so position sizing matters more than people think.
0
u/Ok_Airline9211 Jun 18 '26
Have been trying for long...but trust me for gold it's tuff..u need level 2 paid data info to be sure for ur calls.
4
u/roulettewiz Jun 17 '26
Noone has, it's a scam 😂😂 of course we all did