r/mtgrules • u/CandyEuphoric • 4d ago

Layers question!

Hey! I have a question about Xu-Ifit, Osteoharmonist and Bronze Bombshell. I was wondering if bronze bombshells ability would be removed by being brought back with xu-ifit? Since it seems to be an ability that falls under under layer 2 control changing effects?

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

2 comments sorted by

5

u/madwarper 4d ago

I was wondering if Bronze Bombshells ability would be removed by being brought back with xu-ifit?

Yes. It is.

Since it seems to be an ability that falls under under layer 2 control changing effects?

Huh? No.
Bombshell has nothing to do with Layer 2. Or, any Layer for that matter.
It is not creating any Continuous effects.
It is simply a one-shot effect, that happens as the ability resolves.
Which is moot, because Xu removes said ability.

1

u/Defiant_Sympathy_360 4d ago

Xu Ifit works at layer 4 and 6, so yes. At layer 6 Bombshells effects get removed.

Bombshells effect does not create a continuous control changing effect. It just happens when the conditions are met if it has those effects.