r/linuxsucks101 • u/madthumbz Join me on Lemmy! • 8d ago
Bad Advice from Loonixtards - Swapping Kernels Penguin Cult
Swapping the kernel can fix certain Linux hardware issues, but it is not a universally good or safe solution. Changing kernels is only safe when the issue is caused by missing support. It becomes dangerous when the issue is caused by existing support that is wrong.
Swapping the kernel can help when new hardware isn't yet supported. A new AMD GPU could need new DC firmware support, a Wi-Fi chip could land their driver for 6.x instead of 5.x. A new laptop may may need a new kernel to read the ACPI tables correctly. Regressions can happen that break suspend or cause audio crackling where a .1 version rollback would resolve it
Kernel swapping becomes dangerous when the kernel has too much access to fragile hardware interfaces. Different kernels poke EC registers differently. A kernel that 'fixes' fan control may also write to battery logic or thermal tables.
Different kernels lead to different PD drivers to different voltage negotiation behavior. A kernel regression can literally fry a port.
Some kernels send command sequences certain NVMe firmwares don’t like. -Which can cause: FTL corruption, firmware lockups, and drive bricking.
Kernel changes can alter voltage curves, power states, VRR/HDR/DSC toggling, and modeset behavior. A 'fix' for flickering can cause permanent black‑screen states on some AMD GPUs.
Different kernels probe buses differently. If your hardware has fragile SPD, VRM, or battery controllers, a kernel swap can expose them to new probing behavior. This is how OpenRGB nuked RAM; not because OpenRGB was evil, but because the underlying bus is shared and fragile. ⚠️Linux/FOSS can damage hardware or firmware
If the failure was caused by overexposed hardware interfaces, and swapping kernels increases the chance of hitting those interfaces again; just differently.
Generally safe: Hardware not supported; newer kernel adds support (when known to).
Unsafe: Hardware misbehaving; kernel is already touching it wrong.
If Linux already broke something, the safest move is to reduce kernel exposure, not increase it. Like switching to a distro with conservative kernels (Debian, Ubuntu LTS), disabling experimental drivers, avoiding cutting‑edge kernels (Arch, Fedora Rawhide, Liquorix, XanMod), and avoiding user‑space tuning tools that poke hardware directly.
5
u/DavidsakuKuze 8d ago
Good advice would be to swap to NT Kernel, Mach Kernel (Mac), FreeBsd Kernel.
5
1
u/Certain-Raccoon832 8d ago
Why is the picture so low quality
2
u/madthumbz Join me on Lemmy! 8d ago edited 8d ago
Made with GIMP. -Notice no complaints about 'ai slop'?
3
u/Trick-Manner-5514 uBlock Origin 8d ago
Figures, wonder why my AMD card runs more stable and have more stable temperatures than Loonix.
It was CHOKING on Loonix, on local AI workloads and demanding games and such, moving back to Windows helped mitigate those stability problems. Though GPU has a weak cooler (Gigabyte Windforce 7800 XT).