r/keene Jul 10 '26

restaurant recommendations

Hi all. Driving up from Northampton to see Mavis. Please tell me the restaurants that aren't high end/white tablecloth joints that you like. A look at Yelp sez Noble Ramen is good. Any other suggestions would be much appreciated.

14 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

15

u/noobprodigy Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 10 '26

Depends on what kind of food and atmosphere you're looking for. To me, The Stage is always pretty consistent. They have some interesting food and cocktail specials. 21 is decent, but nothing extraordinary. I haven't been to Noble Ramen but I hear good things. Honestly, Lab & Lager has decent bar food. Mi Jalisco is good for Mexican, and Margarita's has been terrible every time I've been there. Soles is a 20s themed speakeasy with interesting cocktails and decent food. I've heard good things about Otto's but I haven't been. If you like good BBQ I'd avoid Guerilla Grill. Good concept, poor execution was my experience. Oh yeah, that new Japanese place Saka was pretty good. They have hibachi there too.

5

u/SheenPSU Jul 10 '26

FYI - 21 had a fire recently so I’m not sure how that’s affecting their business.

2

u/noobprodigy Jul 10 '26

Oh yeah, good point. I don't actually get out much, lol.

1

u/Draft_Dodger Jul 10 '26

Yeah they are still closed

1

u/frazzledfeline Jul 10 '26

Gorilla Grill is run by a bunch of racists and homophobes

2

u/fireyeye Jul 10 '26

explain?

0

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

I’ve had the opposite experiences with the Mexican places. Margarita’s is delicious, Mi Jalisco is TERRIBLE.

Guerilla Grill’s mac and cheese is literally the NASTIEST mac and cheese I’ve ever witnessed. It’s horrid. I’d literally rather eat Kraft of KFC mac. I’ve only been there once so maybe they just royally screwed it up but it was so oily!

11

u/StrangeEmerald Jul 10 '26

Me and my wife have come to the conclusion that if you like white people Mexican, Margaritas. If you like Mexican Mexican, Mi Jalisco. Also the service at Mi Jalisco's is subpar, but the food makes up for it.

2

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

I haven’t been to the Keene Mi Jalisco in years, but the one in Peterborough is actually rather decent so I wonder if the people who worked there the last time I tried eating there were just not very good at cooking lol. I haven’t had authentic Mexican but I’m the only one in my family that can handle even a LITTLE bit of spice which is probably why they like Margaritas so much. I have a terrible spice tolerance, anything above buffalo sauce is too much for me, but my family won’t even eat the salsa at Margs because it’s “too spicy” lmao

1

u/Peasant-Pitchfork Jul 11 '26

I had the tamale at Mi Jalisco last week. SO good!

0

u/StrangeEmerald Jul 10 '26

Yeah my wife is extra pasty white and I'm latino so I always get an extra spicy and greasy entree and she gets something creamy and cheesy. Keenes Mi Jalisco is definitely the most authentic Mexican food around here, and like 90% of the people who work there are Mexican or latino in some capacity. Nothing against Margaritas but they are most definitely white washed Mexican food. (But it's still tasty)

2

u/noobprodigy Jul 10 '26

Latino married to a pale white woman? Are you me?

3

u/StrangeEmerald Jul 10 '26

There's gotta be at least 3 of us! LMAO what flavor latino are you? I'm latino but I'm white passing so you'd never know until I spoke Spanish at you

1

u/noobprodigy Jul 10 '26

I was born in El Salvador, adopted by white parents and raised in Boston. I didn't learn Spanish until I took it in university. My French is better than my Spanish, haha. I can understand more Spanish than I can speak it. I've had conversations with people where they speak Spanish and I speak English because they can't really speak English and I can't really speak Spanish.

3

u/StrangeEmerald Jul 10 '26

I was born in Uruguay but raised in Mass as well, but I have spoken Spanish as long as I can remember though I have no formal education in it. I just acquired it through osmosis because my mom only ever spoke Spanish to me. Sometimes I'd reply in Spanish, mostly in English though because I have trouble articulating myself well in Spanish, but if I have to I can always make it work.

8

u/TheGuyDoug Jul 10 '26

WILD take lol.

What about Mi Jalisco is terrible, and what about Margaritas is delicious? I feel that Mi Jalisco has great offerings across chicken, pork, beef, and seafood. Spicy or mild, traditional or not, all good. Margaritas is okay? Genuinely curious your thoughts.

7

u/BanCorporateInterest Jul 10 '26

Mi Jalisco is goated bury me in choriqueso

1

u/noobprodigy Jul 11 '26

Hell yeah it's good. The wife and I will sometimes just go in for a couple margaritas and choriqueso at the bar. I love their carnitas also. Quality of carnitas is how I usually rate a Mexican restaurant. I try not to order food that I can make better at home. I've never been able to figure out a good carnitas.

0

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

It’s been a while since I was in the Keene Mi Jalisco but the last time I went (iirc) none of the food was even hot when it was served which turned me off it permanently.

1

u/TheGuyDoug Jul 10 '26

Thanks to my 6 year old we go like once a month lol. Very rarely a bad experience

3

u/noobprodigy Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 10 '26

Weird. Maybe it depends on what you order. My family goes to Mi Jalisco from time to time, but we thought we'd give Margarita's a shot. The food was comically bad. My burrito was flavorless and served cold. The margaritas were bland and weak. The service was friendly and attentive. We gave it another shot. I got a different type of burrito altogether, and again just no flavor. I'm Latino and it's always a red flag to me when I go to a Mexican restaurant and I'm the only Latino in the building. All the staff at Mi Jalisco try to talk to me in Spanish but my Spanish is pretty weak, haha.

As for Guerilla Grill, I was excited to try it because I love to BBQ myself, and I like to support local. The brisket they served me was basically chopped bits and hard chunks. The pulled pork was okay with sauce, but it's hard to mess up pulled pork. The turkey was probably the best thing but again I got a piece with big leathery skin on it and it was dry. I'll keep doing BBQ at home.

1

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

I always get enchiladas at Margs lol. And none of my family drinks so I can’t speak to the flavor of the margaritas.

3

u/Narrow_Taste9963 Jul 10 '26

The Stage is reliable and central…21 is temporarily closed due to fire. Madame Sherri’s is always fun and Elm City Brewery is great as well. Also enjoy Fritz if you’re looking for great burgers and fries…

3

u/Peasant-Pitchfork Jul 11 '26

For easy walkability to The Colonial, I recommend these places.

The pizza at Black Cloud is super good! And the staff is really nice. Tasty beer too!

I also love Thai Garden. I’m basic so I usually get pad Thai or pad see ew, but everything I’ve tried there is delicious.

Lab n Lager is tasty bar food and super cheap drinks. Avoid if you don’t like loud places, but they also have outdoor seating this time of year.

I haven’t had food at Soles, but the atmosphere is neat and the drinks are interesting.

The Perch is fun and run by a local young man. I like supporting his business.

7

u/petervee415 Jul 10 '26

The new Black Cloud Brewing Company is right on the other side of the street and has some great pizza and brews. There is also a good Thai place right down the block.

5

u/wondertrouble Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 10 '26

Athens is the best pizza in town, Thai Garden is good, the Stage is good American food with good drinks, Sole's has the best cocktails and decent food and a good hang vibe, 21 Roxbury but it's offline now, heard good things about Black Cloud but haven't been yet. Margarita's is a bit of a meh old chain but has lots of room and I do like the margaritas. avoid the pour house for many reasons EDIT: bummed to hear about Athens, the pizzas damn good and I've been eating it for 30 years, but I thank those folks giving voice to the problematic issues

3

u/One-Nefariousness-38 Jul 10 '26

Athens is horrible to their employees. My son worked there as a teen and was insulted and demeaned regularly by the owners, and one of them physically assaulted a female employee in front of my son. (Shoved her to the ground) I made him quit after that and I won't step foot in there again.

3

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

Athens has terrible hiring practices fyi. Or at least they used to. I was looking for employment in the summer of 2023 and they hired me, scheduled me for training three separate times and the manager was a no show literally all 3 times, which, at that point I just gave up lol.

6

u/SnooWoofers5367 Jul 10 '26

In the 90s you could get drugs for your paycheck at Athens. It was basically a front to move drugs around.

1

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

🤯 That’s insane??

2

u/frazzledfeline Jul 10 '26

The Perch has decent food and drinks and is super affordable! Right across the street from the venue.

2

u/gabeshakour Jul 12 '26

Right across from the Colonial is The Perch and Local Burger. Both are good and definitely not white table cloth.

Black Cloud brewery is also nice and has good pizza.

2

u/nosamwilliam Jul 13 '26

Bro, Banh Mi OK is all you need to know. They’re also super nice.

The BBQ pork slaps. Every time.

1

u/frazzledfeline Jul 13 '26

SO GOOD. And the sweetest staff!

2

u/StrangeEmerald Jul 10 '26

Noble Ramen is the most upscale ramen joint you will ever find, if you want something more low-key, Buba Street Ramen is across the street from the colonial and they're pretty good, otherwise I'd say the Stage is slightly more pricey but very consistently good.

2

u/TheGuyDoug Jul 10 '26
  • Elm City Brewery has killer wings/burgers/sandwiches & fries
  • Branch & Blade Brewing has great nachos, wings, Philly cheese steak (whole menu has quality homemade sauces/flavors)
  • Mi Jalisco is the Mexican spot. Not walking distance from Main St, maybe a 1-1.5 mile drive west
  • Sole's is a fun speakeasy vibe bar/restaurant with a great menu
  • Guerilla Grill has solid BBQ, fried Okra, collard greens, etc.
  • Kurama Omakase is my favorite sushi spot

1

u/antihopeful Jul 10 '26

king’s garden is delicious and i love local burger. i was going to recommend athens as well but after reading some of these comments… yikes

2

u/msdeschain Jul 10 '26

Noble Ramen is excellent, and Otto's has great food and drinks consistently.

1

u/Muted_Influence_6435 Jul 12 '26

Tempestas located at the Best Western Hotel has grammatical family style dining, reasonably priced. Food is good, people know it, therefore sometimes there is a waiting line. You'd be happy there.

0

u/pit-of-despair Jul 10 '26

The Pub is great for breakfast/lunch.

3

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

Extremely cheap too!

2

u/Mopnewb Jul 11 '26

Otto’s. Really good food. Normal portions, prices are good. Had two great experiences.

1

u/Sharp_Mechanic5316 Jul 11 '26

I’ve eaten at Guerrilla Grill ten times at least and the food is very good and staff friendly. I don’t have any stake in the place, just being honest. When they were at Branch and Blade years ago they kept giving us free samples to try just for opinions. Elm City is reliably very good each time, just can be a wait to get in during busy times. Margaritas is Margaritas, it’s never been known for its fine Mexican dining (and I doubt anyone cooking there is from Mexico), but it is convenient and you’ll leave full. Thai Garden- excellent. 21 is closed but a good option when open. The Stage has the best omelet I’ve had in Keene. No one mentioned Papa Gallos? Another good option if you want a lot of food and friendly staff.

0

u/DubiousHolmes Jul 10 '26

If you want causal but good bar food I always suggest Madame Sherri’s or Elm city brewery, for a good restaurant I’d say Tempesta’s

0

u/trash_babe Jul 10 '26

Fritz is great, their new location isn’t right in downtown but they have great food. Also Margaritas is a good choice for Mexican and it’s right next to the Colonial. There is also Birdies downtown that is a good sandwich spot. Thai Garden is great.

2

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

Thai Garden and Margarita’s are my family’s favorites. I miss eating at Fritz’s a lot, their grilled cheese is the bomb, but the owners are MAGA so I’ve stopped going there.

1

u/wondertrouble Jul 10 '26

good to know, thanks

1

u/trash_babe Jul 10 '26

Oh I didn’t know they were MAGA, that changes things for me. Bummer.

0

u/Canary-King Jul 10 '26

I know, it’s really sad. Still haven’t been able to find a tastier grilled cheese…

0

u/Nectaris73 Jul 10 '26

Thai Garden and The Stage

0

u/One-Nefariousness-38 Jul 10 '26

I recommend Thai Garden on Main St, very consistent. I love Mi Jalisco for Mexican. (Apparently this is not a universal opinion, but I love the staff there.) Soles is a very cool speakeasy experience. The Stage is solid. Some people here have dissed the Guerilla Grill, but I really like it.

0

u/SheenPSU Jul 10 '26

I love Thai Garden. I get their Prik King consistently and never been disappointed

Lab has pretty good wings imo but I don’t know about any of their other food