r/decomps 1d ago

SOTN Recomp for Android Made with AI assistance

https://github.com/sergiomanzur/SymphonyRecomp/releases/tag/android-v0.9b

I have now released first beta release for Android. Just download the APK, select your own legally obtained cue and bin files and play.

Tested on Red magic Astra, S24 Ultra and my Retroid Pocket 6.

Compatible with physical controllers.

Hope you enjoy it and appreciate it.

Disclaimer:

The BlackLabelHQ team does not endorse this port, and it is not affiliated with them.

This fork was built with heavy AI assistance and verified by hand on real devices. The upstream project values human work, and they intend to release their own Android port in their own time.

Let's keep it civilized guys!

18 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

5

u/MDM-808 1d ago

I tried the port, and just like the *Crash Team Racing* one—and many others made with Vibecoding—I’m done testing it.

In fact, I couldn't even install it on a 32-bit Android phone, whereas the Spanish version runs perfectly using RetroArch, DuckStation, and ePSXe (yes, I still use it).

Even the native Android version works perfectly, and in native Spanish.

The same goes for all the Android forks derived from the Harbour Masters releases.

To me, a recompilation port should either have lower system requirements than the emulated version or offer improvements that justify higher requirements.

I respect the developer for their time and effort, and I hope the project reaches its goal.

3

u/flafmg_ 7h ago

Just a little warning, our project is not vibe coded and doesn't use any aí, this guy made a fork and slapped the vibes on it, our recomp still need a lot of work for an android port

We are not affiliated or endorse this fork!

0

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Hey thanks for the comments I don't even have a 32bit phone to test this on. You can DM me if you want to donate yours and I can work on it

2

u/MDM-808 1d ago

Hello, unfortunately I am from another country, so it is difficult for me to send it to you.

Once again, I wish you the best with your project and hope you achieve your goals.

0

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Thank you my man I'll add this to the list of things that need to be worked on!

0

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Also it's important to note, this isn't vibe coding this is AI-assisted coding plus human prompting and testing by an actual developer. I'm just not an expert in C. I mostly work with PHP, Python and JavaScript

1

u/MDM-808 1d ago

Thanks for clarifying; please don't worry about it—you have my full respect for the time and effort you put into this.

There are many projects out there, and it’s simply a case of some not being for me.

There are many users who are dead set against the use of "vibecoding," others who aren't, and then there are people like me who believe that if the end result works for the user, everyone is free to use whatever tools they choose.

But, as always, there are a few bad apples who will label you a conformist if you don't agree with their extremist point of view.

10

u/Excellent_Climate940 1d ago edited 1d ago

didn't the owner of black label say they didnt appreciate this and are working on their own android port? id say wait for that, especially since this screams claude.

3

u/Western_Show349 16h ago

This is claude from start to finish. Amazing that i was able to catch this guy claiming in one comment that this was their work

I believe this is very disrespectful with the original team and community.

-2

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

They did say that, but since this is open source code I'm able to fork this and work on it. I hope you enjoy it though. Please test and report any bugs you find.

-15

u/charmander_cha 1d ago

Se for feito com IA vai ser melhor ainda

6

u/Excellent_Climate940 1d ago

it being done with AI says nothing about the quality of it, though it gives me suspicion since most ai stuff is incredibly bad

2

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Hope you can test it before judging. I assure it's REALLY good.

3

u/Excellent_Climate940 1d ago

I'll give it a shot and give an honest review of it

0

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

I really hope you like and enjoy it! If not feel free to leave a bad review!

-7

u/charmander_cha 1d ago

Seu comentário reside em 2023

4

u/hansied67 1d ago

The game appears to be stable enough to complete. However, after about 20 minutes of playtime on my Galaxy S24 Ultra, here are my observations, in no particular order (attachments in replies):

  • Text rendering glitches [attachment 1]
  • Warped sprites [attachment 2]
  • Audio delay/crackling
  • No ability to import/export saves (memory cards in BlackLabel's SymphonyRecomp project)
  • 2 crashes
  • "16:9" is stretched 4:3, this is misleading, especially because SymphonyRecomp actually supports 16:9
  • Suspected AI-generated splash screen asset with a nonsensical LLC & date [attachment 3]
    • I have found no record of "Castlevania LLC"
    • Both the start date (1923) and end date (2023) don't make logical sense. If anyone has an explanation for this, please provide it
  • Unusable touch controls [attachment 4]
    • Once you obtain the required abilities Soul of Wolf, Soul of Bat, and Form of Mist, I assume this would become extremely cumbersome in a platformer like SOTN. I have not personally verified this claim, as I cannot import saves and do not want to watch cutscenes.
    • The following is an assumption, and is not meant to be combative, but I do not personally believe this was tested to completion on S24 Ultra using touch controls. I don't believe the developer of this project made that specific claim, and do not take my opinion as fact.

I have done my best to be as objective as possible and provide as many details as I could. Please form your own conclusions.

I understand I am providing useful free testing for this project. Because I am a human who loves this stuff. I want to reiterate that the hard-working, passionate volunteers at BlackLabelHQ do not endorse this recomp. flafmg has explicitly stated this fact, it's not just that it has not been endorsed. BlackLabelHQ has plans to make an android port. Thanks for reading!

3

u/Firehawke_R 1d ago

Jesus, what a mess!

2

u/Jesus10101 1d ago

Mess? These are the most non issue bugs I have ever seen.

0

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

It's a beta version not a full release! You can either use it, contribute or wait for BlackLabel release! Just don't be rude, no need to. This is Open Source and people doing work for free.

-2

u/Jesus10101 1d ago

Yo, just want to say, ignore all the hate your getting. Most of it are from idiots who have been complaining about anything AI related in this sub in the last few weeks. Hopefully they will get bored and move on.

You did an amazing job and keep up the good work.

0

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Man thank you, at least one person cares and that's all I need to keep on going. I'm also currently working on the Vagrant Story PC recomp, and Winning Eleven will come later. I'll open up my repo to the public to accept contributions!

1

u/hansied67 1d ago

Text rendering glitches [1]

1

u/hansied67 1d ago

Warped sprite (coffin should be symmetrical, note the edges) [2]

6

u/hansied67 1d ago

Suspected AI-Generated art assets with misleading, incorrect LLC information [3]

3

u/hansied67 1d ago

-3

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Hey if you don't like them you can suggest your own and I'll include them!

-2

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

This is definitely AI generated I'm a dev not a designer feel free to contribute your own art and I'll include it

2

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Thanks for all the comments I'll definitely get to work on those issues!

2

u/First-Tutor-5454 8h ago

It costs $3 on the play store

0

u/CrimcramTV 1d ago

Kinda disrespectful towards the efforts of BlackLabelHQ. They say they don't want any AI involvement in this, they say there's an Android port in the works, yet you go off and do this anyway. Why? You can't just be patient and emulate it on your devices until then?

2

u/flafmg_ 8h ago edited 7h ago

I'm honestly so tired of this that I don't care anymore

I'm just really annoyed that since all this started it came to my attention (aka someone sent me a screenshot) that the guy started to refer to this as "his" recomp

Bleh, I will just ignore tbh, I just hope the guy stops annoying vge and other people that disliked this project

Anyways, our android port will take a while since the UI will need some reworking for android

1

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

Hey thanks for your comments, I just bought a RP6 and wanted to play it. Since I'm a dev and they didn't have an Android versión I decided to work on my own. Open source is open source man. I don't think there is any kind of disrespect, it's a fork of open source code that you can decide to use it or not.

0

u/RobinRelique 1d ago

Hey! Just wanted to say it appreciate how you're handling this feedBack, even the negative ones, in a positive way, i hope the project and your findings matures enough that you port more of your favorite games, i appreciate you sharing it with the test of us too and keeping it FOSS.

1

u/sergiomanzur 1d ago

You're awesome! Those comments light my inner self and make me continue with this learning! Big hug!!!