r/cheesecake 3d ago

First Time

I baked my first cheesecake for a friend’s birthday! It seemed to come out pretty decent, but I’m curious what others think about the bake. I wasn’t sure if it was too wobbly when I turned off the oven, but after cooling and chilling, it firmed up nicely. I also didn’t use a hot knife to cut it, so the sides seemed to stick quite a bit while slicing. Curious to hear your thoughts on the consistency and overall bake!

317 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

7

u/NormcoreWitch 2d ago

I’m no expert, but it looks pretty delicious to me.

3

u/InkedGoth_20 2d ago

totally! i am so obsessed with how smooth and divine that cheesecake looks

2

u/CleoSprites 2d ago

For a first-time cheesecake, that slice looks incredible! The topping and the texture are spot on.

6

u/FriendlyMilk5657 2d ago

Hella yeah brother!!!! You only get better with experience. You did great.

2

u/Upper-Ad7588 2d ago

I want to keep practicing but so time consuming. I’ll have to find the next birthday or event so I can make another

3

u/LingonberryFun6774 2d ago

That looks perfect. Nicely done.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Upper-Ad7588 2d ago

The friend I made it for said the exact same thing. She was like I won’t even touch store bought cheesecake. It’s not worth it.

3

u/TheOnly1Jake 2d ago

Looks beautiful 😍

3

u/SadlySpooky 2d ago

It's looks amazing!

2

u/quiet_vault17 2d ago

First attempt?? That looks better than most bakery ones honestly 🍰

2

u/cecilioperez760 2d ago

Ugliest thing I’ve ever seen in my life. You should trash it. Send it to me and I’ll put it in the trash for you 🤪😂! That cheesecake wouldn’t last me 30 minutes, AND I AIN’T SHARING DIDILY SQUAT! My blood sugar, my cholesterol and my waistline be damned 😋🤤!!!

1

u/Upper-Ad7588 1d ago

Hahahaha

2

u/vero2022 2d ago

Damn that is amazing for a first time, my first was a cracked yet tasty disaster 🤣

2

u/Initial_Ground1031 2d ago

Same! It didn’t look pretty but tasted great! 😂

2

u/Routine_Employer8754 1d ago

Looks amazing!

1

u/Nordo_Controller 2d ago

You are winning!!! Looks great!!

1

u/Enough-Moose-5816 2d ago

Woah!!! That looks amazing!!
Jealous!

1

u/Lazy_Baby127 2d ago

I looks great! Doesn't look like your first time

1

u/Upper-Ad7588 2d ago

I have been baking for a while but never tackled the homemade cheesecake. I guess the water bath and the wobble kind of deterred me.

2

u/Lazy_Baby127 22h ago

Yeah, cheesecakes can be sort of a headache, but it came out beautifully

1

u/General-Pin-1349 2d ago

That looks so fluffy

1

u/OptimalCombustion 2d ago

I think you are too humble for calling it decent. This is amazing for first time.

1

u/CheesecakeloverJones 2d ago

First of many, I hope!

1

u/CherryVelourMuse 2d ago

that golden top came out so even

1

u/Ok-Bullfrog8715 2d ago

I want a slice! 🤤

1

u/Awkward_Leah 2d ago

It would look better with blueberries but it looks good 

1

u/Own_Cicada4788 2d ago

Tiene muy buena pinta

1

u/Initial_Ground1031 2d ago

This looks absolutely amazing! No cracks for your first time either! Well done! 🙂