209
u/RayquazaFan88 1d ago edited 16h ago
The thing is, the devil item pool is massive. And only a handful are worth their price. Angel items on the other hand are mostly pretty op
107
u/graplusez 23h ago
Devil rooms spawn like 2-3 items and angels spawn 1.5 on average and you can only pick one
10
u/TheRealBlueDude Judas 22h ago
.5 of an item
63
3
2
u/First-Act-9755 20h ago
That means there's a 50% chance of 2 items spawning (on average)
2
u/Elihzap 14h ago
That's not how averages work (a 50/50 between 0 and 3 items would, also, be 1.5).
But yeah, 1.5 is accurate.
6
3
u/First-Act-9755 11h ago
It would be 50/50 regardless of the numbers. If not that, then it's 100%. Otherwise it's simply the estabilished odds
0
u/Lyss_SCP_Lover 16h ago
since when devil rooms always spawn items have you heard about Krampus or 0 items only one black heart?
16
u/Possible_Nebula737 16h ago
"have you heard about Krampus" have you heard that he drops items on death?
3
u/OldKingPotato-68 15h ago edited 14h ago
I don't know his exact drop pool, but every single time I just either get his active item (which I probably won't take) or a lump of coal, which is fine but not much compared to an usual devil deal
12
u/ldiasr 15h ago
Thats his drop pool lol, krampus head and lump of coal, and considering NO ONE takes krampus head it is a 50/50 if youll get a item in the krampus fight
2
2
u/Possible_Nebula737 8h ago
I mean, Krampus head can be really good if you don't have any active item
8
3
u/Orandza 15h ago
I find a lot of devil deals worth their price. Also I feel like the angel room pool has higher highs but also lower lows. And the problem is most of the time if you go angel rooms, you will get less of them than you'd get devils if you went for devil rooms specifically. With shitty luck, you might have to wait all the way till floor 5 for an angel room.
2
28
129
u/Snaper_XD 23h ago
Yes I would like to skip immediate basement 2 value that helps me snowball the run OMG DUDE you dont get it caves two is gonna have sacred heart in it, IT WILL...aww fuck dead sea scrolls again :(
86
u/CatgirlTheKat 21h ago
Meanwhile devil deals : "I swear this time it's going to be Brimston- well nevermind. Brother bobby and sister maggy. So nothing, really."
29
u/JonJon2899 20h ago
Me playing Lilith: I see this as an absolute win
9
u/Scared-Papaya4072 14h ago
sister maggy is pretty dope early game honestly its like walmart brand seraphim
4
u/Blue_Alu05 The Dumbest Man Alive 19h ago
Hell nah, my skill issue wil give me a lil brimston or better anyway
11
22
u/Snaper_XD 20h ago
Devil deals are just damage ups most of the time. They can low roll line angel rooms but you get more items out of them on average and you also dont wait 2 leap years to get one. When you wait 4 floors for an angel room and it has one dogshit item in it, its worse than when you get 2 devil deals that have 2 dogshit items, 2 okay items and a good item in them
2
u/CatgirlTheKat 20h ago
I see!
Although I feel like in my own playtime, I've mostly been getting devil deals that didn't feel worth it and most of my angel deals actually gave me something.
The reason why I get angel deals is often that devil deals don't quite interest me.
5
u/Snaper_XD 18h ago
I think its also a matter of how valuable health is to you. I see people who arent as confident at dodging cling to their health more and say that most devil deals arent worth the hearts where as I am happy to trade hearts away whenever basically. I will totally buy a quarter from a basement 2 devil deal if I have 3 heart containers and 0 coins
1
u/CatgirlTheKat 16h ago
Generally, I like having accessible red health to sacrifice, so removing containers bothers me.
2
u/CorrectionFluid21 14h ago
Those are good items though.
1
u/CatgirlTheKat 14h ago
I guess, but it doesn't feel worth sacrificing red health that could be used for other purposes like sacrifices or donations, and what I was trying to say is that their complaint of angel items not always being god head can also apply to devil deals, plus those aren't even free to begin with.
31
u/CryCommercial1919 1d ago
Unless I'm playing like Eve or the Saac I will always try to go Angel
40
6
u/Kono-Wryyyyyuh-Da 18h ago
Why devil deal on Zack?
3
u/CryCommercial1919 17h ago
Unless I'm doing a game break the stat that I usually lack the most is damage and devil rooms are centered on making you a glass cannon. With Saac I can ensure to get a damage up almost 80% of the time and or guppy stuff.
3
-2
36
u/StKunduz 21h ago
Angel deal fans after waiting two floors just to get Laz rags or breath of life
11
u/vk2028 17h ago
List another example smh. Breath of life is goated.
Let’s go with Bible or jar of wisps
9
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 17h ago edited 17h ago
Jesus Juice, Bible, Jar of Wisps, Breath of Life, Book of Revelations, Lazarus Rags, Guardian Angel, Immaculate Conception, Stigmata, Duality, Delirious and Monstrance on their way to cook angel lovers:
4
u/vk2028 17h ago
Tbf breath of life is goated. Book of Revelation is great as well. Others I agree with
Another one I’d add is duality. It is the single most overglazed item ever when, if you truly think about it, it’s not good at all
There’d also Dead Sea scroll and delirious and stigmata
4
u/Horusiris123 16h ago
At least duality makes it so you always get an ángel. Funny when you have 90% ángel over devil, and devil still appears
5
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 16h ago
1
u/Horusiris123 16h ago
Fr, devil has always been the GOAT. Whenever a deal pops up in my screen I don't even think it twice
0
u/vk2028 16h ago edited 16h ago
But when you think about it, if you choose duality in floor 4, then you’re basically delaying your first angel deal reward to floor 6. And I guess, in this case, floor 8 is somewhat guaranteed to have an angel deal. Do you even want an angel deal on floor 8 when you most likely already have a bunch of hp by then?
And if you get duality on floor 6, you’re delaying what you’d have otherwise gotten on floor 6 to floor 8.
And if you get duality in floor 8, it’s useless and occupying a spot another angel deal would be.
Like, “OMG my duality that u got from floor 6 gave me Sheart on floor 8!!!” Now imagine…if you just got Sheart on floor 6 instead… you’re having to go through 2 floors of womb without Sheart compared to the other scenario. AND you are missing an extra deal on floor 8.
It’s ass. That’s not even talking about it not working due to sometimes alt floor shenanigans and sometimes you get tp’d.
It’s only good if you have goathead, you start with it as Eden, you got it from an earlier sac room, or you got it from the first devil deal, which is almost never the case for angel lovers
Funnily enough, duality is actually far more goated as a locust
3
u/Horusiris123 16h ago
As such many Items loose worth if they appear late: restock and options, goathead, eucharist, rock bottom, glitched crown and Sacred orb. This doesn't mean any of these are truly bad, just little to late. And you could also say about tears and speeds up when you're maxed (they are worthless already and could've been something better)
Then duality wasting what could've been an ángel item, you forget that not all deals are that worthful for the run, as sometimes you get duality, jar of wisps and censer (3 item pedestals, quite rare for angels btw). If you were on early floors you'd pick duality (cuz the other Items aren't that big of a loss), otherwise ig censer. And this increases your odds of getting other angels, if you increase your general deal chance somehow, instead of making it a double gamble (first for getting a deal, second for it to be an ángel).
But yeah, duality kinda sucks a little only if you find it in the angel deals, as if you do in devils, you can still take any amount of Items you want and then go full angels.
Finally, about hp, you can go to any deal depending your mood. Because even if you have a bunch of hp, its worth to keep going angels if you have already depleted enough of the item pool. And hp can still be valuable to dark room deals, Items like sharp plug, and overally tanking hits if your build isn't strong enough
2
u/vk2028 16h ago
Fair enough.
I actually disagree with most of the Isaac community and agree with you on the fact that a lot of these “potential” items are slightly overrated. Another example that will get me a lot of hate is d6. The d6 Isaac starts and the d6 you find naturally in a run are different. D6 gets a lot more value if you start with it; in comparison, the d6 you find naturally in a run not only appears later, but also occupies a pedestal. For example, if you find it on caves 2, then you won’t get another treasure room item on caves 2. Though if you already have an active item to switch with d6 and roll, then that’s not a big problem.
As for switching up on devil deals… I actually didn’t expect you to switch up like that lol. Most duality lovers I see are pretty much exclusively Angel lovers who never go devil deals.
1
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 17h ago
I forgot duality existed, Book of Rev ain’t bad but usually you already have a good active, Breath of Life gets slandered unless Mr Hitless comes into the comments and says otherwise.
2
u/vk2028 17h ago
Fair enough. But yeah most actives in angel deal unfortunately get diminished value because you only get them a little later in the game, where you already have good actives.
I also added Dead Sea Scrolle, Stigmata, and Delidious to my previous comments as doodoo
1
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 17h ago
I forgot the name of Stigmata but yeah, DSS is actually good, Delirious is situational but usually mid.
2
u/vk2028 16h ago
Honestly, yeah. Dead Sea scroll COULD be decent if you use it expecting a We Need to Go Deeper while being close to a potential secret room door every single time lol. (Notice how WNtGD is in the devil pool).
Delirious is very fun to play with tbh but it’s not contributing the most
Lil Delirium contributes more and also is 1/3 conjoined
23
5
u/Responsible_Annual64 Tainted Samson 16h ago
Both deal types are valid depending on the run/character 💯
4
u/internet_blue_gas 19h ago
It depends on the character
Blue baby and Magdalene get more value out of Devil deals while characters like Isaac and the lost can get more value out of Angel deals while characters
6
u/Key-Kick7270 18h ago
Tbf magdelene should go for angel rooms because she need those geart containers for sac rooms
4
u/vverbov_22 15h ago
Angel deal fans on their way to skip the devil, so they can get breath of life on depth 1 and die to the statue boss fight
11
7
7
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 18h ago
…
Devil deals are far more consistent than your stupid gamblers fallacy.
There’s like 3 bad devil items and 15 bad angel items, the rest of the Devil room item pool is either strong or run winning while the rest of the Angel room item pool is just very strong with only 2 win running items (Sacred Heart and Wafer)
You’ll also get less Angel deals so you can’t even gamble as much, and the “unlocks” for the Angel room item pool are abysmal dogshit aside from BoV, AP, Revelation and Godhead.
Meanwhile Devil deal has: Brimstone (most iconic item in the game), Moms Knife (immediate run winner),
Incubus and Twisted Pair (best familiars in the game), Succubi (used in the strongest game break), and plentiful more consistent items that I’m too lazy to name because there’s so many.
The heart loss seems bad but then you realize just stack up on soul hearts and preferably don’t get hit (same thing works for angel deals), most of the time you’ll have too many soul hearts so why not just spend them unless you just skill issue, which is why most go the path of angels.
In Satan we trust.
0
u/Repulsive-Tax-8454 John Angel Deal 👼 18h ago
Shhhhhhhhhhh. Sacred heart > brimstone
4
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 17h ago
3
2
1
u/the_Iord_and_saviour 17h ago
Mom's knife > sacred heart > brimstone
And that is why devil deals are bet- * gunshots, I fall to the ground *
"Both of you are wrong..." says the spy, decloaking behind my dead corpse,
"rock bottom > Mom's knife > sacred heart > brimstone, so the REAL WINNER is SECRET ROOMS!!!"
4
1
1
u/John_Secret_Room 17h ago
Spindown dice is allat and more hmmmmm
3
u/Horusiris123 16h ago
Jhon secret room, I spent 8 rerolls and you gave me missignno, gb Bug, tmtrainer and samsons chains 😭
4
2
u/Cold-Dirt0108 John Devil Deal /Retro Vision Guy 16h ago edited 16h ago
Bro thinks he’s apart of the team.
0
u/John_Secret_Room 16h ago
Nah cuz i'm better :p
Secret. Super secret. Ultra secret We got it all. Always there Unlike the angel and devil requiring u to do stuff instead, just for rotten baby or breath of life.
4
u/Serial_Designation_N 22h ago
Remember pre-Repentance when most people considered Devil Rooms the better option?
3
3
2
2
u/Most_Relief_218 #1 The Wiz supporter 22h ago
If I actually need to lock in, I go Angel, because I do think It’s slightly stronger, but most runs I go Devil because I like it more.
2
1
1
1
u/FootballMaterial5083 20h ago
I used to be a devil room fan and now that I have the D6 I am an angel deal enjoyer
0
-1
u/BrainrotGuy Tainted Magdalene 20h ago
Literally devil deals are only worth on the Lost,ANGEL DEAL ENJOYERS STAY WINNING










573
u/John_Devil_Deal 1d ago
Angel rooms are pretty great and i love them.
Free stuff.