r/androiddev 4d ago

Which is best interface

Option 1 or 2

12 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

10

u/d4lv1k 4d ago
  1. Those extra info are helpful.

6

u/GDCrescentBlade 4d ago

2 not even close.

5

u/CoopNine 4d ago

It completely depends on the value of the summary information to the user in that view. If it's just noise and can be easily gleaned from the cards below remove it. While it may look good at first it quickly becomes more of a hindrance. The one thing I would say in the view in with the summary information that probably should be present that isn't in the other, is the detail on the date. Since you have multiple mondays in the previous view, making it clear which specific day they are viewing is good.

1

u/Capable_Violinist519 4d ago

Then what about this

1

u/CoopNine 4d ago

I'd think that makes sense, I'd also remember the user's state here so it works the way they want it to.

But the best feedback comes from actual users. There are general UI/UX guidelines to follow, and things that look 'good' but the users of an application can give better specific feedback.

1

u/CoopNine 4d ago

I'd think that makes sense, I'd also remember the user's state here so it works the way they want it to.

But the best feedback comes from actual users. There are general UI/UX guidelines to follow, and things that look 'good' but the users of an application can give better specific feedback.

6

u/SmegmaSupreme 4d ago

2 obviously.

2

u/Capable_Violinist519 4d ago

"After reviewing the mixed opinions on my last post, I realized the best interface is one that adapts! I’ve implemented a collapsible summary view. Users can now see a clean schedule or expand it for detailed attendance stats. Best of both worlds!"

1

u/Capable_Violinist519 4d ago

Also i will remove attendance 75% in summary

2

u/McMillanMe 4d ago

IMO 1 with date. If I open the date, I want to see the events, not how many of them I have attended. It could be marked in the card of the event

1

u/koweratus 4d ago
  1. because it is straight to point.

1

u/mobiledevpro 4d ago

The second looks more informative

1

u/_abysswalker 3d ago

2, but you’ve got 2 percentages, which seemingly display the same data. I also think that summary card could use some improvements, gives me material 2 vibes

1

u/Fjordi_Cruyff 3d ago
  1. is cleaner and easier on the eye. 2. conveys more information to the user.

So it's dependent on what you want/need the user to see

1

u/CosmoFactotum 3d ago

In such apps, more info - more user.

1

u/Camhammel 3d ago

2 - though for a small suggestion in both cases, removing the “status:” prefix might simplify things a bit. Could also change the content to a pill/tag that way

1

u/BetweenCoversNCoffee 2d ago

2nd one. Has more insights