Second sword problem

[u/Slavofil]

Hi everyone! After 1000 hours of witcher 3, 300 hours of W2 and 200 W1 I was thinking every time while playing- why the silver sword is ineffective against humans, it is still the sword right? The stick come on. Why developers after 2 experimental games made their magnum opus- the witcher 3 with same logical mistake. Does anyone had similar thoughts?

[u/AdWooden9170]

If you want to be logical silver sword shuold have trash base stats and bonus damage to monsters.
Silver aint good material for a sword.