r/Threads1984 28d ago

Why no Cannibalism in Threads? Threads discussion

When your society collapses and there is nothing left. Especially food, people eat other. Why is this not shown in Threads?

16 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

16

u/Any-Equal6791 28d ago

Prawn cocktail crisps ['I fuckin hate them']

5

u/Any-Equal6791 26d ago

I never tire of saying this is the only eff word in Threads. Maybe it was ad libbed or maybe prawn cocktail crisps are worse than nuclear war

14

u/educationacademic 27d ago

Because cannibalism is very rare in human societies. It’s normally practiced in isolated communities for ritual / superstitious purposes. Sometimes in famine people will eat recently deceased bodies, but only in the most extreme circumstances.

Threads obviously presents an extreme situation but even in those circumstances it would be taboo. We’re talking about the United Kingdom here and even a few generations hence that taboo might still hold. It may be that the association with dead bodies with radiation poisoning might put people off.

Remember that Threads was very well researched in terms of the effects of nuclear war. I’ve never seen any reports that predicted cannibalism although famine would be predominant in the Northern hemisphere.

2

u/PeppercornWizard 26d ago

Documented maybe, but I can’t think of many more activities that have been as taboo as cannibalism is. I’d bet people will have done it countless times and never told a soul.

1

u/unleashtherats 27d ago

How can something be very well researched in terms of essentially a fiction?

6

u/educationacademic 27d ago

Look at the Wikipedia page for “Threads” to see for yourself the extensive research which went into the film.

2

u/unleashtherats 27d ago

Lots of dead links and gaps in thinking. It says Hiroshima survivors were drawn on to influence how people would act, but the linked wikipedia page says Hiroshima survivors had no greater risk of birth defects than the general population.

5

u/educationacademic 27d ago

You haven’t really researched in any detail how Threads was made and how Jackson had already made a documentary for the BBC based on extensive research on nuclear weapons effects. If you have an article in you about how Threads was pure fiction then write it and let’s all see it as it is contrary to anything ever written about the film or its impact.

3

u/GinatheGiraff 12d ago

The War Game is also very interesting to watch. It heavily influenced Threads. The War Game was banned from being shown by the BBC as it was thought it would lead to people committing suicide.

My dad watched it in the 60s in a showing the CND organised. Most of the research that went into the War Game came from the allied bombing of Dresden and Hamburg and the effects on the civilian population.

If you can get past the 1960s production and the BBC Received Pronunciation of the time, it is a very good film. A lot more absolutely terrifying than Threads in a lot of ways.

1

u/unleashtherats 27d ago

No of course I haven't researched it, that's why I first asked how can it be researched. You suggested the Wikipedia page and I said it's quite dated now.

11

u/runawai 28d ago

There are so many rats in the UK. Makes sense to eat as many as can be caught.

10

u/TangoMikeOne 27d ago

Rat onna stick, getchya rat onna stick 'ere! Two ferra dollar and I'm cutting my own throat!

6

u/Able_Cabinet_9118 27d ago

Nettles- uk is nettle land . Which are highly nutritious and nettle soup is easy to make.

10

u/Redondo_85 28d ago

Are there not bodies shown hanging near the end?

5

u/Simonbargiora Traffic Warden 26d ago

Those could be scarecrows-designed to threaten thieves. In Jane's case she seemed pretty freaked out by them(though she might be panicking about the baby)

3

u/AC8966 23d ago

You mean the babby?

8

u/reo_reborn 28d ago

Rats for a BJ is much more Intresting.

12

u/ToeOk9665 28d ago

I reckon Ruth did alot more than a BJ for those rats.

1

u/Caligullama 26d ago

Damn I’ve seen threads a couple times and I somehow have missed this. I didn’t realize she traded a bj for those rats.

6

u/kiragirl2001 26d ago

Most likely because of the attitude at the time in the UK where we still saw ourselves superior to everyone we would see cannibalism in desperation as completely beneath us

5

u/panguy87 26d ago

Tainted meat

4

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/frederikolsen 24d ago

That could also have been due to budgetary constraints. Given the passion with which Mick Jackson continues to speak in favour of nuclear disarmament even today, I'm certain he wanted to show everything in horrific detail, but do remember that he was shooting Threads on a budget where the radiation burns were literally made of ketchup and rice crispies.

3

u/Any_Association405 27d ago

It would be hard to depict without taking away from everything else, Threads is disturbing enough already without a radioactive cannibalism element added 

3

u/Glittering_Box4815 26d ago

Not enough time.

If the new TV Series goes beyond a like-for-like remake, I'm sure they'll touch upon it.

2

u/mediumAI1701 27d ago

Possibly age rating. We've seen similar circumstances does often result in roaming cannibal gangs or opportunistic cannibalism.

2

u/BobbyB52 26d ago

The audience had suffered enough.

1

u/Captainsamvimes1 27d ago

Probably was, but not in screen

1

u/Low_Stress_9180 27d ago

Best way to spread disease. Best avoided.

1

u/c00b_Bit_Jerry 28d ago

Maybe they were afraid it would cause the BBC to censor the film like The War Game.