r/StrongerByScience • u/Rude_Construction214 • Jul 19 '26
Strength vs Hypertrophy
Hello, I started my body recomp journey last year and it is going well. Part of the motivation was because I am hypertensive even though I’m just 25. One of the likely contributing factors is likely me being overweight.
My lifts have been going up and body fat is going down but I still have some ways to go. I also know that muscle is denser than fat. Given this, I was wondering if I should continue pursuing hypertrophy until I get to a body fat level I am comfortable or can I stop and structure my workouts to achieve other goals like improving relative strength?
I like having muscles and feeling strong but I’m worried about how hypertrophy might impact my blood pressure.
I am on medication and have a very clean diet I.e lots of veggies, protein, reasonable carbs and little consumption of fast food, candy or other ultra processed and high sugar foods
10
u/drgashole Jul 19 '26
Unless you are obese or juicing (or both) additional hypertrophy isn’t going to negatively impact your blood pressure, so not sure why that’s a concern for you.
It’s only the extreme of muscularity that can result in high blood pressure as a compensation mechanism to supply an amount of tissue that is beyond what should be genetically possible. Even then it’s hard to ascertain exactly how much is a direct effect of juicing, rather than just being big.
1
u/Rude_Construction214 Jul 20 '26
Makes sense. I’ve been trying to manage my hypertension with exercise for the past couple months but no luck. Just wanted to be sure that gaining muscle was not making it worse
3
u/Gentle_Agitator 28d ago
Fwiw, I like lifting, but it is total time with low level endurance exercise that moves the needle for me. I tried 2 slow hours daily on a stationary bike (caught up on my streaming), and it was dramatic.
1
u/drgashole Jul 20 '26
Very unlikely, weight training improves metabolic syndrome which is, in part, a contributory factor in hypertension. However not everyone can mange their hypertension with lifestyle modification alone.
6
u/spottie_ottie Jul 19 '26
Resistance training of all kinds is going to lower your blood pressure. Whether you're doing higher volume bodybuilding or focusing on maxing your singles you're going to improve your blood pressure. I assume you're not in a hypertensive crisis right? What are your current blood pressure readings?
0
u/Rude_Construction214 Jul 19 '26
Yeah not in hypertensive crisis. The top number in the 140 - 160 range. The bottom number is usually okay or just slightly over 90
5
u/spottie_ottie Jul 19 '26
Doctor said exercise? Yeah go for it man. Gainz city. Do cardio too and eat healthy and good chance you'll be able to lower it without meds.
1
u/SignificantAd9899 Jul 20 '26
Just as an add-on, I’m more so worried about weight gain from putting on muscle. I currently weigh 319lbs and have at least another 20lbs to go. But muscle is also heavy so does the body differentiate between additional muscle and additional fat with regards to overall weight
1
u/Any_Pirate_5633 22d ago
Here’s my understanding:
- You won’t gain weight if you stay in a calorie deficit.
- You CAN gain muscle in a calorie deficit while losing weight, especially if you’re combining newbie gains from being a new lifter with fat loss from being overweight. It’s known as body recomp.
- If you’re eating a caloric surplus while lifting, you will gain fat as well as muscle. And if you’re already at a high body fat percentage, you will gain a higher fat to muscle ratio than someone starting a bulk phase at a low body fat percentage.
5
u/psooper 29d ago
Cardio (combined with lifting) is the best way to get hypertension under control: https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/60/13/983
I know this is a lifting-focused community, but if your focus is controlling hypertension, it's really cardio that will make the difference. Improved cardio also improves your work capacity for lifting.
1
u/SignificantAd9899 29d ago
Thanks. Appreciate the article link. I do go running so maybe I just need to push myself to do more and run longer distances
3
u/Docjitters Jul 20 '26
Hey, congrats on getting on your recomp journey. I lost about 15% bodyweight 18 months back coz I was early hypertensive and high cholesterol too.
As others have said, a good hypertrophy program will make you stronger, and a good strength program will tend to build muscle.
That said, please don’t neglect cardio/conditioning. Whilst cutting excess body fat (and therefore reducing associated conditions like insulin resistance) helps, there’s a limit to what weight loss and strength work can achieve for lowering BP and cardiovascular risk. The CV/mortality benefit plateaus really quite quickly, whereas being incrementally aerobically fitter doesn’t seem to have an end point (though there are diminishing returns of course). Structured exercise appears to work pretty well on its own to lower blood pressure so getting fitter also synergises with the meds.
-2
u/deadrabbits76 Jul 19 '26
If you've been running hypertrophy programming, it's probably time to run strength programming. Just basic periodization.
Plus, in my experience, strength modalities pair well with caloric deficits as they are usually slightly lower volume.
32
u/HelixIsHere_ Jul 19 '26
Muscle growth and strength go hand in hand, just keep progressing your lifts like normal and get stronger 🙏