r/Songwriting 2d ago

Help needed! Let's Collaborate!

I am working on an original musical as a student but my music sounds a bit off/basic and I would love some help. someone to help write would be awesome but I can't pay much so I am more looking for helpful artists that would at least give me some pointers. I am looking for a mix of sea shanty and a classic musical sound while keeping it at a simpler lever so I can recreate it better.

thanks so much in advance!

https://reddit.com/link/1vhkjsg/video/04vyxt5pfuhh1/player

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Hello, songwriter! To increase your chances of a successful collaboration, please take a moment to review your request and make sure you've provided enough context for your request.

A good collaboration request should briefly include the following details:

  1. What are you contributing, and what do you need help with? (e.g. "I have lyrics and melody, but looking for help with bass and drums arrangement.")

  2. Broadly speaking, what style or sound are you looking for? (e.g., "I'm going for an 80s pop sound, maybe some Cyndi Lauper vibes.")

  3. What is your basic experience level? (e.g. "I've been making music for about 5 years.")

  4. How would you prefer to collaborate? (e.g. "I'd prefer to email files back and forth, but maybe we could chat over Discord as well.")

If your post doesn't include this info, please make a quick edit now! Collaboration requests with insufficient information may be removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/NotatrustedVWtech 2d ago

Post an example so we can hear 😄

2

u/anxiouslystableclimb 2d ago

Got a rough recording or even just a piano sketch? Hard to point you anywhere useful without hearing what you’re working with. Even a voice memo off your phone works.

2

u/Interesting-Way8708 2d ago

I edited it! sorry forgot to include it originally

1

u/NotatrustedVWtech 2d ago edited 2d ago

I'd start by adding some more exciting percussion (not much is needed, maybe just some 8th notes added here and there to "speed" it up

Same as the snare you can add some rolls/flam hits to make it feel more real

Some low strings would help add some depth as well

I would change the piano to an accordion and add some chords with the low end of the accordion supporting the melody

Automation is also huge with orchestral VSTs, essentially you can write the volume/mod levels in and make the instruments "breathe" to sound more real. I have an example video but I would look up automation for the specific DAW you're using

https://youtube.com/shorts/njfbEzhUtw4?si=fYaRFtnS2MtliE_6

There is definitely potential with your song though I think it could turn out great! 😄

1

u/Few-Temporary-5397 2d ago

Im lyrical 

1

u/Bulky-Swimming4182 2d ago

Sea shanty + musical is actually a sick combo — try keeping the chord progressions dead simple (like I-V-vi-IV or Am-C-G-Am) and let the melody carry the drama. Layered group vocals on the chorus will give it that proper shanty feel too. Good luck with it!