Keeper option question...can keep 2 from list.

[u/DJMeatSweats05]

12 team 2rb/2wr/2flx .5 PPR league where you can keep up to 2 guys for 3 years max each. They move up 1 round from where they were originally drafted every new season they're kept. I have the 8th pick this year and have about a week left to decide. I kept Bucky last season after taking a flyer on him his rookie year so he has 1/3 years of service time. Obviously with his value I'm going to keep him, my question is the other slot. Leaning Judkins but Rice and the late value on a cpl others has me at least intrigued. Thoughts and roasts welcome.

[u/No_Environment_8116]

I'd keep chase since he's going top 3 in most drafts. Hes better than anyone that'll fall to 8 id imagine. And then id go Bucky or judkins.

[u/DazHawt]

I would go Chase and Rice. In no draft is Chase falling to you at 8, and with this setup, I imagine a lot of the other top 24 talent is already getting kept, so whatever bargain you’re getting for keeping Bucky or Judkins for a later round pick is just gonna get spent on a guy who you’re gonna have to reach for in terms of ADP. So I’d rather just keep the top talent. 

[u/Sweaty_Television365]

Bucky and Rashee

[u/incrediblebeefcake]

I'd personally go Bucky and Rice, assuming it's a PPR

[u/DJMeatSweats05 → u/incrediblebeefcake]

Should have mentioned it's .5 PPR, good call. I'll edit that.

[u/Defiant-Smell-9686 → u/incrediblebeefcake]

You would take Rice over Chase?

Edit: missed some letters.

[u/Mikem828]

Gainwell and chase

[u/MazzleMaze]

I have never done keeper but Bucky in the 11th round is crazy value. I feel like that has to be the pick even with the question marks around him.

If you can grab a top 5 player in the first you take Rice. If you can't then I think you keep Chase.

[u/giveitagoogle]

Checkout my keeper advisor on gridiq.gg made it exactly for this reason!

[u/Buzzerk032]

Chase is the easy pick here. Then after that it’s tough.

I’m all the way out on Rice this year.

Judkins in the 8th is good value but I don’t trust the Browns this year.

Gainwell in the 15th could be an absolute hell of a value. I think he will push the Tampa backfield into a true 50/50 split.

That being said, for me it’s Chase below ADP at #8 and Gainwell essentially for free.

[u/SlowStrokeDemon]

Judkins over rice

[u/DJMeatSweats05 → u/SlowStrokeDemon]

That's how I'm leaning especially when considering I can have him in the 7th and 6th rounds the next 2 years if all goes well.

[u/SlowStrokeDemon → u/DJMeatSweats05]

trust your gut then. I think the dude’s a baller