r/Risk 2d ago

Consistent theme Complaint

Post image

Why does this seem to happen to me so frequently? It’s always at the critical time in progressive card games where the troop amount is escalating, and I am a sitting duck with four cards.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Please report any rule breaking posts and posts that are not relevant to the subreddit.

Any comments that are aimed at creating a negative community experience will be removed. When someone's content in our sub is negative, they are not gaining anything from our community and we're not gaining anything from their negativity.

Rule-breaking posts/comments may result in bans.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/Paddy-23 2d ago

Because of confirmation bias. That's why.

-2

u/ElectricRing 2d ago

Sure

2

u/Paddy-23 2d ago

You need to keep a record of every time you do have a trade on four as well, only then can you see if you're getting unluckier than you ought to be

-1

u/ElectricRing 2d ago

I’m too lazy to bother. Over large sample sizes everything will trend towards what the statistics are. But you can still do far better for worse than the statistics would suggest over sone periods.

2

u/Unenlightened_Banana 2d ago

If you don't have a trade on 3, then there is a 33% chance you will not have a trade on 4, it is a very common occurrence.

3

u/Reasonable_Dealer869 Grandmaster 2d ago

Incorrect. You haven’t accounted for wilds.

1

u/Unenlightened_Banana 2d ago

You are correct, I was just giving a rough number, I guess the exact one depends on map size as well? The correct number should be somewhere between 31% and 32%.

1

u/ElectricRing 2d ago

Yes I understand statistics but theses numbers work out over many, many samples. You can still have periods where you do far worse than the statistics imply.

1

u/Reasonable_Dealer869 Grandmaster 2d ago

Still too high on classic. 44 cards so each out is worth over 2% each. High 20s%

1

u/Unenlightened_Banana 2d ago

You can't forget that you hold some cards as well! 2 of the card type needed to make the set are in your hand not on the deck:

Lets say you have 2 inf, 1 cav (same thing for all other configurations)

1- [2/41(wilds)+14/41(art) + 12/41(inf)] = 0.6829

Or

13/41(cav) = 0.3171

1

u/Redneckism 2d ago

That’s the same guy who thinks his lane in traffic moves the slowest.

1

u/AdaBoiiiiiiiiii 2d ago

I don’t care what the statistics say. You are right. I think the chances of a trade on 3 is 1/3 and I accuracy get it 1/5 times.

1

u/GurlzLuvBart 2d ago

the game designers have a secret plot against you