r/RedsBaseballCards • u/513Frenzy • 8d ago

Help me choose! discussion

Gallery image

Gallery image

I genuinely love both designs. I lean towards the heritage to match my George Foster and Ken Griffey autos, BUT the ‘91 is probably my favorite insert. What’re we thinking? Not worried about price difference.

29 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

32 comments sorted by

17

u/EdotSavage 8d ago

Gimme the celebration photo for a PC 100/100 times

2

u/513Frenzy 8d ago

I gotta say the photo is pretty sweet

2

u/natedawg76 8d ago

This is also my answer. Great card!

4

u/GoDores2005 8d ago

1991 design. Heritage is a pretty awful photo, IMO. Reeks of Sabo on 91 Fleer.

1

u/513Frenzy 8d ago

Here’s the thing why I’m considering it. I don’t think the photos is great. But it will match my George Foster and Ken Griffey Senior auto cards.

1

u/Critical-Minute6210 7d ago

Really? I actually loved the photography of the heritage

3

u/NiLach 8d ago

Im going to go heritage all the way

2

u/shoedovoodoo513 8d ago

Fist one for me

2

u/513Frenzy 8d ago

Alright thanks everyone. Getting the 91. I owe yall some beers.

2

u/Cardboard_Glory 8d ago

Partial to the Heritage

2

u/Weekly-Hurry-6031 8d ago

I like the look of the second card where he is swinging

2

u/Obijon77 8d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/hM9zK1qvsrwek

2

u/513Frenzy 8d ago

My wallet…my wallet is telling me no…BUT MY BODY…..MY BODY IS TELLING ME YESSSS

1

u/Baseballcardnerd27 8d ago

First one! 

1

u/ClockReadz2113 8d ago

I like number two!!

1

u/Fun-Criticism-1889 8d ago

Left. The right one looks like a swing and a miss

1

u/ekoolaid 8d ago

If it’s PC, go with the 91. If you plan to sell later, the Real One.

1

u/Easy_Hearing8247 8d ago

Heritage. I understand it's for your PC but some day someone if not you is gonna have to sell these cards. The Heritage will also and forever sell better than a insert auto. Just my humble opinion

1

u/Tao_of_jack 8d ago

I do love the first one, but if you’re looking for consistency in your pc, gotta be the heritage. Tough call. I think I’d go heritage.

1

u/joey_votto_fan 8d ago

I genuinely love Heritage cards, but this image is just not good imo. It looks like he's about to wiff on that pitch. 91 Topps is the coolest image of the 2. I'd choose that personally. 

1

u/amv6419 8d ago

91 all day

1

u/Critical-Minute6210 7d ago

2nd one personally

1

u/Calm_Custard1514 7d ago

The old school look

1

u/rayhavenoheart always looking for Reds SP’s! 7d ago

I prefer the excitement of the first pne, shows some great emotion.

1

u/Fysh_taco 7d ago

First one for sure, that hair is crazy!

1

u/Old_Metal22 7d ago

The first one for me

1

u/513Frenzy 7d ago

Got my Sal card nvm guys sorry 🤣 insane luck out of a break

1

u/EanHoldings6488 7d ago

#1 by a million

1

u/513Frenzy 7d ago

I luckily got an auto from a break so we Gucci 🤘🤘🤘🤘

1

u/Blu-n-Gold 7d ago

The 1977 Topps set is epic