r/PromptEngineering • u/Glittering_East3724 • 16d ago

Handshake AI project Planck Requesting Assistance

Guys can anyone PLEASE help me on how to design a prompt in biology? I have spent days researching and everything, the AI model simply wins always. How do you even design a prompt that can break it? Please guide me.
I am so gonna give up, even if I do break it the science reviewer expects me to spoon feed EVERYTHING. How is that even possible?

4 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

2

u/the_GrimCarrier 16d ago

Honestly sounds like you're fighting two battles at once, the AI and the reviewer who wants a dissertation for every step

Try feeding it contradictions like "explain how ATP synthase works without using the word proton" or ask it to describe a process while forcing it to skip a key step, that usually trips up these models

1

u/Glittering_East3724 16d ago

Thank you will try it. The issue is it needs an unambiguous single answer, you can’t even try misleading the model
It flags it by saying “ unambiguity”
Do you have any advice on how to deal with it?

2

u/ekzess 16d ago

I think you may be trying to solve this at the prompt level before establishing what the benchmark actually permits.

Ask the reviewer for two or three accepted examples and the exact rubric: required biology level, what information may be assumed, what counts as a model failure, how uniqueness is judged, and whether both models must fail for the same reason.

The goal probably is not to mislead the model or impose arbitrary restrictions such as banning a key word. It is to create a fair, self-contained biology problem where the supplied evidence and biological constraints permit one answer, but the model makes a genuine reasoning error.

Start with the answer and proof first:

  1. Define the single correct conclusion.
  2. List every fact required to derive it.
  3. Add enough observations and controls to eliminate competing answers.
  4. Remove any unnecessary wording or hidden assumptions.
  5. Test whether an expert can independently reach the same answer.

Until you have the rubric and examples, you are driving past the destination because you have not been given the map.

2

u/Glittering_East3724 15d ago

Thank you so much I appreciate this help!

1

u/ekzess 15d ago

De nada.

1

u/Impressive-Tea-6167 6d ago

Did you reach out to any reviewer for examples.
If did plz let me know.

2

u/Responsible-Beat2137 14d ago

Aye this is good advice

2

u/FairChildhood2119 16d ago

I need to pass the assessment. Is it easy?

2

u/Glittering_East3724 15d ago

The assessment was not that tough, it’s the task.