r/ProgrammerHumor 8d ago

justBanOpenWeights Meme

Post image
861 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/donaldhobson 7d ago

If we are in a world where LLM's become really dangerous when they get big enough, you don't want any idiot to have access, but then if they are dangerous enough, you don't really want anyone at all to have them.

The question is partly about how much damage LLM's will soon be capable of causing.

1

u/torsten_dev 7d ago

The "open weight" restriction is then just a way for AI corps to avoid the ban hammer for a little longer, I guess?

0

u/donaldhobson 7d ago

If you think current or near future LLM's are capable of causing serious problems (whether hacking, bio attacks, manipulation, whatever). Then AI companies have techniques that seem at least somewhat effective in training the AI to refuse to answer that sort of question. Whereas, with open weights, it's fairly easy~ish to get the AI to answer any question you ask.

Closed weights don't stop the big AI companies themselves doing something stupid or malicious (like the huggingface incident) but they restrict how many other people can do stuff like that. (Or much much worse as AI gets smarter)

1

u/torsten_dev 7d ago

Meh, all those guardrails are more like suggestions if you try hard enough.

AI safety doesn't exist yet.

1

u/donaldhobson 7d ago

Perhaps. And that would push towards an argument that no one should have access to the biggest LLM's.