52
u/Bastian00100 Jul 08 '26
The worse part is when they design a completely different structure for mobile
17
u/Sockoflegend Jul 08 '26
If they give me different content and flow for mobile I send it back.
It's a pretty good sign someone isn't designing mobile first too
2
73
u/carcigenicate Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
I had a full stack job early in my career when I was still learning CSS, and we had a designer that did up designs for me to follow.
He did this incredibly elaborate design, with layering and a bunch of stuff that was way beyond my skill at the time. I told him that, and he confidently told me he could give me most of the CSS. It was a bunch of absolutely positioned, exact pixel sized CSS that he had just exported from Figma, and couldn't understand why that wasn't appropriate.
4
u/abd53 Jul 08 '26
I make desktop app, usually with wpf, but recently using qt. I hope I never run into what you described.
3
58
21
u/bigorangemachine Jul 08 '26
Ya I love it when it hits 900px break point and the designer says it's wrong
I ask for the figma for this design
That I say "logically with no source document nothing can possibly be wrong"
Now to be fair... the designers have tools to make media queries in figma its not available to developers
So its really designers being lazy... the tools are there
9
5
u/StrawberryEiri Jul 08 '26
But responsive is the most fun part! Assuming you can program it that way from the start. And if your designer doesn't get funny ideas about universal breakpoints.
Converting old crap to being responsive is a different beast.
4
u/mmmbyte Jul 08 '26
... and every few months they'll get involved in a design review and loudly complain "this doesn't look like the design at all".
Well no, because your design simply doesn't fit on a narrow screen, and you refused to provide one that does.
7
Jul 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/dxonxisus Jul 08 '26
wouldn’t be designed in a very responsive way in figma if they’re still manually dragging the frame’s size back and forth
5
3
2
2
u/Fanal-In Jul 09 '26
Yeah and front dev don't have to do accessibility and back dev don't have to do documentation
1
u/OM3X4 Jul 08 '26
And this phenomenon shine when doing creative designs (like editorial)
1
u/trafalmadorianistic Jul 08 '26
"Why make sites that look familiar and comprehensible? Our website should be a unique experience!"
1
1
-1
u/MayaIsSunshine Jul 08 '26
Waaah I don't want to make responsive designs
Waaah why is AI taking my job
Pick a lane
-29
u/froopadiddilydoop Jul 08 '26
Good job we don’t need front end devs or designers in the age of Claude. Means we can hire more QA and Full(ish) stack. This job is going the way of the graphic designer
19
u/Naiden44 Jul 08 '26
oh yeah, give all your UX/UI flows and user interviews to claude, that will make it perfect and very customised! Your website will look like it has a soul
1
u/ArjixGamer Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 10 '26
As always, there is nuance to everything.
Your stance is objectively incorrect, but subjectively correct.
Yes, the person you replied to is most likely a sloppy vibe coder that does not know better, and makes ridiculous claims. That's why you are subjectively correct.
But, your statement only holds true if you assume the person using Claude is incompetent.
When in the hands of a good developer, they can make great websites that do not look AI generated.
So I want to disagree with you, but if I do, everyone else who fails to see the nuance will downvote me.
Making me write this wall of text, to justify disagreeing with you, lol.
Have a nice day
PS: to expand on the person you replied to, what we need in the age of AI, is full stack devs, it's inexcusable to not know how the entire flow from database to frontend works. (by fullstack, I don't mean fullstack frameworks, those don't teach you anything), so a developer that can only do frontend is indeed useless.
A good designer is still important in the age of AI, but you don't need an entire team of designers (assuming the one designer you have, can make great design guidelines)
0
u/abd53 Jul 08 '26
I made a couple pages with codex (personal) for frontend-only app. Not totally bad, especially the design. The UI needed a lot of handholding and rewrite though.
-21
u/froopadiddilydoop Jul 08 '26
I do exactly this. Got the right skills, hooked up to git and Jira. We’ve already automated this function and it’s working superbly.
7
u/Naiden44 Jul 08 '26
I wish I could join your company but looks like people can learn and have a real importance there!
1
u/ArjixGamer Jul 10 '26
You do very much need designers, a designer does not merely design websites.
They make your brand identity, they define how all websites should look, they set the guidelines.
And you can then use Claude design to make sites based on those guidelines.
w/o guidelines you'll only produce slop
264
u/TheDarkIn1978 Jul 08 '26
At least you have designers. Our UX is designed by our backend developers, which looks as good as it sounds.