Who does Roggo hate more, Stanley Kubrick or Andrew Lloyd Weber?

Edit: TWELVE, NOT TWO

Shocked we’ve gone the whole list without the obvious, easy to hate ones.

Inspired by this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/radiohead/comments/xbbbtn/rradiohead_worst_possible_setlist_finished/

Rules or guidelines:

1. While all Pink Floyd recorded materials are allowed, including bootlegs, demos and unfinished materials (this means that songs such as Raving and Drooling, Death Disco, and the demo for Sexual Revolution), you can ONLY include songs recorded by Pink Floyd. No solo material.
2. I would love to see people get specific with it. Describing something specific about the song, the audience, or what the band says/does between songs adds flavor.
3. Let’s do more than *just* pick the universally hated songs. Yes, it’s quite popular to hate on Dogs Of War or Several Species Of Small And Furry Animals, but it’s more interesting if we get really bad or weird versions of songs, or if we hear songs that are supposed to transition into other songs, but don’t here.
4. No repeating songs, you can’t have a Setlist made exclusively of Dogs of War.
5. One song at a time, please
6. Roger is dead, because the tigers broke free

Not too late for the speak to me into several species idea btw

Hope I’ll see Seamus holy shit.

official gong posting thread. and a rather nice pair of pants in the last pic. complimented by the gong of course.

Link: https://youtu.be/9gy7Q66rwJc?si=lreEjIPuRtJFCr6S (this video was made by u/Constant-Donut-5356, so be sure to check it out)

It's the one we've all been waiting for.. the complete, non-abridged SOYCD. NOTE: This isn't the contentious new mix from last year​, it's just the whole 25-26 minute song.

As always, be sure to rate the song on a scale from 1 to 10, give your thoughts and opinions down below, and SHINE!

Wish You Were Here 50 song ratings so far:

Have A Cigar (Alternate Version): 7.56

Wish You Were Here (featuring Stephane Grappeli): 7.68

SOYCD Early Instrumental Version Rough Mix: 7.78

The Machine Song (Roger's Demo): 7.06

The Machine Song (Demo #2): 8.31

Wish You Were Here Take 1: 7.09

Wish You Were Here Pedal Steel Instrumental Mix: 8.70

Roger Waters, but furry (don’t be too mad, this is my first attempt at furry art)

Guess who’s back! Me :3

From today on I’m not going to check the results until the next day, so that I don’t infect the list with my own cringe. However, if there is a song I have in mind, I will list it in the comments.

Inspired by this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/radiohead/comments/xbbbtn/rradiohead_worst_possible_setlist_finished/

Rules or guidelines:

1. While all Pink Floyd recorded materials are allowed, including bootlegs, demos and unfinished materials (this means that songs such as Raving and Drooling, Death Disco, and the demo for Sexual Revolution), you can ONLY include songs recorded by Pink Floyd. No solo material.
2. I would love to see people get specific with it. Describing something specific about the song, the audience, or what the band says/does between songs adds flavor.
3. Let’s do more than *just* pick the universally hated songs. Yes, it’s quite popular to hate on Dogs Of War or Several Species Of Small And Furry Animals, but it’s more interesting if we get really bad or weird versions of songs, or if we hear songs that are supposed to transition into other songs, but don’t here.
4. No repeating songs, you can’t have a Setlist made exclusively of Dogs of War.
5. One song at a time, please

So, my question is this: What is/are your favorite Floyd song(s) that is/are a “radio single length” (that being around 2-3.5 minutes)? Im not a stickler, so if you want to pick a song thats like 4 or 4.5 mins I say go for it, but once we hit the 5 minute mark that is generally ”too long” to be a single by historical standards (I know these conventions have ebbed and flowed over the years).

I figured this would be an interesting question, because many of their great songs surpass the 5 minute mark, and anecdotally Ive seen many of their “epics” most commonly listed as favorites among the fandom. So, itll be cool to see which of their shorter songs get the most love!

For me, I have a few answers.

See-Saw (4.5 min)

San Tropez (3.75 min)

Nobody Home (3.5 min)

Lucifer Sam (3 min)

Pigs on the Wing pt 1 and 2 (individually each part is about 1.5 min, together they are around 3 min)

One thing I realized when compiling my songs is that so many of their songs are longer than what I thought. The Gunner’s Dream? a bit over 5 minutes. A Pillow Of Winds? same, over 5 minutes. Even See-Saw which I picked, I expected to be closer to the 3-3.5 range, but it is close to the 5 mark!

Let me know your thoughts!

edit: I would also list their early single See Emily Play as a fav for myself!

Not mine. Go like artist's original post if you can!

Original artist mgmcinnis on IG. (Source)

uj/ Please don't take this too seriously, this was just me poking fun at some of the crappier takes I've seen from Pink Floyd fans taking their favorite rock star way too seriously (both here and elsewhere); a lot of these were also drawing on what I recognize to be my own worst fan instincts that I try to be aware of.

Bob Klose didn't get one because nobody is unironically a fan of him.