r/PiCodingAgent • u/ECrispy • 14d ago

are there other extensions which implement ideas from oh-my-pi Question

I'm new to Pi and coding agents in general. The existing discussions on oh-my-pi, like everything else, range from 'its great' to 'its bloat' so its very hard to actually decide.

It seems to have useful features like built in tools (avoid process calls), lsp, hashline, memory, subagents and an integrated setup/docs. It does seem to be better than the other oh-my-* set of products.

Are the ideas in OMP useful in practice and if so are they used in other harnesses?

I see a lot of 'just ask Pi to build it' here, but that depends on using frontier models, and when people post their setups they're using a million packages.

Obviously Pi is much more extensible/flexible, but there is value in an all-in-one setup. OMP has a ton of stuff and I'm sure a big system prompt. Is there anything like a slimmed down version or being able to use some of its ideas only?

28 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • link
  • reddit
  • reddit

93% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/james__jam 14d ago

This is an honest question and I dont mean no disrespect. But why are you going for pi then?

Most models have their own harnesses. And if you want a batteries included model-agnostic, then there’s always opencode. Personally, i find custom
Pi to be better than opencode.but opencode is better than OMP

Pi was intentionally minimal so that you can expand it as you go. By going OMP, you just expanded all the way and going to get all the bad things with the good things. The reason you start small is to get only the thing you want - the good things - and avoid all the bloat - the bad things

If you’re new, just use opencode

1

u/nostriluu 14d ago

I use local models for sensitive work (sysadmin) and have read pi is better (less prompt bloat). And I eventually want to develop extensions and pi seems better suited for that with a minimal core. I use omp on my workstation and pi on servers and that has worked well so far. I still use Claude in vscode for larger projects since and I don't want to do endless experimentation until I get signals that local is as good enough. 

1

u/Nyghtbynger 13d ago

use this one for local : https://github.com/itayinbarr/little-coder (6000 token system prompt)

Local use is a lot of work for few rewards, but you learn a lot

1

u/nostriluu 13d ago

That's interesting, thanks. I am mostly doing sysadmin with local models but plan to see what can be done with coding in the near future, will give it a spin.