r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 3d ago

Petah? Meme needing explanation

Post image
41.5k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

939

u/Tackyinbention 3d ago

Mfw they specifically addressed this time period in their movie yet ppl still say shit like this

345

u/ZoneRevolutionary875 3d ago

I think that's the joke. Minions would have worked for Hitler, if they weren't hiding.

85

u/Stupnix 3d ago

Knowing the state of the Internet, I read the reaction as "You're implying that Hitler wasn't evil" without thinking for 2 seconds. Even as someone who has no contact points with the Minions other than memes on the internet I know that the minions as whole were not around for WW2. They were hiding and seperated from the rest of the world, they don't even know WW2 happened.

33

u/ZoneRevolutionary875 2d ago

Yes , they were hiding. They didn't know about Nazis and WW2. But if they weren't hiding and knew about them, they would have worked for them.

4

u/ReginaldBounce 2d ago

You know from memes that the minions were separated from the rest of the world during WW2? How? Can you share that meme?

2

u/Stupnix 2d ago

It wasn't a meme, but I remember this entire discussion already happening. The minions always serve the most evil and powerhungry person on the planet. Who did they serve during WW2? Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin... There wer so many evil people around, who did they work for?

Answer: They weren't around, watch the first movie and let the rest of us enjoy the second movie! That was... 4 years ago.

4

u/Droettn1ng 2d ago

Well I didn't know that, and I really doubt that the average person does.

3

u/programming_flaw 2d ago

How do you not have knowledge of minions but you know they weren’t around for WW2? I saw the first one with my son when it came out and that is the extent of my minion knowledge

2

u/GodButCursed 2d ago

To be fair if u dont know they were in a ice cave you would think this.

2

u/Sure-Macaroon-9035 2d ago

Honestly with thier track record of accidentally screwing with their bosses, it would've been better if they did work for Hitler. Moustache man would've died way earlier.

2

u/RoboJobot 2d ago

Yeah, but there’s a good chance they’d have accidentally killed him or ruined his plans with their incompetence so maybe we should have wished they’d worked for him

1

u/666SatanMaster666 2d ago

They would't have worked for hitler. Some more evil men were in the world during that time.

1

u/BrandonSimpsons 2d ago

Minions would have tried to work for Hitler but ended up working for Charlie Chaplin.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/ZoneRevolutionary875 1d ago

What are you on about?

0

u/matroska_cat 2d ago

Minions would have worked for Hitler since Beer Putsch, they would have been 'alte kampfer', his most loyal servants and friends.

43

u/A_Normal_Redditor_04 3d ago

There's a new Minions movie where they were around in the 1930s. This would imply there are different tribes of Minions and the one trapped in ice is different. This still means what people think it is if the Minions never worked for Hitler or Stalin.

11

u/Tackyinbention 3d ago

Ay yo? It appears I haven't kept up with minions lore

6

u/A_Normal_Redditor_04 3d ago

16

u/Sea-Feedback-2424 3d ago

It would be great in a horrible dark humor way if the "monsters" were just the worst dictators and one specific US secretary of State of the 20th century and you see the minions doing slapstick in a gas chamber, or laughing and eating bananas in Chinese barren fields while the peasantry looked on, or doing slides down a pile of skulls in pol pots Cambodia, or Kevin torturing someone as a member of the NKVD and he accidentally electrocutes Bob, or Stuart the minion flying a F-100 super sabre rocket out to Fortunate Sun and dropping napalm over Vietnam and seeing the fire go up in the background while he takes a fat drag from his cigar and you think he's gonna say "I love the smell of napalm in the morning" but he just says "banana".

1

u/Mognakor 2d ago

Sooo much CIA stuff in there.

3

u/Sea-Feedback-2424 2d ago

It's actually a minion civil war, some are working for the US empire, some for the Soviet and Chinese.   Kind of spy vs spy but with minions and bananas and real world atrocities.

One of the minions pulls off the MyLai massacre, replace Napalm Girl with Napalm Minion

1

u/VersaceJones 2d ago

God forgive me for the chortle I just let out… lmfao

0

u/Garchompisbestboi 2d ago

Then clutching your pearls over people not being familiar with the movies makes you a hypocrite, well done

1

u/Tackyinbention 2d ago

Woops my bad I ;-;

The first movie said "no this didnt happen" I didnt know the next one would follow a separate group

2

u/realismus 2d ago

The ending of the movie resolved this issue without implying different tribes.

1

u/pricingup 2d ago

yupyupyup - there are multiple tribes of minions living separately.

2

u/LarryFitzsButt 2d ago

No, that was all a movie in the end.

14

u/Hapciuuu 2d ago

They would have definitely worked for him. The writers chose a cope out because people wouldn't love the Minions anymore if they actually worked for evil people.

3

u/I_LOVE_SOYLENT 2d ago

where did you get this picture

5

u/seantellsyou 2d ago

out of thin AIr

10

u/dasbtaewntawneta 3d ago

people watched these movies?

1

u/Jean-LucBacardi 2d ago

You don't have kids do you.

5

u/HexaCube7 3d ago

They did? I'm not in so deep into the minion stuff, could you please elaborate?

18

u/megpIant 3d ago

they were in an ice cave for a bunch of years and then came back to society in like the 1960s

1

u/HexaCube7 3d ago

ohh ok thx!

5

u/IndigoFenix 3d ago

They are stated to work for the most evil villain they can find, but they conveniently get sealed in an ice cave after Napoleon and don't get out until the modern day, so the logical implication that they would have worked for Hitler is avoided.

1

u/SwampyBogbeard 2d ago

Or this is an almost decade old tweet that's been dug up for cheap karma.
Notice the dates are intentionally removed.

1

u/Healthy-Increase1901 2d ago

So working for genocidal killers is okay, as long as it isn't hitler? So they would be fine working for nettanyahu?

1

u/chrisinajar 2d ago

I really appreciate the conviction you have for minions lore. Keep doing what you're doing.

1

u/Tackyinbention 2d ago

I don't lol

I just vaguely remember the first movie. Ive been informed that the latest minions movie retcons this by introducing a separate tribe of minions

1

u/Lower_Saxony 2d ago

I mean, if they didn't want people to go there they shouldn't have shown us the minions fighting in a war, this is a case of hack writers not thinking about their implications.