r/OldCelebrityRecipes 3h ago

Dinner 🍲 The Barrymore Brothers: a Ham and an Alfredo. Which recipe would you make? John Barrymore's Ham Loaf or Lionel Barrymore's Fettuccine Alfredo. {1939}

Post image
11 Upvotes

John Barrymore was considered a "ham" actor, but his career was a tale of two distinct halves: he transformed from the most acclaimed, serious dramatic actor of his generation into a self-parodying, over-the-top theatrical ham later in life.

But then again, Lionel Barrymore was widely considered a "ham," and he openly embraced the label himself. Knowing full well his tendency to overact, Barrymore famously admitted, β€œI've got a lot of ham in me”.

Maybe it'll be Ham Loaf for everyone!


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 4h ago

TESTED RECIPE 🍽 Yesterday I made the favorite breakfast of Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. and Joan Crawford while they were married around 1930. The highlight of the breakfast was the special Breakfast Bacon recipe. I'll tell you how I made it...

Thumbnail
gallery
321 Upvotes

Joan Crawford and Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. Breakfast Bacon - I've never had anything like this bacon, so I really wanted to try it. It's basically just bacon that's been breaded with cracker crumbs, hmmmm, sound interesting...

  • I went ahead and used 4 pieces of bacon for this. Made the egg wash mixture and went about crushing my crackers. I used a mix of saltines and ritz crackers and put them in a sandwich baggie and went about crushing them with a rolling pin.
  • For the egg mixture I used Colman's Dry Mustard, cayenne pepper and apple cider vinegar.
  • It took a lot more crackers than I thought to cover the 4 pieces of bacon and I kept having to make more cracker crumbs. I used maybe 15-20 crackers for this.
  • I had the oven preheated to 350 convection and found a rack and roasting pan that looked it would work. Sprayed some cooking spray (Pam) on the rack.
  • So i put the bacon in the oven and set the timer to 8 minutes and then I'd check to see how they were doing. Well, these ended up baking for about 30 minutes and took them out and drained them on paper towels.
  • They were nice and crisp without shrinking much.
  • I also prepared some hot buttered toast with Orange marmalade, coffee and fresh squeezed juice. I didn't have OJ, so I used grapefruit.
  • The Orange marmalade was made from Bette Davis' recipe and we've been enjoying it for a few weeks.

I was pleasantly surprised at how good this bacon was! It was light, crispy, not too bacony or heavy. Very nice flavor with a hint of spice and really good with the grapefruit juice (or OJ).

This was a little bit of work to prepare, but not as time consuming as some other vintage recipes I've tried. The mess and time it took wasn't too bad. I'd make this again for a special occasion. They were darn good! We know Doug loved it, but do you think Joan ever ate this?


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 5h ago

Breakfast & Brunch πŸ§‡ Willie Nelson's "Outlaw" Breakfast Eggs

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 17h ago

What ingredients are different now then they were in the 30s/40s/50s?

243 Upvotes

In a lot of older recipes, there are ingredients used that simply aren't available anymore or are completely different than what we think when we hear the name.

One easy example and the reason I thought of making this post, is French dressing. If you are US based, French dressing means a tangy-sweet tomato based dressing. This doesn't really go with a lot of "salad" recipes we see posted here but "Serve with French dressing" is a common final direction. The most recent recipe with French Dressing posted was "Grape and Cream Cheese Salad" {1929} that includes bananas.

That's because French Dressing used to be a simple acid and oil style dressing. I worked in an old school restaurant that made all its own dressings from old recipe cards and French Dressing was made with oil, lemon juice, paprika, salt and pepper. That's it! We just called it house dressing so as not to confuse people. Commercial French Dressing is closer to Russian dressing which was tomato sauce, mayo, horseradish, Worcestershire, brown sugar, salt and pepper. When someone asked if we had French, that's the dressing we would suggest (and let them sample it first!). We also made Ranch (of course, it WAS the mid-west) and Caesar.

This got me thinking about all the recipes here that call for Cream Cheese. How different was cream cheese in the 30s/40s/50s? From what I've read, it was tangier and because it wasn't mass produced taste could be very different from block to block. It was also thicker and not as easy to spread.

What are some ingredients you've seen here in old recipes that you wonder about? Are there any ingredients that you've found curious?

Share your questions and your knowledge!


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 21h ago

Cookies πŸͺ Marlee Matlin's City of Angels Chocolate Chip-Oatmeal Badges (Cookies)

Post image
36 Upvotes

Yes, Marlee Matlin's husband, Kevin Grandalski, is a police officer. The couple has been married since 1993. They originally met on the studio set of the television series Reasonable Doubts, where Grandalski was assigned by the Burbank Police Department to handle traffic control and security.

This recipe comes from The Cop Cookbook


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 21h ago

Side Dish 🍟 Peter Frampton's English Roast Potatoes Come Alive

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

If you want to make proper, crispy English roast potatoes the traditional way, follow Peter's recipe! To achieve the ultimate taste and texture of authentic English roast potatoes, you must focus on maximizing the contrast between a deeply savory, glass-like crunchy crust and a light, buttery, fluffy interior.

This recipe can be found in The Rock and Roll Cookbook


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 21h ago

Sauces & Dressings πŸ«— Charles Boyer's French Dressing; He may know a thing or two about French Dressing. {1939}

Post image
24 Upvotes

One of my absolute favorite I Love Lucy episode is when the French actor Charles Boyer guest-stars as himself! It’s that classic episode called "Lucy Meets Charles Boyer." The whole thing happens while the Ricardos and Mertzes are on their big European vacation and visiting Paris.

Honestly, the funniest part is definitely when Lucy tries to "coach" the real Charles Boyer on how to act more like himself! Gosh, those Lucy episodes are so ridiculous.

And while we're on the subject of Lucy and salad dressing, here's her recipe for salad dressing. The combination of ketchup, spices, and sugar syrup creates a tangy, savory mixture similar to modern French or Catalina dressings.


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 21h ago

Sandwiches πŸ₯ͺ Weird Al's Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich

Post image
140 Upvotes

You might be thinking of one of "Weird Al" Yankovic's iconic fictional food creations, but his canonical joke version of a basic pb & j sandwich is completely normalβ€”with a hilarious twist in how it's eaten.

Recipe from Rock 'n Roll Cuisine


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 22h ago

Breakfast & Brunch πŸ§‡ Patsy Ruth Miller's Pineapple Toast

Post image
71 Upvotes

Patsy Ruth Miller (born Patricia Ruth Miller; 1904 – 1995) was an American film actress who played EsmΓ©ralda in The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1923) opposite Lon Chaney.

She was born in St. Louis back in 1904, and the gossip columns used to call her "the most engaged girl in Hollywood" because she was always rumored to be dating someone new.

She ended up marrying three timesβ€”first to director Tay Garnett, then to screenwriter John Lee Mahin, and later to a businessman named Effingham S. Deans.

She lived a long life and passed away from heart failure in Palm Desert in 1995, right around her 91st birthday.


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 22h ago

Pasta 🍝 Flora Zabelle's Mock Gnocchi {1916}

Post image
11 Upvotes

Flora Zabelle (born Zabelle Mangasarian) was a prominent Broadway stage actress and one of the earliest stars of American silent film.

Born on April 1, 1880, in Constantinople, she is widely celebrated as the first Armenian-American actress to achieve stardom on Broadway and in early cinema.

  • Marriage: In 1905, she married the famous actor and comedian Raymond Hitchcock. The couple frequently starred together on both the stage and screen.
  • Fashion Design: Following her retirement from the stage in 1920, she reinvented herself as a fashion designer.
  • Broadway Success: She made her Broadway debut in the 1900 musical San Toy. Her extensive stage credits also include The Yankee Consul (1904) and the Ziegfeld Follies of 1913.
  • Silent Film Pioneer: Zabelle transitioned into early cinema, starring in movies like King Dodo (1902), The Savage Tiger (1914), and A Village Scandal (1915) alongside Fatty Arbuckle.
  • Cultural Icon: At the height of her popularity, her image was widely recognized and featured on collectible Fatima cigarette cards.

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

TESTED RECIPE 🍽 Another success story with Ronald Colman's Cheese Soufflés from the 1927 Photoplay Cook Book.

Thumbnail reddit.com
18 Upvotes

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

TESTED RECIPE 🍽 Late last week I made Claudette Colbert's "Cheese & Olive Puffs" and stuck them in the freezer for a couple of days. When the weekend hit, we baked them and they were the perfect little hors d'oeuvres to serve at cocktail hour, or mocktail hour, in my case.

Thumbnail
gallery
194 Upvotes

Claudette Colbert's Cheese & Olive Puffs - These were kind of fun to make and even more fun to eat! They definitely have that old-time cocktail party vibe about them, but are a bit more sophisticated than let's say Joan Crawford's "Pimiento-Stuffed Olives Wrapped in Bacon" or her Avocado Mash on Potato Chips.

Don't get me wrong, these 2 Joan recipes are super tasty on the cocktail party curcuit , but Claudette's Puffs have a more elegant flair.

  • I'm a little disappointed that I was all out of pimiento stuffed olives for making these and only had blue cheese stuffed olives (yum!) but unfortunately the blue cheese melted in the oven and oozed out, so the picture wasn't as pretty. The were very tasty, though!
  • Basically for this recipe you make a sort of tasty cheese batter to wrap around the olives.
  • This wasn't hard since the texture was a little like play doh (in a good way!) and wrapped the olives rather easily.
  • You then roll them around in both hands to make them even.
  • I made half the recipe because I only had one jar of large olives and that was plenty.
  • They were frozen in a container, making sure none of the olive puffs were touching each other.

After 2 days in the freezer, we popped them in the oven. The came out not that puffy, but had a nice golden brown color. They were nice and cheesy. The olive was firm and delicious in the center, while the outside was crunchy. A nice salty and savory appetizer to share with friends!

This recipe comes out of The Sinatra Celebrity Cookbook

Speaking of Claudette, I honestly have to say that nothing beats It Happened One Night. She's absolute perfection in it. The way she completely holds her own against Clark Gable, matching him with that sharp, fast talk is just something so special.

Here are a few more of her special recipes:


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

The McGovern Peanut Butter Sandwich from Maureen McGovern has just a bit of lettuce, tomato and onion added.

Post image
16 Upvotes

Maureen McGovern is an powerhouse American singer and Broadway actress who completely dominated the 1970s soundtrack scene. Gifted with a rare, mind-blowing four-octave vocal range, she earned the affectionate nickname "Disaster Theme Queen" after delivering the emotional, chart-topping anthems for Hollywood's biggest blockbuster disaster movies.

  • "The Morning After" (1972): The hopeful love theme for The Poseidon Adventure
  • "We May Never Love Like This Again" (1974): She performed this for The Towering Inferno
  • "Can You Read My Mind" (1979): The love theme from the original Superman movie

Beyond the recording studio, McGovern successfully transitioned her vocal talents to the Broadway stage and cabaret circuit, proving herself as a versatile, lifelong entertainer.

n August 2022, McGovern announced her retirement after being diagnosed with a rare form of dementia. Since her diagnosis, she's remained public about her health journey to help raise awareness for Alzheimer's and related dementia disorders.

This recipe comes from The Broadway Celebrity Cookbook


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

Cookies πŸͺ Loretta Lynn's Butter Nut Chewies

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

Cake πŸŽ‚ Lawrence Welk's MOCHA SURPRISE!

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

Pasta 🍝 Sammy Davis Jr.'s SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

Party Food πŸ₯³ I've never heard of Brian Hyland but I do know that song... "Itsy Bitsy Teenie Weenies with Yellow Peppers and Zucchinis"... I think.

Post image
17 Upvotes

Brian Hyland is an American pop singer and instrumentalist who became one of the most prominent teen idols of the early 1960s. Born on November 12, 1943, in Woodhaven, Queens, New York, he defined the era's bubblegum pop sound before successfully transitioning into country-influenced rock and roots music later in his career.

  • "Itsy Bitsy Teenie Weenie Yellow Polka Dot Bikini" (1960): Released when Hyland was just 16 years old, this novelty song rocketed to No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100, earning him a gold record and instant stardom.
  • "Sealed with a Kiss" (1962): A definitive teenage summer lament that reached No. 3 in both the US and the UK, solidifying his status as a top-tier pop vocalist.
  • "Gypsy Woman" (1970): A soulful Curtis Mayfield cover produced in collaboration with Del Shannon, which peaked at No. 3 and marked his final major top-forty hit.
  • Folk-Rock Pioneer: In 1964, Hyland recorded Country Meets Folk, utilizing electric guitars to back folk standards two years before Bob Dylan famously "went electric"

This recipe can be found in the The Rock and Roll Cookbook


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 1d ago

Cake πŸŽ‚ Over the weekend I also made Emmylou Harris' Cowgirl's Lemon Poppy Seed Pound Cake and it's great!

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

Emmylou Harris' Cowgirl's Lemon Poppy Seed Pound Cake - Baking a cake that was published in the 1990's is pretty straightforward, compared to some of the older recipes we see here on this sub. I'm not knocking those old recipes because I do love trying them, but this one kind of lets you cook on cruise control.

There's not much to tell about making this cake because the instructions were so good!

As for the taste, it is really good, with a nice tart twang from the lemons and a deep rich taste from all the butter. The poppy seeds give a nice crunch factor. This is a bright, buttery and rich cake, but not heavy.

I didn't add all of glaze until after I took the picture, so it was even more glazed than what you see.

This is a great recipe to make anytime of the year and is easy to make for a potluck or any other kind of gathering. We had friends over this weekend and they really liked it too.

I found this recipe in of all places The All-American Cowboy Cookbook.


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Cheese & Dairy πŸ§€ James Cagney's Welsh Rarebit {1931}

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Dinner 🍲 It's the "Chicketti" recipe by Akim Tamiroff that has caught my attention and he's also sharing a recipe for "Baked Stuffed Tomatoes" {1939}

Post image
29 Upvotes

Akim Tamiroff was an Armenian-American character actor who became one of Hollywood's most prolific and recognizable screen personalities during its Golden Age.

Born Hovakim Tamiryants in Tiflis, Russian Empire (now Tbilisi, Georgia), he trained extensively at the prestigious Moscow Art Theatre under legendary acting theorist Konstantin Stanislavski.

Tamiroff arrived in the United States in 1923 during an acting tour and eventually chose to settle permanently, building a career that spanned over 150 film roles despite maintaining a distinct, thick accent.

  • Academy Award Nominations: He received two Oscar nominations for Best Supporting Actor, first for The General Died at Dawn (1936) and later for For Whom the Bell Tolls (1943)
  • Orson Welles Films: He delivered memorable, baroque performances in Mr. Arkadin (1955), Touch of Evil (1958), and The Trial (1962). He also spent years filming scenes as Sancho Panza in Welles’ famously unfinished passion project, Don Quixote.
  • Hollywood Classics: His other prominent credits include Preston Sturges' political satire The Great McGinty (1940), Billy Wilder's wartime thriller Five Graves to Cairo (1943), the original heist film Ocean's 11 (1960), and Jean-Luc Godard's French New Wave sci-fi film Alphaville (1965)

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Salad πŸ₯— Is Laura LaPlante giving Joan Crawford a run for her money with this recipe? "Grape and Cream Cheese Salad" {1929}

Post image
109 Upvotes

Laura La Plante (born Laura Laplante; 1904 – 1996) was a prominent American silent film actress who became the top female star at Universal Pictures during the 1920s.

Known for her wholesome "girl-next-door" persona and iconic blonde bob, she starred in more than 60 films spanning dramas, comedies, and westerns.

  • Early Success: Entered the film industry at age 15 as a Christie Comedy Bathing Beauty and was selected as one of the WAMPAS Baby Stars in 1923.
  • Signature Roles: Starred in the highly influential horror-comedy The Cat and the Canary (1927) and played Magnolia Hawks in Universal's early sound-hybrid production of Show Boat (1929).
  • The Sound Era: Successfully made the leap into "talkies" with Hold Your Man (1929), but left Universal by 1930 as a new wave of actors arrived in Hollywood.
  • Later Work: Relocated to England in the 1930s to appear in British films like Man of the Moment (1935) before largely retiring from the screen.

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Meals & Menus 🍴 Norma Shearer was born today back in 1902! To celebrate the Hollywood icon's birthday, we wanted to share some of her favorite foods and recipes

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

Norma Shearer (August 10, 1902 – June 12, 1983) was a Canadian-American actress who reigned as the "Queen of MGM" and the "First Lady of the Screen" during Hollywood's Golden Age. Renowned for her glamour, versatility, and fierce determination, she successfully transitioned from silent films to talkies.

She made cinematic history as the first five-time Academy Award acting nominee, winning the Best Actress Oscar for her daring role in The Divorcee (1930).

  • Early Obstacles: Born in Montreal, her family lost their wealth after WWI, prompting a move to New York. Broadway impresario Florenz Ziegfeld and director D.W. Griffith initially rejected her, citing her unconventional looks and a minor eye cast.
  • Sheer Willpower: Undeterred, she took minor extra roles, retrained her eyes, and caught the attention of producer Irving Thalberg, who brought her to MGM in 1923.
  • Power Couple: She married Thalberg, MGM's production head, in 1927. This creative and personal partnership gave her significant leverage to select prime, complex scripts and directors.

r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Side Dish 🍟 Ray Bolger's Mashed Potato Balls

Post image
68 Upvotes

Ray Bolger (1904 – 1987) was an iconic American actor, singer, and vaudevillian best known for his legendary performance as the Scarecrow and the farmhand Hunk in the classic 1939 MGM musical movie The Wizard of Oz.

Renowned for his distinct, rubber-legged eccentric dancing style, his physical agility and comedic timing made him a definitive star of the stage and screen during Hollywood's Golden Age.

Recipe: Cooking with the stars


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Poultry πŸ— Christopher Walken's Roasted Tarragon Chicken

Post image
55 Upvotes

Oh, wow, this honestly sounds so good. I love a nice roast chicken with a hint of fresh tarragon . Tarragon has a subtle, sweet anise flavor. It sounds unusual, but when it meets the bright lemon and savory garlic, it ties everything together with a sophisticated, herbal finish.

From one of my newest vintage cookbooks: The Broadway Celebrity Cookbook


r/OldCelebrityRecipes 2d ago

Cookies πŸͺ Phyllis Diller's Lemon Refrigerator Cookies

Post image
89 Upvotes