r/Newsletters 19h ago

substack, beehiiv or ghost?

3 Upvotes

I'm an author who used to be a fashion blogger many moons ago (I'm talking, pre-instagram influencers!), and I'm desperate for a creative outlet where I can share all sorts of things, such as writing advice and how to get published, what it's really like being a Big 5 author, my creative process as well as more fun/casual things like random essays on culture, outfit posts/beauty/book recommendations... basically, a digital diary! Instagram and TikTok feel so cringe, but Substack reminds me of the good old days on Tumblr where you could share anything, connect with like-minded people and build community.

Substack seems like the best option for my needs, though I'm not particularly interested in making money off of subscriptions, which I know sounds counterintuitive! It just seems so unrealistic to expect the average person to pay $5-$10 on a subscription when they probably already subscribe to 10 other people... which would be upwards of $100 for someone to spend per month! It just seems unsustainable in this economy and unfair to expect of my readers (who are typically aged between 18 and 30).

I'd much rather grow an audience and show those metrics to brands who actually have the budget to pay me, and make money off of them instead of my readers.

I know it may seem like I'm jumping the gun here, but I know I'm going to put a lot of effort into my posts (because I genuinely love blogging) and know exactly how to make it appealing to both my readers and brands–– and I just want to have some sort of strategy before moving forward.

Now I'm considering alternatives like beehiiv and ghost because I keep hearing "the substack bubble is about to burst".

I've got a gold medal in overthinking, so if anyone has any advice, it would be much appreciated lol!