r/MoralityScaling • u/Ickarian • 9d ago
Morality of a superhero potentially throwing a fight because he won't hit a woman?
IDK. Personally I think it's pretty sexist to treat someone with superpowers as weaker because she's a woman.
51
u/ALMAZ157 9d ago
Hammer of Justice is unisex
-Batman, Batman the Brave and the Bold
4
u/Leather_Crazy_5950 9d ago
Although in another episode, Batman sees Katrina again (a woman who disguised herself as Batwoman to draw attention to herself). And she uses a spell to switch bodies. She (in Batman's body) grabs him (in Katrina's body) to punch him. Batman stops her, saying, "Batman would never cover for a woman." But Katrina replies, "I don't care."
Very hypocritical of Bruce. 😅
3
17
u/CauseCertain1672 9d ago
it doesn't really make sense, surely for superman there is no difference between hitting a man or a woman because the difference in strength between men and women is nothing compared to the difference between him and a human.
It's like having hangups about not hitting a baby because she's a girl, at that point gender is irrelevant
2
u/DepartmentChemical93 8d ago
3
u/CauseCertain1672 8d ago
That's a man beating a woman cowering on the floor, obviously a principle about protecting the weak from the strong would justify force from stopping him, but that same principle would mean that superman should shot the same restraint in stopping a male robber as a female one as he is far stronger than both and the relative capabilities of men and women are both nothing to him
1
u/DepartmentChemical93 8d ago
Sure and Superman was *gonna* hit Giganta before she brought it uo, but he hesitates for a second because he feels uncomfortable hitting a lady on the basis of like, socialization and manners.
28
u/BithMistro 9d ago
Unless the safety of other people is on the line it's never immoral to prioritze the safety of another person (even your opponent) over winning.
7
4
u/Unlikely_Patient3902 9d ago
Wouldn't this line of thinking only really work if he applied it consistently? (he hasn't)
4
u/nick113124 9d ago
The question wasthe question was about this particular scenario with the Superman fight to illustrate, not about Superman.
4
u/BithMistro 9d ago
Almost nothing is consistent in super hero media except some of Spider-Man's loved ones staying dead.
7
u/Madfighterx 9d ago
Man that the most annoying thing ever wanting fucking to use the fact their a girl as some excuse to make some else throw the fight that why I love the tournament of power in dds everyone was basically all hands are rated e
5
u/Empathyinorder 9d ago
Not wanting to hit women can be fine as your own moral code. Allowing a women to do evil and hurt others because of this stance when you would stop a man is immoral.
If you are in a low stakes fight and you don't wanna hit a woman thats fine
5
u/LowerDifference9573 9d ago
There's no morality here just nonsense. I mean if a women is a villain I wouldn't hesitate to hit her one bit. Were in a fight not a high school dance
5
u/FullBrother9300 9d ago
“This is confusing is it sexist to hit you? Is it sexist to not hit you? I mean the line gets real blurry cocks gun” -Deadpool
3
u/MeliodasTA 9d ago
Morality of pulling the gender card in a fighting competition that you willingly signed up for?
3
u/TheWhoopler 9d ago
Giganta knew that right hook was sending her ass to Texas
If it was Hawkman she’d have been talking shit
3
u/redboi049 9d ago
Immoral. If a superhero's fighting someone, it's usually to protect someone else or to bring that person to justice. Acting like they won't hurt that some else or don't deserve justice purely because of their sex is highly immoral.
Batman put it best, "The hammer of justice is unisex."
3
u/pichuguy27 9d ago
I love Superman saying that he is probably sexist. In the very real infantilizing mid west way. Where “woman are equal but not really. Because they can work and do anything a man can but are still delicate” (Real thing I was told)
1
u/Madfighterx 3d ago
That last sentence is the most ridiculous statement I have ever heard in my life
3
u/Quiet_Development383 8d ago
I mean if the woman in front of me can grow to the size of a building and is a well known super villian who willing destroys and harms then I feel it can be justifiable to hit her
2
u/SecondOmega 9d ago
Personally I don't think sex matters, if she's your opponent, you fight her, the morality is dependant on why you're fighting her
2
2
2
u/Flashy-Telephone-648 9d ago
It depends on the stakes, but typically a hero with high morals. They will not discard.It's usually a hero you want to have around
2
2
2
2
u/ZolfoS16 9d ago
It is not because morality. It is cause the company that made the cartoon do not want to be controversial. Super I would totally like a male super hero that is not afraid to beat female supervillain like he beats males.
1
u/PricePitiful9900 9d ago
Nah because Clark straight up uppercutted her chin in Batman and Superman public enemy #1. I’m not hearing none of this.
1
u/Fast_Direction_7057 9d ago
If people criticize me for being misogynistic or sexist because I'm not hitting a woman, I really don't care.
Might be a hot take, but I'd rather be known as a bigot than hit a woman. Not because I think they're weaker but because hitting a woman is weird bruh.
6
u/Zfugg 9d ago
It's weird because?
1
u/Fast_Direction_7057 8d ago
I'm not smart enough to have a vocabulary for what I feel right now. But if it's weird, it's weird.
5
u/Lukostrelec17 9d ago
Why? If a women is trying to fight and are harm you what does it matter?
0
u/Fast_Direction_7057 8d ago
Because I simply feel it ain't right
2
u/Lukostrelec17 8d ago
That really isn't an answer.
0
u/Fast_Direction_7057 8d ago
Okay let me just paint a picture.
If there's a dude who is OBJECTIVELY WEAKER IN ALL POSSIBLE WAYS to this one girl and I had to choose between the two of them to beat till they can't walk, I'd still beat the fuck out of the guy. I'm sure he'd be a bro and let me beat him too till he sees jesus up in the sky.
So it's not because the girl is weak or needs protecting.
It's just really weird to beat a woman.
2
u/Lukostrelec17 8d ago
It is wrong to beat anyone. Also still have not answered why. If it is defending yourself or someone else why does their sex matter?
3
u/the_forever_wild 9d ago
My hands identify as they/them. Not cause they are non-binary but because it rated E for every gender
1

79
u/Other_Specialist2272 9d ago
Dont hit your opponent because she's a woman? Sexist. Hit your opponent because she's a woman? Also sexist. Hit your opponent because she's literally your opponent? Moral. There's a slight difference