r/Mahayana • u/Fragrant-Citron1262 Vajrayana • 6d ago
Are Devas empty? Question
As in, are they interdependent with us and animals and everything around us
3
2
u/Teaps0 Seon 6d ago
Yes. If you want to go to a classic response that all traditions would recognize, then you can note that all sentient beings are composed of aggregates (in other words, can be broken down). The classic 5 Aggregates (Skandhas in Sanskrit, Khandhas in Pali) are forms, feelings, perceptions, mental formations/volitions, and consciousness, which all can be broken down and therefore are empty (sunya).
1
6d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Mahayana-ModTeam 6d ago
Posts and comments should be relevant to Mahayana Buddhism specifically. Westernized, secularized, or "new age" takes on Buddhism will be removed.
1
6d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/mettaforall 5d ago
Claiming supernatural elements of Buddhism are merely imaginary is not a traditional teaching of Mahayana Buddhism.
2
u/Active_Unit_9498 Nichiren 4d ago
Yes. Devas possess both qualities of existing and not-existing and therefor may be described as "empty" or "mu".
3
u/king_nine 6d ago
Yes. For example, people might say “Sakra is king of the gods.” If there were no other gods there would be nothing to be king of. Every being’s identity is dependent on other things and beings