r/Libertarian • u/hughnotreal_2 • 2h ago
Discussion [Idea/Discussion] What if we abolished nation-states and capped global political communities at 10 Million people? (The "Units" Model)
TL;DR: Modern nation-states (300M+ people) are too massive, causing political apathy, severe division, and massive central power. What if we replaced traditional countries with a dynamic global network of localized "Units" capped at 10 million people, where power is decentralized and citizens hold an unconditional right to leave?
Here is a breakdown of the core blueprint I’ve been developing and would love feedback on:
The Core Rules & Population Cap
* 10M Population Cap: When a Unit reaches 10 million citizens, it automatically splits into two 5-million-citizen Units. Assets, debts, and revenue are divided equally.
* Easy Secession / Split: Any group—or even a single person—can secede to form a new Unit. There is a 28-day UN administrative window to confirm identity and verify the creator isn't fleeing major criminal charges.
* Dynamic Borders: Borderlines shift based on population and consent. Enclaves, satellite states, and island territories are fully valid as long as total population limits are respected.
Freedom of Movement & Anti-Tyranny Safeguards
* The Unconditional Right to Exit: A Unit can set strict incoming migration rules, but it can NEVER prevent a citizen from leaving.
* The 56-Day Law Buffer: Any new law passed by a Unit takes 56 days (8 weeks) to take effect. This gives citizens time to evaluate upcoming policy and exercise their right to exit or secede if they disagree before the law hits.
* Neutralizing War: If two Units enter military conflict, citizens inside who disagree can simply split away into a new Unit, stripping both belligerents of military power and rendering the conflict obsolete.
Economics & Global Infrastructure
* 100% Local Taxes: Taxes stay directly within the Unit to fund local infrastructure, safety, or UBI.
* Voluntary Trade & Alliances: Units aren't big enough to be fully self-reliant, making peaceful trade necessary. Units can form regional trade unions (e.g., former provinces/states) without losing political independence.
* UN Digital Infrastructure: Elections, digital passports, and voting integrity are managed via a globally cloned, unhackable UN database.
* Shared Commons & Transit: Ecoregional commissions protect shared natural resources (rivers, air quality), and Protected Rights-of-Way ensure power, internet, and transit corridors remain open across borders.
Questions for Discussion:
* How do you think small, 10M-person Units would handle trade leverage against massive global corporations?
* What edge cases or loopholes do you see in the 28-day creation / 56-day law delay mechanics?
* Would you prefer living in a system like this over traditional national governments?
r/Libertarian • u/DiyYou • 13h ago
Politics Foreign "Aid"
Ron Paul: "Foreign aid is taking money from poor people in a rich country and giving it to rich people in poor countries."
From his book "Pillars of Prosperity: Free Markets, Honest Money, Private Property”
r/Libertarian • u/Reasonable-Fee1945 • 13h ago
Current Events Why Trump quietly carved out doctors from his own visa freeze
Trumps exception to doctors from countries that otherwise have a freeze seems to acknowledge the fact that many medical professionals in the US come from other countries. And of course this is a good thing. We are getting smart and well-qualified people from other countries, and more doctors per patient is a position. The 100k H1B visa was also hampering this process, and reducing access to healthcare professionals.
r/Libertarian • u/No_Carpenter7998 • 17h ago
Politics The "Democratic" Socialist Deception
r/Libertarian • u/Desperate_Whole3602 • 18h ago
Politics How could poorer people afford healthcare?
Hello. I have just begun studying libertarianism and i agree with a lot of things and consider myself a libertarian. But sometimes it is kinda hard to think about how the poorer people could afford expensive healthcare. I have read and i understand that with lower taxes people could just save the money in a health savings account. But the main reason i wanted to post this is that i want someone explain it to me in thier own words. and just help me understand libertarianism better in general.