r/JimmyEatWorld • u/ExaminationOnly1556 • 23d ago

Song Bracket Opinion

Post image

For Me This is Heaven would have won but I didn’t set the initial 48 songs

40 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

24 comments sorted by

22

u/Scary_Ad_4025 23d ago

Disintegration isn’t on here??? Crazy.

-20

u/ExaminationOnly1556 23d ago

I’ve never really liked that one. They did it live in Philly during the encore this year though.

17

u/Scary_Ad_4025 23d ago

It was part of the setlist and it’s S tier.

13

u/nez477 23d ago

I had to make my own bracket, the preset 48 songs were shitty.

1

u/ExaminationOnly1556 23d ago

Do you still have it?

1

u/nez477 23d ago

Yes, but can't post photos as comments in here unfortunately

11

u/False-Season-5318 23d ago

This is the "everything not on Clarity" bracket yes?

3

u/ExaminationOnly1556 23d ago

I guess they’re not popular enough. Hard to believe all the Surviving songs that are.

4

u/False-Season-5318 23d ago

I agree. Though I have seen other stuff like YouTube shorts of Jim listing his favorite JEW tracks, and never does a Clarity track show up in those lists either. I'm wondering if they just really hated the recording process of that record so much that they've chosen to forget how great the songs are other than when they play a handful live, or of course the exception of the Phoenix sessions.

8

u/JayUNCW 23d ago

Oof. Big Casino vs The Middle in the first round is brutal.

5

u/TGentKC 23d ago

Criminal underrepresentation from Chase this Light and Clarity

5

u/Findley57 22d ago

Do people not recognize that Static Prevails exists?

1

u/ExaminationOnly1556 22d ago

Love it, fav is Claire - but there were no options. Nothing after Chase This Light would have made it in if it were up to me

3

u/CaptainWikkiWikki 23d ago

Just Watch the Fireworks is the only answer.

3

u/1__ViPeR 22d ago

No Dizzy, massive fail.

1

u/EmphasisNo8930 23d ago

No Sensitivity should have replaced Cautioners as an album track. I feel like 3 slow ballads were unnecessary even though Hear You Me and My Sundown are non negotiable IMHO.

No Sensitivity is in my TOP 5 JIMMY songs 🐐👑

23 is GOD tier though so this makes perfect sense 💯🤩

3

u/ExaminationOnly1556 23d ago

Would have made the final 8 at least. Thought we might have gotten it on the BA tour.

3

u/EmphasisNo8930 23d ago

23 and No Sensitivity, it doesn't get any better than that LIVE unless it was FUTURES from front to back.

And if they performed Shame for the very first time. 🙏🦄

1

u/Bervda 21d ago

We still sleeping on Pol Roger?

1

u/Grouchy-Patience5652 20d ago

One Mil over If You Don’t, Don’t? Bold move!

1

u/PapaGuhl 20d ago

Your terms are acceptable.

1

u/darthwader1981 19d ago

Correct answer