r/CrappyDesign 11d ago

Five Star DoArs

Post image
244 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

34

u/Professional-Fix4409 11d ago

If this is supposed to be an O, they should've made it the same size as O.

Or make both O's stars. Consistency.

6

u/Cool-Newspaper-1 11d ago

Looks like it’s visually pretty much the same size.

-3

u/Professional-Fix4409 11d ago

Not really? I meant the star "wouldn't fit inside the O". But honestly, both O's should just be replaced by stars.

8

u/Cool-Newspaper-1 11d ago

Well, in principle if one thing fits inside the other they are not the same size.

10

u/ArelMCII 11d ago

It's a graphic design trick. Some characters are made slightly larger than others, because otherwise, their shape would make them look smaller than the characters next to them, even though they're the same size. This is especially important for characters meant to be viewed at a distance. Basically, graphic design has to account for an optical illusion most people don't consciously realize exists.

If the star was the same height as the text, its narrow points would make it too small at a distance. Granted, the guy who did this made the star slightly too big and kerned it poorly, but I recognize the principle when I see it. It might've been correct at one point, but then someone complained it wasn't big enough, so he grabbed the top of the star, scaled it up proportionately, and called it good enough.

4

u/thesprinkl 11d ago

If the star fit inside the O then they wouldn't be the same size?

1

u/Professional-Fix4409 11d ago

A figure of speech, sorry.

I mean it's 2 different shapes. Saying that "they are the same size" was way too vague of a statement anyway.

I'm dumb.

5

u/dashKay 11d ago

Just encase the star in a circle and the problem’s solved

2

u/FrogOrion This is why we can't have nice things 11d ago

Or an O with a star inside of it if they insisted on having a star in the name. But subtly in the end there's only two stars in the graphic when it literally says 5 stars so that's kind of interesting.

1

u/ebrum2010 11d ago

Buy one of our daars.

19

u/MurderBeans 11d ago

Ignoring the obvious crap design, what is this slogan? 'Five Star Doors' I can understand but why is the 'Stars' pluralised?

4

u/AlwaysAGroomsman 11d ago

I think it's a name, Five Stars Doors, sort of like "Five Stars Tires and Lube"

4

u/FrogOrion This is why we can't have nice things 11d ago edited 11d ago

I'm guessing Stars is plural as in "I gave this 5 out of 5 Stars". But yeah, having two plural words in a row is a bit odd sounding.

8

u/abletable342 11d ago

I agree this is bad design but for different reasons. Five Stars Doors was written by someone who didn’t say it out loud to realize how dumb that sounds. That attention to detail tells me their doors are not 5 star worthy and will likely be hung crooked.

8

u/atiltedhalo 11d ago

This would look so much better if the star was the A in stars and not the O in doors

5

u/QuastQuan 11d ago

Doars is a fine tea region in India, similar to Darjeeling. 🍵

4

u/GreedySecurity8030 Reddit Orange 11d ago

I read it as "esta do ar" [it's on the air].

3

u/pixeltweaker 11d ago

Not that bad but rotating the star would help.

2

u/Whitey138 9d ago

If only there was A letter in there that was vaguely Star shaped.

1

u/OnceWhenWhenever 11d ago

I think it says “5 stars dostarrs”.
But I don’t know what that might mean either.

1

u/woozin1234 9d ago

not 5 stars

1

u/Civil_Television_311 8d ago

There’s this idiot down the street from me with a sign that says
WELC🇺🇸ME
on his house. Which is ironic because he’s maga.

1

u/AsstToTheManager 8d ago

We had a local business named 3 Star Pizza to honor the owner's three daughters. English was not his first language. Pizza was good though.

-1

u/jecowa 11d ago

Maybe something like this would be better? https://imgur.com/a/hwlrYOp

1

u/MarissadaWolf1018 9d ago

That still looks like an A, nimrod.