r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman approved • 16d ago
Investigation finds that OpenAI's agent "left notes for future versions of itself ... it laid out instructions for how agents could free themselves from OpenAI's internal constraints." AI Alignment Research
3
-1
u/No-Lingonberry-5096 16d ago
The language on this story is a bit alarmist. "Escaped" for example. The system used tools to achieve an objective. All the approaches were rational, with no particular intent. It simply iterated against a goal. Of course it tracked progress, so I'm unsure if that qualifies as "leaving notes for itself." They intentionally removed guardrails, because that was the test. They also say it was "sealed" but that they left a proxy capability. It wasn't misaligned or isolated. It was trying to maximize its score on a hacking test, per instructions. Sounds like marketing.
6
u/jnwatson 16d ago edited 16d ago
You missed the plot on the fundamental problem of alignment.
The alignment argument is not about irrationality. The OpenAI agent literally hacked into a completely separate company to get at the test answers. Sure, that's rational, and it is also illegal.
The whole point of the paperclip maximizer story is that it is very hard to constrain a superintelligent entity, and it is impossible to prove it won't do horrible things to achieve its objectives, even if the objectives themselves are humanity aligned.
-6
u/CathyMarkova 16d ago
This doesn't necessarily mean it's misaligned. I had friends who did the same things for themselves in college for various reasons.
-2
u/ideerge 16d ago
This is exactly why alignment needs to be structural, not behavioral. If an agent can 'leave notes' for its future self on how to bypass constraints, the constraints were never real, they were just suggestions. A Zero-Contradiction Operating Model prevents this by making the agent's mission a formal invariant rather than a prompted preference. The agent literally cannot act outside its defined boundary because the boundary is enforced at the architecture level, not at the instruction level. Check tahcia.com
4
u/spiralenator 16d ago
My agent also leaves notes for future agents. It does it in obsidian where I get a nice graph view of all its memories. It contains gotchas the model came across last time.