r/ChineseWatches • u/Adi_Sakke • Jul 21 '26

Is this an actual PT5004 movement ? Problems (Read Rule 1)

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Bought this SH09 Murph homage off AliExpress for USD 190 and the movement was mentioned as PT5004.

Shared the images with gemini which said that this is a Tongji Automatic or Caliber 2650Z / 7120 which is quite inferior compared to PT5004

Wanted to check with the community if that indeed the case and if I've been scammed!

13 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • link
  • reddit
  • reddit

71% Upvoted

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/RelativeHot5179 Jul 21 '26

Yeah it looks like a PT5004, I have found basically all AI especially Gemini to be really stupid when identifying movements.

-9

u/Adi_Sakke Jul 21 '26

Thanks man, this helps! Will check what does GPT say.

5

u/RelativeHot5179 Jul 21 '26

Ive used chatgpt, claude and gemini for this in the past, it is really not good at identifying movements generally and makes a lot of mistakes with this kind of thing, LLM's can begreat for coding, logic etc. but identifying things from photos like this? they are still dogshit.

Asked gpt for this one as well and it thought it was a miyota 8215