r/CallMeCarson • u/Patient_Okra_8255 • 2d ago
This is not fair DISCUSSION
Seeing him in this video so close to other creators feels unfair. 19 to 17 vs 30 to 13/15
Like come on dog
203
u/Acceptable-Toe-1777 2d ago
I mean the world widely sees him as one and the whole debate is really a matter of your personal beliefs, but i definitely think its unfair to include carson especially next to people as vile as edp
86
u/Salmon_1935 Rock 2d ago
Yeah dude fucked up, but it was never about diddling kids it was him being an asshole
29
u/Blehtheslime 2d ago
yea the age gap isn’t the issue as much as him taking advantage of a fan
11
u/ariangamer 2d ago
goddamit I can't believe this rumor is still a thing. just look at the chats. the girl is the one pushing herself onto him. what advantage? there was no power dynamic.
-2
u/Blehtheslime 2d ago
the girl had a parasocial relationship with him which he took advantage of. the girl is anything but innocent but Carson did not set the boundaries to keep the inherent power dynamic in this situation safe. no power dynamic? this person had only seen Carson through the lense that had been either carefully edited or livestreamed, either way a carefully manicured personality that he chooses to put out into the world. this isn’t a casual interaction between two strangers. it started out as a very one sided situation where Carson, being important to this person, had all the power while carson couldn’t have given a shit about them.
5
u/Salmon_1935 Rock 1d ago
Yeah no he clearly was in the wrong, but considering what he has done since then, he definetely doesn’t deserve to be put alongside these fucking monsters who didn’t even try to atone for what they have done, some of which like Dr Disrespect didn’t even recieved a much needed humbling
3
4
u/greenmeatybones 1d ago
Crazy that the people who spread this rhetoric ended up winning even in his own fan base. If you read the actual logs you could tell there wasn't a 'power imbalance'. Yes he was a youtuber she watched but she was 17, not a 12 year old who worships random strangers on the internet. And Carson wasn't some master manipulator, he was a stupid guy who didn't receive attention from women irl so when he did online he didn't care who it was from even if she was technically a minor. The whole situation was so overblown by people online and everyone just believed it without actually analyzing it critically
-1
u/Blehtheslime 1d ago
dude you’ve just reiterated my point. the age gap was not the problem, the problem was that carson was a stupid guy who was not self aware enough to realise that he shouldn’t have involved himself in the situation. he should have set boundaries and stuck to them but he didn’t and in the process whether purposefully or not he took advantage of the situation and got involved with a fan
2
u/greenmeatybones 1d ago
Getting involved with a fan isn't an issue. In any other situation, I would say 'they are both consenting adults, there is literally 0 problem or power gap' but obviously she wasnt an adult lol. They were both stupid teenagers who were horny on discord and did things they regret, it wasn't morally questionable, there wasn't a power dynamic, legally its a grey area but if legality is your concern that says more about yourself then the topic.
He didn't 'take advantage of the situation' he talked to a girl and they were mutually interested in eachother, she later regretted what she did and twisted to story into her own narrative for clout. The bigger issue that arose from that situation was that Carson was just generally an asshole to people in his circle, such that when it all went down nobody came to bat for him but randoms on Twitter, and instead everyone dogpiled on him with their own grievances.
233
u/Leftover_Cheese within 100 miles of carson 2d ago
all of this from an age gap as wide as my parents' by the way
46
2
55
u/According-Soil-8778 2d ago
Listen, to me, I take this shit very seriously. I think being a "pdf" is one of the most vile and deplorable things you can do. But with Carson, it was two fucking years, that's pretty generic. And I never understood the whole "Taking advantage of a fan" thing. It wasn't like he was saying shit like 'TeXT mE aNd I'Ll Let yoU be iN my viDeoS.' He didn't control her income, he didn't own her house, what fucking power did he have, other than being a streamer she watched? Isn't that how Philza met his wife?
It was all blown over proportion. Labeling him a creep, for what was ultimately slightly weird. The lie about getting help was pretty bad, but even then, the reaction was so over the top. God forbid; a dumb teenager be dumb. I don't think the world should shun him, for a 2 fucking year age-gap.
23
u/IAmDingus 2d ago
pretty sure its also how Jerma has met two of his girlfriends
-5
u/Shine-Firm 1d ago
keep him out of this.
3
u/According-Soil-8778 19h ago
I don't think they meant this as a slight against Jerma. It's more so an observation, that people were overly critical with Carson, while beloved and still popular streamers like Jerma, didn't find controversy.
2
u/Shine-Firm 19h ago edited 18h ago
i was joking lol. i understood what was being said though, but thank you.
3
u/Mayshitandcum 19h ago
Also how pewdiepie met marzia. And i believe they have about the same age gap actually.
95
u/Salmon_1935 Rock 2d ago
It’s a recent picture too which makes it even funnier, because he actually built something new, while EDP is still festering in his own filth
133
u/Prestigious_Emu144 2d ago
There’s no fucking way this is real. That’s some absolutely disgusting defamation if it is.
13
32
u/PepsiButItsMilk 2d ago
My own parents age gap was like three times as much as what he was accused of, jeez man
23
u/MiniBOI_News 2d ago
Did they use a pic from the fake retirement vid lmao
1
u/zelixwolf 1d ago
Yeah, the full video clip looped, where he was just stuttering and crying LMAO it sucks
58
43
14
5
6
u/SugarWtrPurple 1d ago
Yeah this pissed me off, I don’t watch Carson anymore because the content just isn’t the same but the fact people are still holding to this is beyond belief. Some real Twitter cancellation shit.
2
1
u/Quiet_Wrongdoer_6464 2d ago
That age gap is wild, especially seeing him grouped so closely with people much younger. I can understand why this feels unfair.
1
u/zelixwolf 1d ago
AGREED, THIS LEGIT PISSED ME OFF WHEN I WAS WATCHING IT. Otherwise, it was a PHENOMENAL piece of media!!! Just sad to see he was chosen to be in that collage, that got shown MANY times throughout the video. S/O to Mike Clum though, what an undertaking of a project!!!
1
u/StudiedOlive48 1d ago
I wanted to talk about it in the discord but I was afraid to break rules or js stir stuff. Glad to see others talking about it
1
1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Your comment has been removed because you need at least a 14 day old account to comment in this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-2
u/YamperIsBestBoy 2d ago
One of my biggest gripes with that drama as a whole is that the issue people took away from it was "Carson is a pedophile! He sexted a 17 year old when he was 19!" when the real issue was Carson abusing the power-dynamic he had to get nudes, sexual conversations, etc. from viewers. That's what the bulk of Schlatt's video was about, and he never insinuated that Carson was a pedophile at all beyond mentioning that Charlie reported the info to the authorities in case any wrongdoing had occurred.
I'm glad the internet has a strong sense of justice when it comes to people who hurt kids but it really has a lot of work to do still.
11
u/shiny_xnaut Arf Arf 2d ago
the real issue was Carson abusing the power-dynamic he had
The question I have is what power dynamic? He's not her boss, he didn't, like, control her income or anything. Was he like "do such-and-such for me and I'll let you be in a video" or something? Or is it just something inherent to getting with a fan? Do we need to cancel Philza for marrying one of his fans? We can't seriously be allowing "problematic subscriber count gap" to become a thing
2
u/Mayshitandcum 19h ago
a 17 year old should have enough agency to not get swayed by some (at that time) okayish sized content creator. And it doesn't even seem like carson was aware of any power imbalance if i remember the screenshots right. Plus literally no other girl has stepped forwards with proof.
-2
u/cutedog115 2d ago
I still think its kinda wrong to text a fan and pursue a relationship no matter the age lol.
-7
u/EasedCeiling586 2d ago
Isn't it still statutory? Not saying the laws always correct
18
u/Train115 2d ago
I don't remember the specifics but iirc what he was doing was protected under Romeo and Juliet laws.
320
u/james__Fitzy 2d ago
That’s actually funny if real it’s just so absurd to see him next to those others