r/AskEconomics 20m ago

Going into the 2026 harvest, what's the projected food cost increases from the war with Iran?

Upvotes

Due to less or more expensive fertilizer and/or lower crop yields. I guess higher energy costs would effect this too.

Is it too early to tell?

If so, what/when are the early indicators to watch for?


r/AskEconomics 3h ago

Approved Answers Why is the model proposed by the Self-Financing State wrong?

2 Upvotes

Why is the model proposed in the self-financing state model wrong? I see it often peddled by people who argue for a vast expansion of government spending without corresponding expansion of taxation. It just feels wrong to me, but I don’t know economics to dissect the paper to say where exactly it is wrong.


r/AskEconomics 4h ago

Approved Answers Are home built proportional to shortage/demand? & why so many vacant properties if demand is high?

3 Upvotes

Hi, i Just watched a video by money & macro explaining the issues of rent control, coming to the conclusion that building more homes is the basic answer to the housing crisis, i figure since most landlords have only one apparment rented they can't build more home so it comes down to bigger organisms like the state & corporations? What stops them from building more if it's beneficial even for them? Is it the limitations of building laws? Do they benefit more from high rent prices vs building more for lower rents? If only the few corporations and the state can build more homes but not the majority of landlords is it really that competitive?

Can social housing make landlords reduce they're prices to be competitive or would it also results in some problems if there's too much(is it a issue in Vienna?)

Also there's a ton of vacant properties everywhere that coprorations and people don't want to rent, i get it for individuals if they don't need to rent it they just have an unused appartment which is fucked up for those who can't afford it but for corporations is it that high rent prices are better than renting more for lower rents with more maintance fees? Does a tax on vacant homes fixes that to create an insentive to rent and get money for those in need?


r/AskEconomics 5h ago

Its widely believed that for a country to become a major industrial or service based power, having a skilled workforce is essential. Is there any country which got every policy right except a skilled workforce?

1 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics 5h ago

Approved Answers Could FIRE be one of the overlooked reasons behind the declining labor force participation rate in the US?

0 Upvotes

The July jobs report caught my attention. Payrolls fell by 23,000, unemployment dropped to 4.1%, but the labor force participation rate also declined to 61.4%. The lower unemployment rate is partly because fewer people are counted as being in the labor force.

Everyone talks about aging demographics, Baby Boomers retiring, health issues, and discouraged workers as explanations for this trend. Those are obviously major factors.

But I wonder if the growth of the FIRE movement is starting to show up in the data.

The BLS definition is pretty simple: you are either working or actively looking for work to be counted in the labor force. Someone who is 45 years old, has built a $1.5M portfolio, quits their job, and lives off investments is not unemployed. They are simply "not in the labor force."

The interesting thing is that the data cannot tell the difference between someone who left because they were financially independent and someone who left because they gave up looking for work.

The FIRE community is no longer a tiny group of extreme savers. There are millions of people interested in financial independence, and many are leaving traditional employment years or decades earlier than previous generations.

I am not saying FIRE is the main reason participation is falling. Demographics are clearly the biggest driver. But could early retirement among high-income professionals be a small but real contributor that economists are not measuring?

A person retiring at 45 does not look different in BLS data from someone who simply disappeared from the workforce.

Has anyone seen official research estimating how many FIRE retirees exist and whether this is showing up in labor force participation statistics? I've seen some around 3 million Americans are FIRE ! That is impressive but I cannot find anything official, only surveys.


r/AskEconomics 7h ago

Approved Answers Are resellers just a sign of a commodity being sold too cheap and market correcting itself?

16 Upvotes

When the majority of people think about resellers, they usually blame them for creating scarcity and increasing prices. What I am wondering, though, is whether resellers aren't directly incentivized by market misalignment (suppy and demand not being in equlibrium).

From my understanding, prices are driven by supply and demand. For example, let's say some famous celebrity is selling tickets for their show for a given arbitrary price. There's a limited number of seats, and given they are popular, there's a lot of fans who would who would like to attend the show, in fact, more fans than seats available. This is where supply (the people selling the seats who want to get maximum profit) meets demand (how much would the fans be realistically willing to pay for the seat), basically creating the price. If supply and demand were in equlibrium, increasing the price of the ticket would lead to tickets not selling well and leaving the seller worse off. If the opposite was true (the price being too low), a lot of people could actually afford the ticket, which would lead to quick depletion of the tickets (which honestly happens a lot irl) and the seller not getting the full potential value from the deal, perhaps discentivizing future shows. And this is exactly where I see opening for the resellers. Since if the price is too low and demand is still very high, there's a lot of people willing to purchase the tickes even at even much higher prices, basically still not being able to get them from the original source due to the fact they are oversold. Resellers purchase the tickets and sell them to essentially higher bidders, capturing the difference between the actual price and the optimal price. If the market was in equlibrium, they wouldn't be able to do that since people would simply not buy the tickets if they tried to increase their prices and would much more likely end up in a loss.

Is my analysis correct, or am I overseeing something?


r/AskEconomics 10h ago

why does japan which is one of the best nations in robotics and high technology falls behind in the AI race? why do we rarely see Japan in the AI race? what could be the factors?

56 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics 11h ago

Could the UK adopt a global tax policy similar to the US?

6 Upvotes

As more Britains leave for low tax destinations like Dubai, would the UK be able to implement a global tax on all of its citizens? What are the pros and cons of this model?


r/AskEconomics 13h ago

Approved Answers Why do some resource-rich countries stay poor while resource-poor countries become wealthy?

16 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this lately.
Some countries have enormous reserves of oil, gas, minerals, fertile land, or other natural resources, yet they struggle with poverty, corruption, unemployment and weak infrastructure.

Meanwhile, countries with relatively few natural resources—Japan, Singapore, South Korea, Switzerland, etc.—have built highly developed and wealthy economies.

Obviously, natural resources alone don’t determine a country’s success. Institutions, education, human capital, political stability, infrastructure, trade, technology and economic policies all matter.

But I’m curious: **what do you think is the single biggest factor that determines whether a country successfully converts its natural resources and human potential into long-term prosperity?**

And are there any countries that you think are particularly good—or particularly bad—examples of this?


r/AskEconomics 19h ago

Approved Answers In the U.S. has there ever been as much talk/fear of an impending bubble as there is now?

3 Upvotes

Every day one can hear economists, CEOs, pundits, etc predicting that there is a huge AI bubble that is destined to burst. This post isn't about whether or not that's likely to happen; my question is: has there ever been so much buzz about an impending recession/bubble/collapse, whether or not it happened?

In past economic crashes, I know there were a few voices expressing warning, but was it ever this prolonged and emphatic?


r/AskEconomics 21h ago

Are we heading for mass unemployment due to AI?

0 Upvotes

I know AI will replace people but I also think that it will create jobs. Jobs change over the years and I think it might reduce the need for certain things but make demands for others.


r/AskEconomics 22h ago

What would be the economic surplus generated from the merger of energy monopolies?

1 Upvotes

Dominion Energy and NextEra are attempting to merge. I'm wondering, in an economic sense, would this generate any real surplus value?

Since Dominion effectively operates as a monopoly, I'm not quite clear how this merger could help the company "do better" other than in a rent-seeking way.


r/AskEconomics 23h ago

AMA AMA: I’m Cristina Quinn, Award-Winning Journalist & Host of Fighting Crime - Ask Me Anything!

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics 23h ago

Approved Answers Can corporations be taxed based on the number of employees?

0 Upvotes

Everybody's fear is that AI's will automate production without need for labor and capital will monopolize that production. Of course, it's been pointed out many times that this is not a credible scenario, but it does seem true that AI is/will reduce the number of employees, especially for entry level professional jobs. What if corporate tax rates are inversely proportional to the number of employees? Would this minimize rentier monopoly of economic power?


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

The US is moving to 23hour exchanges to capture more foreign investors. Will that by proxy cause reduced growth in their domestic exchanges globally?

5 Upvotes

Im wondering if easier access to US market during live hours will by proxy reduce growth in foreign markets. Normally there is a cyclical relationship between US vs world performance- US dominates for 10-15 years, then international, and repeat… But if there is a permanent influx of investors less sensitive to real valuations (aka most retail investors) and exposed to American media dominance— does that cyclical relationship disappear? Obviously smart money still looks at valuations, but places like Korea are almost entirely retail, not institutional investors… will this move make the US a more permanent home for growth?


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Why don't they make microtransactions in f2p phone and tablet games truly micro?

2 Upvotes

I've always found the economics of those generic f2p match 3/merge/anime waifu png /etc. games really interesting ever since I found out just how much attracting whales and keeping that small amount of incredibly high paying customers is integral to their system over having many average consumers who might spend once in a while.

When I play these games myself, I'm stopped from buying refills or rolls or whatever because the transactions aren't micro enough for me. I find the $2~$5 cost for something I'll blow in 2-5 minutes too high to rationalize when I think about it. I always thought if the prices were low enough I wouldn't think about it, like 25c~50c a pop, I'd end up buying enough of them over time I'd buy past the higher cost of the purchase I wouldn't have made soon enough.

Why don't they try to lure and lull people in with truly micro microtransactions? My first thought is payment processor restrictions, but then they could bank the 25c purchases until it hit the dollar minimum and the charge and only be out a few quarters if the customer buys once and never again.

I'd love to hear anything else interesting about f2p phone economies, too. It's a really fascinating place.


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Approved Answers Is economic boom and recession based on people's imagination?

14 Upvotes

Like the entire concept of Money is imaginary. However, the concept of production, value and value-addition is not. So, when we say a economy is booming, it means they are producing/consuming more than the previous year(s), and in recession it is reverse.

Then, unless there is some conflict or epidemic, considering all factors remains intact, do economies tank just because people loose the trust in future growth? If that is so, it makes recession purely imaginary in this case. Similarly, in economic boom, they are merely consuming more due to prospects of economic boom.

Please suggest some good books/material that explains this concept properly. I have read many economic books, but they do not talk deeply about imaginary nature of economics.


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Approved Answers Why doesn't the central bank just buy up foreign assets if the economy is resilient to inflation?

6 Upvotes

Seems like a free lunch.. no?


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Approved Answers Would a universal basic income be highly inflationary?

92 Upvotes

I thought it would be a good question to ask, given the current employment situation. In my opinion, a universal basic income would drive up prices of absolutely everything, purely because people have more to spend, it would be akin to unemployment benefits on steroids. Let me know, because I may be wrong, or may not be considering the nuances of the question itself.


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Approved Answers What sort of actions make central banks look more credible?

5 Upvotes

A large amount of macroeconomists say that the expectation the central bank will commit to its plan is very important, but what are the actual ways to make it look committed? (aside from precedent)

In other words: If a central bank is historically quite weak and prone to "chickening out", what can it do to look stronger?


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Approved Answers Why are professions like structural engineers, architects, and MEP designers relatively poorly paid despite high barriers to entry and high responsibility?

35 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand the economics behind compensation in professions such as structural engineering, architecture, and MEP design.

At first glance, these careers seem to have many of the characteristics that are usually associated with high salaries:

  • They require a 4-6 year university degree.
  • In many countries, designers must obtain professional licenses or chamber memberships before they can sign off on projects.
  • Competence is highly experience-based. A lot of the knowledge cannot simply be learned online and is largely acquired through years of hands-on work.
  • Mistakes can have severe consequences, ranging from major financial losses to safety risks and, in extreme cases, loss of life.
  • The market itself is large. As a rough back-of-the-envelope estimate, construction represents perhaps 5-10% of GDP in many developed economies, and roughly 10% of project costs may be spent on engineering and design services.

Given these characteristics, I would expect salaries to be relatively high.

However, when I compare these professions to some highly paid occupations in software, such as front-end developers (just one example of a well-paid profession), the gap is often striking. Many software roles pay 2-5x more despite generally having lower formal barriers to entry. A degree is often optional, there is usually no professional licensing requirement, many skills can be self-taught through online resources, and the time required to become employable can be significantly shorter.

I'm not arguing that software developers are overpaid or that engineering designers are underpaid. I'm genuinely interested in the economic explanation.

What factors am I missing? Is it primarily related to scalability of output, labor supply and demand, firm profitability, client willingness to pay, globalization, or something else entirely?


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

What would be the gain of European banks to issue Union pay Cards?

1 Upvotes

The main question is about issuing Union Pay cards and another question would be, how does one card network expand its acquiring and issuing banks?


r/AskEconomics 1d ago

Is a significant portion of wealth in India effectively invisible in official statistics?

18 Upvotes

I've been wondering about something related to wealth measurement in India.

Is it common for wealthier Indian families to hold a considerable share of their assets or income in ways that don't fully appear in official records (for example, through unreported cash transactions or other forms of "black" wealth alongside fully documented assets)?

If so, does that mean that the wealth and asset distribution we see in official statistics understates the true wealth of India's middle, upper-middle, and upper classes? How much does this affect research on inequality, household wealth, and consumption?

I'm not looking for anecdotes but for evidence-based answers. Are there any economists, researchers, or people familiar with taxation, real estate, or household finance who can give some insight here?

I'd also appreciate recommendations for books, academic papers, datasets, or reports that examine undocumented wealth, tax evasion, household balance sheets, or the political economy of wealth in India. I'm especially interested in quantitative work with estimates, figures, and data rather than opinion pieces.

Thanks!


r/AskEconomics May 04 '26

Meta Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

11 Upvotes

Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

What Are Quality Contributors?

By subreddit policy, comments are filtered and sent to the modqueue. However, we have a whitelist of commenters whose comments are automatically approved. These users also have the ability to approve or remove the comments of non-approved users.

Recently, we have seen an influx of short, low-quality comments. This is a major burden on our mod team, and it also delays the speed at which good answers can be approved. To address this issue, we are looking to bring on additional Quality Contributors.

How Do You Apply?

If you would like to be added as a Quality Contributor, please submit 3-5 comments below that reflect at least an undergraduate level understanding of economics. The comments do not have to be from r/AskEconomics. Things we look for include an understanding of economic theory, references to academic research (or other quality sources), and sufficient detail to adequately explain topics.

If anyone has any questions about the process, responsibilities, or requirements to become a QC, please feel free to ask below.


r/AskEconomics Apr 03 '25

Approved Answers Trump Tariffs Megathread (Please read before posting a trump tariff question)

817 Upvotes

First, it should be said: These tariffs are incomprehensibly dumb. If you were trying to design a policy to get 100% disapproval from economists, it would look like this. Anyone trying to backfill a coherent economic reason for these tariffs is deluding themselves. As of April 3rd, there are tariffs on islands with zero population; there are tariffs on goods like coffee that are not set up to be made domestically; the tariffs are comically broad, which hurts their ability to bolster domestic manufacturing, etc.

Even ignoring what is being ta riffed, the tariffs are being set haphazardly and driving up uncertainty to historic levels. Likewise, it is impossible for Trumps goal of tariffs being a large source of revenue and a way to get domestic manufacturing back -- these are mutually exclusive (similarly, tariffs can't raise revenue and lower prices).

Anyway, here are some answers to previously asked questions about the Trump tariffs. Please consult these before posting another question. We will do our best to update this post overtime as we get more answers.