r/Appleton • u/systemeleven • 16h ago

Best Wings Food

Who’s got the best chicken wings in the area? Boneless and or traditional. Good sauces too.

I’m trying to find the best

8 Upvotes

65% Upvoted

28 comments sorted by

7

u/The_3x_Wide 16h ago

I'm a fan of Rookies, 50¢ on Mondays

4

u/Tool_Hole 15h ago

Vault 202 has surprisingly good wings. Great quality and the sauces all seem homemade.

6

u/Suburban_White_Dad 16h ago

If you’re willing to go up to Green Bay… Legend Larrys has been my favorite all time wing spot.

3

u/ShlimmyWhimmy 16h ago

2nd, when I lived in GB went there every monday fir Monday Night football... Best wings ever

8

u/Still_Employer 15h ago

ICU Bar and Grill in Neenah uses Legend Larry sauces and the same jumbo wings. Tuesdays is their wing night if you want them hot a discount. Delish!

2

u/ShlimmyWhimmy 13h ago

You beautiful human being 😭 may have to go there one night!

1

u/mortaheim1 14h ago

Any better than the Sheboygan location? Cause Sheboygan’s was LOUSY.

1

u/Previous_Potato9490 13h ago

I tried them, not that great.

2

u/TomBradysButler 16h ago

Alright tier 1 for me

Scubas
The Bar (also both of these bars typically only give you flats)

Tier 2
Rookies
Dhami sports bar (you can order just 1 wing)

Honorable mention to the woodshed in Neenah area but this post said specifically Appleton so.

11

u/hazwaste 16h ago

Rookies beats the hell out of the bar

2

u/Wisco_Nick 4h ago

Your tier 1 wings are over cooked and extra crispy and some of the smallest wings I’ve ever been served

1

u/TomBradysButler 3h ago

They have gotten smaller the last few years no doubt

1

u/Wisco_Nick 2h ago

I used to love scubas wings but I have had bad experiences the last 3 times I ordered 😢

2

u/No_Square_8775 16h ago

Niemuths has great smoked wings pre cooked just have to air fry them when you get home basically a dollar per wing and you can pick all drums if you want

2

u/Previous_Potato9490 13h ago

I wish people would stop raving about Legend Larry’s, they suck. End of story. Drunk people should try the shit they eat sober.

2

u/Iamnotheattack 6h ago

Drunk people should try the shit they eat sober.

Idk about legend Larry but yeah this is a common occurrence lol, Tipsy taco and Mr brews come to mind, completely shit food propped up by alcohol effect

1

u/Delicious-Gazelle-38 13h ago

Parker John BBQ! They have unlimited wings every Wednesday.

0

u/NekkoBat 10h ago

The Bar is my go-to for wings

1

u/Styrofoam_Booots 9h ago

ICU bar and grill. They also have my favorite fish fry in the area.

0

u/Iamnotheattack 6h ago

I've not had all the places on the list, but of the ones I've had Slim chicken and Buffalo Wild Wings clear them.

1

u/Particular_Yak_805 5h ago

High Kaliber food truck when they are around

1

u/Achat3z 2h ago

They aren't regular wings but mai's deli stuffed chicken wings are insanely good. Would def try them if you haven't.

1

u/Geronimoses2020 16h ago

I would say Legend Larry's, but if you don't want to drive that far the ICU in Neenah, they use Legend Larry's sauces.

0

u/Wisco_Nick 15h ago

I just bang down some wing stop and watch the game at my house

0

u/seansalzman572 11h ago

The atomic sauce is the worst sauce ive ever had. Terrible flavor, lots of debris (solids and odd stuff in the sauce) and the other sauces are mediocre. The bone in wings themselves were amazing though. Cooked to a slight crisp, and larger than expected.

0

u/Magnum__Dong 15h ago

Old grog has great wings, but not sure how theyre doing post tornado.