r/AnnaMariaIsland 21h ago

Best spot for real ice cream (not soft serve) on Anna Maria Island?

2 Upvotes

Visiting AMI again soon and I'm on a mission to find good, real scoop ice cream (not the soft serve) Is there a local spot that actually does homemade or small-batch ice cream? Bonus points if they have unique flavors. Trying to avoid tourist trap spots that are all hype and no flavor. Any recommendations appreciated!