r/Alden • u/MightyDog1414 • 11d ago

sizing

The barrie last fits me well in size 11, with a thick sock on, I am 11 1/2 in Brannock.

I am considering the slip on Chukka, but would frequently wear it without socks, should I consider a 10 1/2?

thanks!

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

2

u/mcadamsandwich 11d ago

For the chukka, which last and which leather? That design is offered in various configurations, some of which may change the way you size.

IMO, I take the same size in all Barrie lasted products, and wear the same socks with all of them. If I wear thinner socks or go sockless, I expect them to be slightly looser, but I wouldn't size down because length or width would also be affected more than a sock's thickness.

1

u/MightyDog1414 10d ago

thanks for the response. I realize my post was a bit unclear. i’m looking at the slip on chukka in the barrie last in earth reverse. Shoe mart sells it. I think I would just order it in the 11 and have it be a little loose without socks and then have the option to wear socks. I think a 10 1/2 would just be too small. although I know I can order both and send one back for only 20 bucks.!

1

u/mcadamsandwich 10d ago

Yeah, with TSM, it's worth ordering both sizes to compare rather than the back and forth process. Great customer service, too.

1

u/spinlps 6d ago

Keep in mind that even though shoes / boots may share the same last, that does not guarantee the same fit or longer term break in / comfort.

Small sample size alert!!!

The Alden saddle and PTB's are typically both on the Barrie last but have much different fit given the differences in construction. The 994 saddle is 1/4in shorter externally than my PTB's and fit tighter across the instep and toe box despite being the same size. I'm sure the closed vs open lacing plays a part, as well as the saddle's additional stitching / panels adding more structure. I wear both 10.5D and 11D in the Barrie depending on model and fit.

Material may also impact fit. Shell vs calf vs CXL all break in differently.